I had a recommendation from a friend that this was a spot for a good pizza. The Pie-rogi was excellent! Crispy crust, loaded with potatoes, full of flavor ? I will definitely be making this a regular stop!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pierogi Pizza
Dawn Kummer
Just found this little gem today!! Can’t believe I didn’t know it was in Butler!! Wonderful pie!! ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS ? I’ll definitely recommend this lil pizza place, and will definitely be back!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Big Bake on the Move
Walked in at 8:45pm they were closing… I got 5star service without a dirty look and I still apologized for coming in last minute but I had just gotten into town and just got my hotel room. I asked for a recommendation and the chef hooked me up very quickly I was in and out of the restaurant in about 7 minutes… super fresh food and the place was spotless! If you don’t know which pizza place to choose and are looking for “that” spot! This is it trust me! I got the chicken bacon ranch with a chef salad and a chocolate chip cookie and a bottled tea. 5stars all the way!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
EMILY THOMM
We tried third eye pies for the first time tonight and it was delicious. Fast & Friendly service and atmosphere. Good prices.Would highly recommend as they have all kinds of options for your pizzas.We got the Lord of the Brussels and the Mac Me So Happy pizzas. Simply delicious.
Gina Evans
My first time there, Butler location. Had a build your own, the crust is excellent and they do not skimp on the toppings. The employees were super friendly and explained everything to me as I have visual impairment and couldn’t really see the menu. Would definitely recommend and will be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Build Your Own
Jessi Barber
So fun & so good!Great fun experience. You can grab a pizza from the list or build your own down the line!!It's awesome & each time it's been delicious!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
chris rusch
Excellent food at a great price with a cool experience
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brandon Augustine
Got the general TSO and the American gothic. Both were absolutely fantastic. Will definitely be back. Definitely pizza with an awesome twist!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Chunk Red Velvet Cookie, Nashville Hottie
Jen Fester
The staff here is always so friendly! Not to mention the pizza and salads are delicious!!!
First time ordering from here. I had it delivered. This pizza is the best that I have had in Butler! I love the option of fresh sliced mozzarella! The red sauce is amazing (be sure to order extra on the side for dipping)! Definitely my go to from now on! YUM!
Anonymous 1
I came here 3 WEEKS AGO purchased a peice of cheesecake. I took one bite and it was SPOILED! I spit the bite into container and immediately after purchasing took the cheese cake back! Was told by the guy working he wasn't authorized to refund my money would I like something else. Ummm NO. Not one product in the case had a date. Who knows how long they've been in there (considering what I bought was spoiled) this will be my third week calling to get a refund I already returned which the guy threw away wrote my name and number down and HAVE YET TO HEAR BACK. CALLED LAST WEEK, A WOMAN WROTE MY NAME AND NUMBER DOWN AND STILL NO CALL RETURNED!!! When I call today and you tell me "oh, someone will call you back" I am reporting to the health department and the better business bureau!! This is ridiculous 6 plus dollars for a disgusting spoiled cheesecake I didn't even eat!!!!
Zach Landon
Service was quick and very pleasant. Answered every question I asked with detail and a smile. Now down to the main point. THE FOOD!!!!!..... Girlfriend got the Alfredo Chicken Pasta Bowl.. first reaction was OMG SO GOOD. Daughter got the Pierogie Pizza... she shared with her baby brother and the both scarfed it down like they would never be feed again. She couldn't stop talking about how amazing it was. Myself I got a make your own pizza. CHICKEN BACON MOZZARELLA CHEDDAR PINEAPPLE WITH BUTTER&GARLIC SAUCE WITH A DRIZZLE OF HOT HONEY ON TOP. Hands down the most fantastic and tasteful. Pizza I have had in 20 years! I recommend Third Eye Pie to everyone and anyone! BEST PIZZA IN BUTLER! HANDS DOWN! It's affordable and delicious and I say that with 100% Truth. I have eaten at over 100 Pizza shops through out the country. Third Eye Pie is my new #1!
No Thank you
I came here 3 WEEKS AGO purchased a peice of cheesecake. I took one bite and it was SPOILED! I spit the bite into container and immediately after purchasing took the cheese cake back! Was told by the guy working he wasn't authorized to refund my money would I like something else. Ummm NO. Not one product in the case had a date. Who knows how long they've been in there (considering what I bought was spoiled) this will be my third week calling to get a refund I already returned which the guy threw away wrote my name and number down and HAVE YET TO HEAR BACK. CALLED LAST WEEK, A WOMAN WROTE MY NAME AND NUMBER DOWN AND STILL NO CALL RETURNED!!! When I call today and you tell me "oh, someone will call you back" I am reporting to the health department and the better business bureau!! This is ridiculous 6 plus dollars for a disgusting spoiled cheesecake I didn't even eat!!!!
Carol Griffiths
Stood around inside without being noticed or waited on. Young man working said that the door bell didn't ring And I he didn't hear me come in.Food was good though and not too expensiveParking: Next door to the UPS pack and ship store, which is always busy but cars come and go frequently so if you want a close parking space, you can wait a bit until someone leaves . Otherwise there are plenty of spaces if you can walk a little ways.
