Garys is a small but mighty community store. They have everyday essentials, like milk and eggs. They also put together terrific sandwiches fresh from their deli counter.
I’ve been coming here for yrs and really never been disappointed tonight we went with a couple subs, appetizers and finally got my chance to try Pot O Gold chocolate milk ???will be back and highly recommend if you’ve never stopped 2 check them out #supportlocal you won’t be
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anna Wow
It's about time for a update..........Pizza and antipasto outstandingGreat special......fresh dough pizzaCall ahead for
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Antipasto Salad, Two X
Greg more
Great food. Excellent wings,subs.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Balls
Mary Wnukowski
Always wanted to try this place. A friend got me a sub on a fundraiser. I ordered a hot Italian which consisted of 1 and half pieces of thin ham on a 10 inch sub, 3 very thin slices of salami. Some soggy lettuce and thin nasty tomatoes. I'll add some meat and veg to try to make it palatable. Appreciate my friends kindness and the fact I won't be patronizing. Sorry I left a tip
James Walker
My wife and I had the best pepperoni balls EVER at the suprette followed by playing some slot machines with great company and great service! Most deffinantly a 5 star place:)
Everett Skinner
VERY disappointed, 4th time in a week and a half tryed to place an order and the phone rang until the machine cut it off. Love the food that's why the 3 star's. But
Matt T.
This spot is a hidden gem. You'd think it was just a place to stop in and get snacks or pop. That is the farthest from the truth! Their cold and hot in house made subs are fantastic. Forget about Subway and I hate to say it, Sheetz too. These are the OG subs. Haven't tried their pizza yet, but their ranch fries are great. 10/10 stop in or call ahead. They're friendly and will hook you up with a quick after work dinner for you and you're significant other.
Kari Nicholl
Just had pizza and wings from Gary’s. It was delicious. Best pizza I’ve had in a while. Lots of flavor and no skimping on the cheese and pepperoni!
Tammy Schley
I normally order my boneless wings here I WON’T ANYMORE!! I order Parmesan ranch flavor but tonight my wings are hot meaning spicy I called and they said it was the wings they came that way .. I’ve been ordering these wings for years never have they been spicy ..,
This is a great little corner store basically and has great pizza and wings.
Megan Sowers
Got the worst service ever tonight along with the worst food I ever got from there. These 2 girls who are working tonight I would not have them employed anywhere. Food looks like it was tossed all over the place not even toasted and thrown in a bag. I will never give my business to this place again while yhese 2 are working.
Mercy W.
I would never recommend this place to anyone.... older lady/owner?? deli clerk was always so extremely rude every time I went there..... stands idle for a long time while the customer waits to be ordered on and she never smiles, is mad about her life or something. Says so busy all the time but store is always empty and they never answer phone to call ahead. Deli prices good but subs not at all... the rolls are light and flaky instead of Italian like and have no flavor and can't get full on it because not enough substance. Booooooo On customer service.... don't waste your money. If they can't handle the business then they should not advertise, enough said!!!!!
Mike Kovach
Good food and great prices. Wings and pizza are top notch.
Garys is a small but mighty community store. They have everyday essentials, like milk and eggs. They also put together terrific sandwiches fresh from their deli counter.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Cold Cut Combo, Cream Cheese Jalapeño Poppers, Pizza Logs 4, Gold Chocolate Milk
I’ve been coming here for yrs and really never been disappointed tonight we went with a couple subs, appetizers and finally got my chance to try Pot O Gold chocolate milk ???will be back and highly recommend if you’ve never stopped 2 check them out #supportlocal you won’t be
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It's about time for a update..........Pizza and antipasto outstandingGreat special......fresh dough pizzaCall ahead for
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Antipasto Salad, Two X
Great food. Excellent wings,subs.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Balls
Always wanted to try this place. A friend got me a sub on a fundraiser. I ordered a hot Italian which consisted of 1 and half pieces of thin ham on a 10 inch sub, 3 very thin slices of salami. Some soggy lettuce and thin nasty tomatoes. I'll add some meat and veg to try to make it palatable. Appreciate my friends kindness and the fact I won't be patronizing. Sorry I left a tip
My wife and I had the best pepperoni balls EVER at the suprette followed by playing some slot machines with great company and great service! Most deffinantly a 5 star place:)
VERY disappointed, 4th time in a week and a half tryed to place an order and the phone rang until the machine cut it off. Love the food that's why the 3 star's. But
This spot is a hidden gem. You'd think it was just a place to stop in and get snacks or pop. That is the farthest from the truth! Their cold and hot in house made subs are fantastic. Forget about Subway and I hate to say it, Sheetz too. These are the OG subs. Haven't tried their pizza yet, but their ranch fries are great. 10/10 stop in or call ahead. They're friendly and will hook you up with a quick after work dinner for you and you're significant other.
Just had pizza and wings from Gary’s. It was delicious. Best pizza I’ve had in a while. Lots of flavor and no skimping on the cheese and pepperoni!
I normally order my boneless wings here I WON’T ANYMORE!! I order Parmesan ranch flavor but tonight my wings are hot meaning spicy I called and they said it was the wings they came that way .. I’ve been ordering these wings for years never have they been spicy ..,
Restaurantji Recommends
Simply the home town best!!!!
This is a great little corner store basically and has great pizza and wings.
Got the worst service ever tonight along with the worst food I ever got from there. These 2 girls who are working tonight I would not have them employed anywhere. Food looks like it was tossed all over the place not even toasted and thrown in a bag. I will never give my business to this place again while yhese 2 are working.
I would never recommend this place to anyone.... older lady/owner?? deli clerk was always so extremely rude every time I went there..... stands idle for a long time while the customer waits to be ordered on and she never smiles, is mad about her life or something. Says so busy all the time but store is always empty and they never answer phone to call ahead. Deli prices good but subs not at all... the rolls are light and flaky instead of Italian like and have no flavor and can't get full on it because not enough substance. Booooooo On customer service.... don't waste your money. If they can't handle the business then they should not advertise, enough said!!!!!
Good food and great prices. Wings and pizza are top notch.