I got the buffalo chicken bacon sandwich. While it wasn't quite what I expected (I thought it would be spicier than it was), it was still one of the best sandwiches ive had in quite a while. Really nice people, really cute interior, and a good price. Over all, really good. I've already recommended the place to all my
Breakfast was great. Also got a cinnamon crunch bagel that they loaded up with cream cheese. 10/10 will be
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jake Francis
Bagels are
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Dozen Bagels
Nicole Johnson
Got them on Door Dash. The BYO with ham & egg was really good. Wish the bagel selection/options were posted but I just commented to give me 2 everything & the rest a variety so that worked out. The Cream Cheese Servings were amazing, especially the chive.
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Individual Bagel, Build Your Own with Egg
Carrie C.
The bagels are the best I've had. They have a nice bite going in and that is followed by a light and airy middle.
Kyle T.
Best tasting bagels in the area, they have numerous varieties and they are very tasty. We used a variety of bagels for our stuffing and received numerous compliments. I would highly recommend you give them a try, and believe me you won't be disappointed.
Daysha Love
Great bagels! Super soft and fresh. The service was great and the place had a nice, locally owned feel.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwiches
Emma Evans
The food is amazing and fast!!! I go at least once a week and everything I’ve had is great!(The TV is pretty loud inside)
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwiches, Build Your Own, Dozen Bagels, Individual Bagel
This is one of the best Bagel places I have ever eaten at....the bagel varieties are amazing and the cheese spreads offer lot of variety..the Hot Pepper is our favorite .....and the prices are so affordable.... must visit placeNeed to visit early to get ur choice...it sells put most fo the times
Steven Lin
Absolutely life changing bagel sandwiches that are easy on the wallet. Also had a fun chat with one of the staff. Made my day.
Barb Saccamozzone
Best bagels in Erie. Pumpkin cream cheese is unbelievably good ❤️
Peter Withheld
Great sandwiches- especially the roast beef- as well as top-notch bagels and homemade cream cheese. And yes, I’m a former New Yorker. The veggie cream cheese is intense!I think my only critique would be the loud TV blaring the news as it would be nice to have music or at least a quieter TV.
Diane C.
First time at New York Bagel West Lake Rd. 5 star. Got the Little Italy on a cheese/jalapeno bagel. Big enough to split. The staff was super helpful. The sandwich is my new favorite.Didn't really rate the ambiance as we were getting to go. Will definitely be back!
Always a good experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I got the buffalo chicken bacon sandwich. While it wasn't quite what I expected (I thought it would be spicier than it was), it was still one of the best sandwiches ive had in quite a while. Really nice people, really cute interior, and a good price. Over all, really good. I've already recommended the place to all my
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Bacon Ranch, Individual Bagel
Breakfast was great. Also got a cinnamon crunch bagel that they loaded up with cream cheese. 10/10 will be
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bagels are
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Dozen Bagels
Got them on Door Dash. The BYO with ham & egg was really good. Wish the bagel selection/options were posted but I just commented to give me 2 everything & the rest a variety so that worked out. The Cream Cheese Servings were amazing, especially the chive.
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Individual Bagel, Build Your Own with Egg
The bagels are the best I've had. They have a nice bite going in and that is followed by a light and airy middle.
Best tasting bagels in the area, they have numerous varieties and they are very tasty. We used a variety of bagels for our stuffing and received numerous compliments. I would highly recommend you give them a try, and believe me you won't be disappointed.
Great bagels! Super soft and fresh. The service was great and the place had a nice, locally owned feel.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwiches
The food is amazing and fast!!! I go at least once a week and everything I’ve had is great!(The TV is pretty loud inside)
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwiches, Build Your Own, Dozen Bagels, Individual Bagel
Best bagels in Erie! Love the bleu cheese
Restaurantji Recommends
This is one of the best Bagel places I have ever eaten at....the bagel varieties are amazing and the cheese spreads offer lot of variety..the Hot Pepper is our favorite .....and the prices are so affordable.... must visit placeNeed to visit early to get ur choice...it sells put most fo the times
Absolutely life changing bagel sandwiches that are easy on the wallet. Also had a fun chat with one of the staff. Made my day.
Best bagels in Erie. Pumpkin cream cheese is unbelievably good ❤️
Great sandwiches- especially the roast beef- as well as top-notch bagels and homemade cream cheese. And yes, I’m a former New Yorker. The veggie cream cheese is intense!I think my only critique would be the loud TV blaring the news as it would be nice to have music or at least a quieter TV.
First time at New York Bagel West Lake Rd. 5 star. Got the Little Italy on a cheese/jalapeno bagel. Big enough to split. The staff was super helpful. The sandwich is my new favorite.Didn't really rate the ambiance as we were getting to go. Will definitely be back!