Guy was nice and was
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Build Your Own
I had a recommendation from a friend that this was a spot for a good pizza. The Pie-rogi was excellent! Crispy crust, loaded with potatoes, full of flavor ? I will definitely be making this a regular stop!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pierogi Pizza
Just found this little gem today!! Can’t believe I didn’t know it was in Butler!! Wonderful pie!! ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS ? I’ll definitely recommend this lil pizza place, and will definitely be back!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Walked in at 8:45pm they were closing… I got 5star service without a dirty look and I still apologized for coming in last minute but I had just gotten into town and just got my hotel room. I asked for a recommendation and the chef hooked me up very quickly I was in and out of the restaurant in about 7 minutes… super fresh food and the place was spotless! If you don’t know which pizza place to choose and are looking for “that” spot! This is it trust me! I got the chicken bacon ranch with a chef salad and a chocolate chip cookie and a bottled tea. 5stars all the way!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We tried third eye pies for the first time tonight and it was delicious. Fast & Friendly service and atmosphere. Good prices.Would highly recommend as they have all kinds of options for your pizzas.We got the Lord of the Brussels and the Mac Me So Happy pizzas. Simply delicious.
My first time there, Butler location. Had a build your own, the crust is excellent and they do not skimp on the toppings. The employees were super friendly and explained everything to me as I have visual impairment and couldn’t really see the menu. Would definitely recommend and will be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Build Your Own
So fun & so good!Great fun experience. You can grab a pizza from the list or build your own down the line!!It's awesome & each time it's been delicious!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent food at a great price with a cool experience
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Got the general TSO and the American gothic. Both were absolutely fantastic. Will definitely be back. Definitely pizza with an awesome twist!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Chunk Red Velvet Cookie, Nashville Hottie
The staff here is always so friendly! Not to mention the pizza and salads are delicious!!!
Restaurantji Recommends
First time ordering from here. I had it delivered. This pizza is the best that I have had in Butler! I love the option of fresh sliced mozzarella! The red sauce is amazing (be sure to order extra on the side for dipping)! Definitely my go to from now on! YUM!
I came here 3 WEEKS AGO purchased a peice of cheesecake. I took one bite and it was SPOILED! I spit the bite into container and immediately after purchasing took the cheese cake back! Was told by the guy working he wasn't authorized to refund my money would I like something else. Ummm NO. Not one product in the case had a date. Who knows how long they've been in there (considering what I bought was spoiled) this will be my third week calling to get a refund I already returned which the guy threw away wrote my name and number down and HAVE YET TO HEAR BACK. CALLED LAST WEEK, A WOMAN WROTE MY NAME AND NUMBER DOWN AND STILL NO CALL RETURNED!!! When I call today and you tell me "oh, someone will call you back" I am reporting to the health department and the better business bureau!! This is ridiculous 6 plus dollars for a disgusting spoiled cheesecake I didn't even eat!!!!
Service was quick and very pleasant. Answered every question I asked with detail and a smile. Now down to the main point. THE FOOD!!!!!..... Girlfriend got the Alfredo Chicken Pasta Bowl.. first reaction was OMG SO GOOD. Daughter got the Pierogie Pizza... she shared with her baby brother and the both scarfed it down like they would never be feed again. She couldn't stop talking about how amazing it was. Myself I got a make your own pizza. CHICKEN BACON MOZZARELLA CHEDDAR PINEAPPLE WITH BUTTER&GARLIC SAUCE WITH A DRIZZLE OF HOT HONEY ON TOP. Hands down the most fantastic and tasteful. Pizza I have had in 20 years! I recommend Third Eye Pie to everyone and anyone! BEST PIZZA IN BUTLER! HANDS DOWN! It's affordable and delicious and I say that with 100% Truth. I have eaten at over 100 Pizza shops through out the country. Third Eye Pie is my new #1!
I came here 3 WEEKS AGO purchased a peice of cheesecake. I took one bite and it was SPOILED! I spit the bite into container and immediately after purchasing took the cheese cake back! Was told by the guy working he wasn't authorized to refund my money would I like something else. Ummm NO. Not one product in the case had a date. Who knows how long they've been in there (considering what I bought was spoiled) this will be my third week calling to get a refund I already returned which the guy threw away wrote my name and number down and HAVE YET TO HEAR BACK. CALLED LAST WEEK, A WOMAN WROTE MY NAME AND NUMBER DOWN AND STILL NO CALL RETURNED!!! When I call today and you tell me "oh, someone will call you back" I am reporting to the health department and the better business bureau!! This is ridiculous 6 plus dollars for a disgusting spoiled cheesecake I didn't even eat!!!!
Stood around inside without being noticed or waited on. Young man working said that the door bell didn't ring And I he didn't hear me come in.Food was good though and not too expensiveParking: Next door to the UPS pack and ship store, which is always busy but cars come and go frequently so if you want a close parking space, you can wait a bit until someone leaves . Otherwise there are plenty of spaces if you can walk a little ways.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pierogi Pizza