New York Gyro

129 E 3rd St, Bethlehem
(844) 692-4976

Recent Reviews

Matt Ferrigno

I don't understand how so many people like this place?? Goto Johnny's Gyros a few minutes down the road. Blows this place away on gyros. The gyro sauce at this place is nasty. Definitely not homemade like Johnny's. Taste just like every other place that sells gyros.

Marv D.

Not going to say much because I'm not here to bash but what I will say is, this place didn't not represent at all what I'm used to being from nyc. I'm a known halal indulger lol from halal guys to adels famous halal to even no name food trucks. This goes to show you I always know where the good halal spots are. So I decided to look up some while out here in the Lehigh valley and only saw 2 spots. I went and ordered from this spot because it said NY, boy was I fooled the food didn't taste good let alone didn't even come close to the spots in nyc. There's more that I can say but ima leave this here. Just know if you from the city and know halal good you will be disappointed! P.s. they don't have lamb it's only beef

Kenneth Lukasik Jr.

Subpar employees didnt know prices unless computer register told them . Wouldn't just take my money and make the food. Then another employee had to come in and hit the power button to get register on. Food was subpar too , I thought a New York gyros place would be great . Highly disappointed. Won't be returning

Robert M.

Ordered 2 meals through Grubhub. They canceled one meal and made a refund. But what does the person who ordered the canceled meal eat? Should have made a substition or maybe called if they could. I tried to call them and went to voice-mail. Falafel was overcooked and oily. Will not return.

Chloe Castillo

Just got my order and it was so nasty. Soggy, the fries have seasoning dumped all over them to the point they are inedible, had to throw the whole order away. Big let down, trying to support local businesses but I was disgusted.

Stephano Z.

Good spot for quick food, good portions but very greasy and that's expected. Food coma after

Rudy Rivera

I love Gyros and ths particular place has a great variety and despite the quarantine it was a delight . The young lady behind the counter was attentive and had a good disposition. The food was delicious and I highly recommend this restaurant.

Sagar Y

The food was 'meh'. The rice was clumped up and tasteless, it looked it was microwaved or was cold at some point. The chicken was extremely dry and borderline stale. The taste of the entire platter as a whole was not that great. Even though it was warm, it didn't feel freshly made at all. Sauces are okay, fries are okay , but the rice and chicken were a big let down. I had bad experiences with the Allentown branch about 2 years ago, decided to give this another chance , extremely disappointed. Spoilt my appetite, left a bad taste (literally and figuratively). Never eating here again.Edit : forgot to mention that the chicken had a weird smell/taste to it , almost like some other meat (very gamey) . Honestly could have just been very off.

Sandra Jennings

A fav place for delicious gyros. I will be back with my coworkers.

Markus Jonez

store manager who treats Doordash and grubhub drivers like trash. Store manager (short chunky Spanish he/she). He’s very rude. I seen him curse at drivers out on multiple occasion. From what I hear, drivers don’t go to pickup food from that restaurant anymore to avoid dealing with that rude SOB. I stopped delivering their orders because of this reasons.

Jacob Smith

If you love halal guys or nyc street cart food, this is the closest you'll get to it in this area. Usually they give you a pretty filled platter.

Thomas Urban

I paid for a gyro and the disgusting worker started making it and was touching the food with his hands that were not clean. I just walked out. this place is very dirty.

Shane Ankrom

One of my favorites in the area! Absolutely delicious!

Ashlee Rose

First time here! Amazing food I was starving and it filled me right up

Mohidur Milton

Food quality isn’t the same as before, very rude employees. Never going back again.

Load More