Kelly's Steak & Seafood

316 Boal Ave, Boalsburg
(814) 466-6251

Recent Reviews

Derec Markle

As always, the place is busy so just be patient. Don't be hard on the host stand because you can't get your favorite table. Great food, great service, great place.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sara Ventimiglia

Dark but pleasant lighting.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

toni miller

I used to love eating here until my husband and I split an entree salad which was already $18.00. When the bill arrived it had a split charge on it which was an additional $2.00. When I asked the server about this she said they have been doing this since Covid. Needless to say I will NOT be back. I was NOT informed of the fee before ordering and $20.00 for a salad is absolutely ridiculous!!!! I made sure to deduct that fee off my somewhat snippy servers tip. Way overpriced and by the way COVID IS OVER!!!!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Walt Fillmann

Had their NY Strip Oscar. Extremely flavorful. Hollandaise sauce with blue crab on top was delish. The steak itself, however, though marbled very well, had too much gristle to work through. Drawback of hollandaise sauce on top is that you can't see the gristle before you bite into it. Recommend they thoroughly trim the steak before serving it this way.Desert of Tiramisu was superb, creamy and exploding with flavor.Service was confusing and mistake prone. Items on three bills got mixed up, etc. Be patient with the staff.All and all, very friendly and cheery atmosphere!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Tiramisu, Mashed Potatoes, Salad, Blackened Salmon

Thomas Sroka

Great waitress named Jordan on Friday. Awesome food.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Xiaotian Li

This place is a bit of a disappointment. We thought it might be one of the better restaurants in town but not as good as we expected. We ordered the Cabernet scallops, fillet mignon, and halibut cheeks. The scallops were just salty, I couldn't taste any other flavor other than salt. It was a bit under cooked. (My husband got diarrhea afterwards) The steak was good but it was cold when it came and it was rare even though we ordered medium rare. We also got an appetizer the teriyaki steak was pretty good. The place is old and could use some upgrades.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 3

Michael Stuck

The service here is spectacular, staff is funny and expedient. Food is fantastic. Patrons here are friendly and almost a Cheers atmosphere.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

eddie n.

Another great meal at Kellys had the tuna dinner so delicious a well balanced, delicious dish . A friend, and I sat at the bar & bartender was professional, courteous, and attentive. Thank you !!

Danny Kay

This was our first time here. We came for our 15 year wedding anniversary. I didnt really know what to expect walking in here because I only took a quick look at the menu but all I can say is this is my new favorite restaurant in the area. To start off the evening we shared the Crab and Artichoke Dip. We both really enjoyed it. Rich , creamy, and exploding with flavor. For dinner I had a hard time deciding between a steak or seafood. I could have gotten the surf and turf but the Steampot was calling my name. It did not disapoint. It was amazing and took me back to eating steampots on the Carolina coast. My wife had a spcial. It was a horseradish encrusted steak. We shared our dinners with one another and that steak was amazing. I hope they are running that special next time we eat there. Dessert... well we went a few days after Halloween so we had our fill of sugar and skipped it but the Tiramisu looked delicious. Thanks for making our special night that more special.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mary C

Awesome restaurant to celebrate! Seafood was excellent, service great.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Crab and Artichoke Dip, Grilled Veggies, Tiramisu

Paul W.

Enjoyed the Food, service and the entire dining experience. Considering it is a "Steakhouse" , I thought the prices were reasonable.

Pia P.

Food is amazing and coming from NYC/Westchester, the prices are great for the quality of food. Appetizers are Fantastic (we tried all of them!) and the steak is delicious and cooked perfectly. Would highly recommend!

Claire Colebrook

I will not be going back. This was a regular for us, but a few days ago we booked a table for dinner. Our main course was set dow on the table while we were eating our first course. When I pointed this out I was told bluntly 'It's a football weekend and we are busy.' A football weekend is something you can plan for, and it's not a good excuse. We ate cold food.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Claire Colebrook

Do NOT go here. Food is average but service is unacceptable. Main course served while we were eating our first course. Ended up eating cold steak. AVOID.

claire c.

Totally ruined and expensive evening. The food is fine, but when your main course is slammed down on the table while you are eating the first course... and then you are told to suck it up because it's a football weekend and busy..... Go somewhere with a little more decorum.

Load More