Nannycakes Bakery

215 Main St, Orangeville
(570) 336-3099

Recent Reviews

Laurie Neyhard

Natalie baked cupcakes for my parents' anniversary party. They were beyond delicious and everyone absolutely loved them! Thank you Natalie for such wonderful flavors and for being willing to accommodate food allergies!

Justin Hess

They made me some french macaroons for a present to my gf...delicious

Emily Brophy

Beautiful job on our cupcakes and smash cake. I sent her a Pinterest idea and it turned out beautifully! Thank you so much! Trust me they tasted as delicious as they look!

Angel Hazen-Rupert

Got cookies for my daughter to share with her preschool class and they are so cute!

Erica H

Asked for very light colored cake color for a gender reveal as I’m trying to avoid consuming too much food coloring, and the nannycakes owner agreed. Got the cake and it was super bright color inside. I asked the nannycakes owner why it was so bright when she specifically agreed to make it light, and the reply was that she used gel coloring and that’s as light as she can make it. She should have explained that when I asked for light color. Otherwise the cake was cute.

Abigail Karkenny

Nannycakes Bakery is amazing! We asked Natalie to make cupcakes, cookies, and smore kits for our party celebrating our elopement. She was so flexible with our many requests, and so easy and friendly to work with. Everything was not only delicious but also adorable! The cookies made to look like our cats were a huge hit - we ran out completely and several guests said it was their favorite part of the party. Thank you, Natalie!!

Theresa Wirth

Natalie is truly so creative. Not only were the cookies beautiful but they tasted amazing. Everyone loved them! Very easy to communicate with and provides exceptional customer service.

Randy Espinal

Love everything! specially the Cookies they are my very very favorite. Thanks so much Nannycakes Bakery !

Lauren M.

Natalie was so great! My Previous baker fell through last minute for our wedding and I needed cake/cupcakes for 80 people. Natalie was very accommodating and gave us exactly what we wanted! It looked beautiful and tasted incredible! I highly recommend!! And I'm happy to support a small local business

Just M

Love everything! specially the Cookies they are my very very favorite. Thanks so much Nannycakes Bakery !

Erin Harrar

Thank you Natalie for the gorgeous cake and cupcakes!! Everything was excellent! Highly recommend!! Everything was delivered to our venue and set up beautifully! Can’t thank you enough!! Pleasure to work with you!??‍♀️??‍♂️???

Jessica Zeno Gallagher

The picture doesn’t do this cake justice at all. We contacted NannyCakes a month before our wedding and they came through for us. Great communication, attention to detail was 100%, easy and fast payments and very affordable. The cake not only looked beautiful but also tasted great. I would recommend this bakery to everyone I know.Thank you so much for providing my husband and I with the most beautiful wedding cake.

Jessica Zeno Gallagher

Thank you so much for the wedding cake you made for my husband and I. Our wedding was on August 21, 2021. We contacted this bakery one month before and she came through with a cake exactly as the picture I sent and it also tasted delicious. Thank you so much for making our wedding cake dreams come true. The Gallagher’s PS: Look how identical she made our cake to the picture we provided. The only interaction we had with NannyCakes was via fb messenger and she came through 100%.

Jessica Gallagher

Thank you so much for the wedding cake you made for my husband and I. Our wedding was on August 21, 2021. We contacted this bakery one month before and she came through with a cake exactly as the picture I sent and it also tasted delicious.

Jessica Zeno

The picture doesn’t do this cake justice at all. We contacted NannyCakes a month before our wedding and they came through for us. Great communication, attention to detail was 100%, easy and fast payments and very affordable. The cake not only looked beautiful but also tasted great. I would recommend this bakery to everyone I know.Thank you so much for providing my husband and I with the most beautiful wedding cake.

Load More