Witch Flavor is a charming ice cream spot that casts a spell with its whimsical decor and enchanting atmosphere. Upon entering, you're greeted by the delightful aroma of brewing soup in a cauldron, adding to the mystical ambiance. The walls adorned with snapshots of patrons add a personal touch, though the tradition of immortalizing visitors in polaroids seems to have waned. Despite its magical charm, Witch Flavor remains first and foremost an ice cream haven. While I've yet to venture into their soup offerings, the tantalizing scent never fails to entice me. However, it's the ice cream that truly steals the show, with flavors that transport your taste buds to new heights. Among their bewitching selection, the Rocky Mountain Raspberry stands out as a personal favorite. The creamy texture and burst of raspberry flavor make each spoonful a delightful indulgence. Whether enjoyed in a cone, cup, or as part of a decadent sundae, this flavor never fails to satisfy. Beyond the delectable treats, Witch Flavor boasts friendly staff who add to the warm and inviting atmosphere. Their passion for their craft shines through in every scoop, ensuring each visit is a magical experience.
Lee Doran (Doranauctions)
Miss the Penn State creamery ice cream but it's still good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Avtor aka Thor B
If you are an ice cream snob like my brother is, you will enjoy this place. He makes us come here every time we are in town because of how unique the shop is. Lots of crazy flavors that draw you in and make you want to come back and try.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
gcrews412
The cutest ice cream shop ever !! And def the best ice cream ever! The owner and employees are always so sweet and awesome.. They also serve soup In the cold months and every soup is amazing ! Milkshakes are 10/10 as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Janette Cauthen
Delicious ice cream and cute atmosphere. Tables outside to eat at.
gary white
Ice cream isn't very good. Flavors are very bland and the consistency is very hard like cheap store bought ice cream. You're better off going to Katie's corner, Bruster's ice cream.
Jim Valenti
This is simply a great small town ice cream shop. The owner clearly puts a lot of care and love into it, both the ice cream and the shop itself.
Aryl Eel
For all you Coffee-Lovers "Witches brew coffee" is for you!Wonderful place
Jim and Kristen Sands
What a delightful little shop! I love the whimsical theme, the staff member was friendly and helpful, and the ice cream (Witch's Brew Coffee) was delicious!
Really good locally owned ice cream shop in Beaver. My son and I stopped in today. He has the super hero, and I had the grasshopper pie. Both were great!
Stephen Metz
Staff is super friendly and polite, the store's atmosphere is absolutely amazing, and the root beer floats are fantastic
Gavin Williams
Due to the phenomenal service+atmosphere+great ice cream that I received this past Wednesday, I decided to return this evening with my wife and 2 kids! Once again, amazing job Boden and Wyatt! (Had to use my very old google account to write this review because I couldn’t write another one with my daily email!)
Michelle Skirble
Super cute ice cream shop with a witchy feel.would definitely travel back there again
Lisa C.
Many choices of hand-dipped hard ice cream here! I ate two scoops--one toasted coconut & one witches brew, which is a fudge delicious coffee ice cream. The staff was amazing, very knowledgeable of ice cream flavors, and took good care of us. I could tell customer service was a priority here. The ice cream was fresh and tasted great. Unique flavors. The decor was fun! There are also tables and chairs available outside.
Great service and flavor options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Witch Flavor is a charming ice cream spot that casts a spell with its whimsical decor and enchanting atmosphere. Upon entering, you're greeted by the delightful aroma of brewing soup in a cauldron, adding to the mystical ambiance. The walls adorned with snapshots of patrons add a personal touch, though the tradition of immortalizing visitors in polaroids seems to have waned. Despite its magical charm, Witch Flavor remains first and foremost an ice cream haven. While I've yet to venture into their soup offerings, the tantalizing scent never fails to entice me. However, it's the ice cream that truly steals the show, with flavors that transport your taste buds to new heights. Among their bewitching selection, the Rocky Mountain Raspberry stands out as a personal favorite. The creamy texture and burst of raspberry flavor make each spoonful a delightful indulgence. Whether enjoyed in a cone, cup, or as part of a decadent sundae, this flavor never fails to satisfy. Beyond the delectable treats, Witch Flavor boasts friendly staff who add to the warm and inviting atmosphere. Their passion for their craft shines through in every scoop, ensuring each visit is a magical experience.
Miss the Penn State creamery ice cream but it's still good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
If you are an ice cream snob like my brother is, you will enjoy this place. He makes us come here every time we are in town because of how unique the shop is. Lots of crazy flavors that draw you in and make you want to come back and try.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The cutest ice cream shop ever !! And def the best ice cream ever! The owner and employees are always so sweet and awesome.. They also serve soup In the cold months and every soup is amazing ! Milkshakes are 10/10 as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious ice cream and cute atmosphere. Tables outside to eat at.
Ice cream isn't very good. Flavors are very bland and the consistency is very hard like cheap store bought ice cream. You're better off going to Katie's corner, Bruster's ice cream.
This is simply a great small town ice cream shop. The owner clearly puts a lot of care and love into it, both the ice cream and the shop itself.
For all you Coffee-Lovers "Witches brew coffee" is for you!Wonderful place
What a delightful little shop! I love the whimsical theme, the staff member was friendly and helpful, and the ice cream (Witch's Brew Coffee) was delicious!
Restaurantji Recommends
Really good locally owned ice cream shop in Beaver. My son and I stopped in today. He has the super hero, and I had the grasshopper pie. Both were great!
Staff is super friendly and polite, the store's atmosphere is absolutely amazing, and the root beer floats are fantastic
Due to the phenomenal service+atmosphere+great ice cream that I received this past Wednesday, I decided to return this evening with my wife and 2 kids! Once again, amazing job Boden and Wyatt! (Had to use my very old google account to write this review because I couldn’t write another one with my daily email!)
Super cute ice cream shop with a witchy feel.would definitely travel back there again
Many choices of hand-dipped hard ice cream here! I ate two scoops--one toasted coconut & one witches brew, which is a fudge delicious coffee ice cream. The staff was amazing, very knowledgeable of ice cream flavors, and took good care of us. I could tell customer service was a priority here. The ice cream was fresh and tasted great. Unique flavors. The decor was fun! There are also tables and chairs available outside.