Got a footlong meatball hoagie. Too bad it only had 6 meatballs on it and 5 inches worth of empty bun. Really awesome.....
Cindy S.
I am disappointed to say that our recent experience ordering from The Hoagie Shop was not what we expected. We ordered Tuna hoagies and they were edible. The tuna flavor was very overbearing and the amount of mayo made the hoagie inedible for me. Luckily, my husband was able to eat it the next day. Stay with their regular subs and you should be fine!
Joe Kummer
Love it! Great food! Great prices!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Regular Hoagie
Helen O.
The best ever! Has not changed in 65 years! So yummy! And a great price! Butler food at it's finest.
Dave Wolfe
The second you walk in it smells like cat urine, food is great, service is great but the smell is over Behring! Needs to be addressed
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 5
John Lefebvre
Stopped in for first time today. Phenomenal food!!! Super great price! I will be coming back for more. There's a reason why they have been in business since tue 50s. Order whole steak hoagie. Pulled pork cheese fries and a soda. All for 18 bucks. Yes please and thank you
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jodi S
ABSOLUTELY LOVE THIS PLACE!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tuna Salad
David M.
The smothered brisket sandwich was delicious . Just dot it with a little hotsauce takes over the top ! You can thank me later .
Blue Sapphire
It's written over the store in simple red letters: HOAGIE SHOP.This is exactly what you'll get, and they do it perfectly. Clean, fresh, and fair-priced. Friendly staff. Will definitely return!-Feb. 2023
Mikey8 S
This home town place has some of the best French fries in butler. The hoagies are always delicious! Try the hot sausage or the fish hoagie! They are huge!The small order of fries are big alone enough to fill you up! My wife and I finish off the fries before we even make it home!The prices are really reasonable and the place if local! Why not go here when you’re hungry! You don’t have to spend 30$ for hoagie meals for two like some of the chain hoagie shops and you are also supporting local businesses!Stop here, you won’t regret it! Highly recommended!
I love The Hoagie Shop. A Butler institution. Some don't like their deli meat cut a little thick and wrapped around the cheese and shoved down on top of the lettuce and tomato, but that's what the Hoagie Shop is. Great meatballs, hot fresh fries and plenty of them. You have to try the Brisket. It's so good that sometimes I crave it at night! Very tender and cooked just right. Their horseradish sauce makes this sandwich a 10! And, I'm pretty sure the 2 Hoagie Shop locations are keeping a rubber band factory in business. Lol
Harry W.
Always fresh, delicious and fast. Their capocollo hoagie rocks with spice oil. It's my favorite. Great for a picnic before a kayak paddle.
Got a footlong meatball hoagie. Too bad it only had 6 meatballs on it and 5 inches worth of empty bun. Really awesome.....
I am disappointed to say that our recent experience ordering from The Hoagie Shop was not what we expected. We ordered Tuna hoagies and they were edible. The tuna flavor was very overbearing and the amount of mayo made the hoagie inedible for me. Luckily, my husband was able to eat it the next day. Stay with their regular subs and you should be fine!
Love it! Great food! Great prices!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Regular Hoagie
The best ever! Has not changed in 65 years! So yummy! And a great price! Butler food at it's finest.
The second you walk in it smells like cat urine, food is great, service is great but the smell is over Behring! Needs to be addressed
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 5
Stopped in for first time today. Phenomenal food!!! Super great price! I will be coming back for more. There's a reason why they have been in business since tue 50s. Order whole steak hoagie. Pulled pork cheese fries and a soda. All for 18 bucks. Yes please and thank you
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
ABSOLUTELY LOVE THIS PLACE!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tuna Salad
The smothered brisket sandwich was delicious . Just dot it with a little hotsauce takes over the top ! You can thank me later .
It's written over the store in simple red letters: HOAGIE SHOP.This is exactly what you'll get, and they do it perfectly. Clean, fresh, and fair-priced. Friendly staff. Will definitely return!-Feb. 2023
This home town place has some of the best French fries in butler. The hoagies are always delicious! Try the hot sausage or the fish hoagie! They are huge!The small order of fries are big alone enough to fill you up! My wife and I finish off the fries before we even make it home!The prices are really reasonable and the place if local! Why not go here when you’re hungry! You don’t have to spend 30$ for hoagie meals for two like some of the chain hoagie shops and you are also supporting local businesses!Stop here, you won’t regret it! Highly recommended!
Restaurantji Recommends
Onion rings just tasted like fryer
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 5
Pulled Pork was excellent
Good service and good food at a reasonable price.
I love The Hoagie Shop. A Butler institution. Some don't like their deli meat cut a little thick and wrapped around the cheese and shoved down on top of the lettuce and tomato, but that's what the Hoagie Shop is. Great meatballs, hot fresh fries and plenty of them. You have to try the Brisket. It's so good that sometimes I crave it at night! Very tender and cooked just right. Their horseradish sauce makes this sandwich a 10! And, I'm pretty sure the 2 Hoagie Shop locations are keeping a rubber band factory in business. Lol
Always fresh, delicious and fast. Their capocollo hoagie rocks with spice oil. It's my favorite. Great for a picnic before a kayak paddle.