Katie Cakes Cakery

118 E Penn Ave, Cleona
(717) 383-1689

Recent Reviews

Nicole Kloza

Katie did our wedding cupcakes/cake, and it was fantastic. The designs were absolutely beautiful, and the cake tasted incredible. Very airy and light.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake

Erin Weidman

My husband and I used Katie as our baker for our wedding day. She was a dream to work with. She is a very talented baker, and made my wedding cake dreams come true. She took my inspiration and brought it to life. We ordered a cake for the two of us to cut, and then cupcakes for our guests. All of our guests raved about how good the cupcakes were. We ordered a chocolate cake, and it was the best chocolate cake we have ever had. I would highly recommend hiring Katie as your baker. You, and your guests, will not be disappointed!

Katie Freeman

Katie provided us our wedding cake and several dozen mini cupcakes. The cake was out of this world. The guests raved about it and many said it was the best cake they have ever had. We went with almond cake with almond buttercream. The mini cupcakes were also delicious and super cute.

Paul Yarrish

Working with Katie was amazing! She help guide us and went the extra mile to make sure everything was made the way we had envisioned it to be. Our guests are still raving about the wedding cake and cake pops. We would highly recommend her for your wedding or any occasion.

Kate N

We are so thrilled Katie made the cake and cupcakes for our wedding. We tried several local bakeries and she was, hands down, the best. Her flavors were impressive and we fell in LOVE with all her frostings. From start to finish, she was easy to work with. She even took a family recipe and turned it into a cupcake for us! Thank you so much, everything was perfect. - Kate & Anthony, December 2022

Tiffany Kimmel DDS

Katie is an amazing baker. We had so many compliments from guests on how delicious the cake was. We wanted a more classic design with florals and she coordinated perfectly with our florist. It turned out delicious and gorgeous! Thank you Katie!

Georgia N

We are so thrilled Katie made the cake and cupcakes for our wedding. We tried several local bakeries and she was, hands down, the best. Her flavors were impressive and we fell in LOVE with all her frostings. From start to finish, she was easy to work with. She even took a family recipe and turned it into a cupcake for us! Thank you so much, everything was perfect. - Kate & Anthony, December 2022

Courtney Lee

Cake was cute. Did NOT taste good. Cupcakes were nicely decorated. She did not tell me she was using fondant. Overall she was very nice. Decorations were awesome, but the cake and cupcakes were not good.

Tiffany Kimmel

Katie is an amazing baker. We had so many compliments from guests on how delicious the cake was. We wanted a more classic design with florals and she coordinated perfectly with our florist. It turned out delicious and gorgeous! Thank you Katie!

Sarah Snyder

So happy we decided on Katie as our baker for our wedding. Every guest component just how delicious her cupcakes were. Our cake was delicious, too. Katie was great to work with!

Brianne Henry

We got our wedding cake from Katie. It was beautiful and delicious! The hardest part was narrowing it down to just one cake and frosting flavor. We ultimately went with raspberry frosting with chocolate cake. Rave reviews from all our guests. I would highly recommend!

Katelyn Arlene Mease

She does amazing job! She did cupcakes for my bridal shower and they were amazing and yummy. Booked her for my wedding. Her cakes and cupcakes are so good

Sarah Snyder

Great communication, delicious cakes and cupcakes. Booked for our wedding and has been helpful in the planning process with all things sweet!! Update- wedding happened and every guest compliment just how good the cupcakes were!!! They were a hit!!!!

Monica Marinkov

Ordered Katie’s cupcakes for Christmas and they were delicious! Had just the right amount of sweetness and were an awesome variety. Will be purchasing again!

Nicole Youngling

Katie made a beautiful cake for my wedding. Everyone RAVED about how delicious it was. She was so great to work with and did an amazing job!!

Load More