We come here many Fridays. No matter what we try, its always fantastic!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tiffany Rohrer
My first experience at Jimmy C’s was outstanding. The customer service was remarkable and despite having a limited menu because of the holidays...the staff was so helpful and accommodating. The soup was delicious. I will be back to try more!
Aikey55
Living nearby we visit often and in the past our order has been incomplete several times with the missing signature sauces. During our last two visits a week apart… the sauces were discovered once again missing after a 10 minute drive home. Although it’s difficult to check due to the packaging, I would not suggest leaving without checking. The food is good, the sauces make it great… I don’t understand how not including them seems to be a habitual problem.
Brian Kiefer
Some of the best food you will ever eat! I've never tasted anything from Jimmy's that I didn't love. Super clean and fast service! An absolute must try for everyone.
Hardy Hill
I just tried some of Jimmy C's Chicken Pot Pie (bought 2 quarts) and I can't believe I waited this long to try it! It's so good it reminds me of my grandmother's recipe and brought back many loving memories! Needless to say, I'll definitely be coming back for more! Just delicious and perfect for this colder weather!
Bridgid Byrne
Always delicious! We stop every time we are in town and never left unsatisfied. It truly is the best homemade meal to go.
Jesi Hamberger
Everything is delicious! Especially the homemade soups and macaroni and cheese! The staff is absolutely wonderful also! I’ve been going here for almost 40 years and it is always consistent. One of my favorite Friday rituals:)
Dan Druck
Great chicken pot pie, both baked and boiled! Hot roast beef sandwiches with gravy, or roast turkey with gravy. Everything is delicious!
Stacey Murphy
Inside New Eastern Market.super busy? Tables available on a limited basis. The food was good and freshly cooked. Give them a try.
Great homemade cooking at the New Eastern Market! Highly recommend eating there or take home for a great meal!
Jimena M.
This place kind of reminds me of Mel's Diner for some reason. I went in for a quick lunch, sat at the bar and ordered a turkey sandwich on pretzel bread. Pretzel bread makes my trips here so worth it. I just love it. The turkey slices were grilled, which was a nice surprise and the pretzel bread slightly toasted. The lettuce and tomato slices were fresh and crisp. It came with standard chips and pickle. Sandwich and drink came out to $6 plus change. What a steal! The best part was that all the locals were so friendly and chatted me up while I waited and ate. I met George, who works at a dairy company nearby. He's worked there over 30 years! and comes to Cindy's regularly. Every knew him when he walked in and they talked to each other like family. This place gave me the warm fuzzies, check it out if you're ever in York.
Love eating here.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
We come here many Fridays. No matter what we try, its always fantastic!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My first experience at Jimmy C’s was outstanding. The customer service was remarkable and despite having a limited menu because of the holidays...the staff was so helpful and accommodating. The soup was delicious. I will be back to try more!
Living nearby we visit often and in the past our order has been incomplete several times with the missing signature sauces. During our last two visits a week apart… the sauces were discovered once again missing after a 10 minute drive home. Although it’s difficult to check due to the packaging, I would not suggest leaving without checking. The food is good, the sauces make it great… I don’t understand how not including them seems to be a habitual problem.
Some of the best food you will ever eat! I've never tasted anything from Jimmy's that I didn't love. Super clean and fast service! An absolute must try for everyone.
I just tried some of Jimmy C's Chicken Pot Pie (bought 2 quarts) and I can't believe I waited this long to try it! It's so good it reminds me of my grandmother's recipe and brought back many loving memories! Needless to say, I'll definitely be coming back for more! Just delicious and perfect for this colder weather!
Always delicious! We stop every time we are in town and never left unsatisfied. It truly is the best homemade meal to go.
Everything is delicious! Especially the homemade soups and macaroni and cheese! The staff is absolutely wonderful also! I’ve been going here for almost 40 years and it is always consistent. One of my favorite Friday rituals:)
Great chicken pot pie, both baked and boiled! Hot roast beef sandwiches with gravy, or roast turkey with gravy. Everything is delicious!
Inside New Eastern Market.super busy? Tables available on a limited basis. The food was good and freshly cooked. Give them a try.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great homemade cooking at the New Eastern Market! Highly recommend eating there or take home for a great meal!
This place kind of reminds me of Mel's Diner for some reason. I went in for a quick lunch, sat at the bar and ordered a turkey sandwich on pretzel bread. Pretzel bread makes my trips here so worth it. I just love it. The turkey slices were grilled, which was a nice surprise and the pretzel bread slightly toasted. The lettuce and tomato slices were fresh and crisp. It came with standard chips and pickle. Sandwich and drink came out to $6 plus change. What a steal! The best part was that all the locals were so friendly and chatted me up while I waited and ate. I met George, who works at a dairy company nearby. He's worked there over 30 years! and comes to Cindy's regularly. Every knew him when he walked in and they talked to each other like family. This place gave me the warm fuzzies, check it out if you're ever in York.