Restaurants in Greencastle

“I found this hidden treasure today waiting for next appointment. I will say this was one of the best breakfast I have ever had at a restaurant. Staff was extremely nice. Will definitely be stopping there again, when I'm in the area.”

“Great drinks and excellent food! I enjoy the specials (cream of crab soup) plus the salad, and shrimp and grits. Can’t wait to continue to return and try out more on the menu !!”

“We have been here several times, and every time it is delicious comfort food at its finest! My husband loves the steak, and crab cake dinners, and I really like their turkey dinner with homemade Martin’s stuffing, and their beef brisket. They give kids in your party a little wood coin for their candy store too, which is enough to get at least a couple pieces of candy. Our son just loves it and always looks forward to going over after we are done eating for some treats. The candy store has a nice selection of homemade chocolate candy that is also very good!”

“Our family had a nice evening here! Overall it was a very good experience. I had the fried haddock and would certainly order it again, in fact, it was recommended by my son (who couldn't make it) and we came here specifically based on his recommendation. It did not disappoint! I could see us go here again, simply to order that item. It consists of two huge planks of fried haddock that were perfectly battered and with the tartar sauce, absolutely delicious. The rest of the family order items to their specifications and simply is pleased. Only hold up from five stars, was there seemed to be a miscue at the start of our experience as we were waiting for a solid 10 or 15 minutes for anyone to come over. The hostess eventually realized we were still sitting, I took care of getting the server to come over. The server overall was good, personable, and worked to make connections with the kids in particular which was nice. So, maybe just a bit of disorganization somewhere. Oh, I should mention the dessert we ordered was phenomenal! Peanut butter pie is to die for.Kid-friendliness: They have two sections here, a bar / lounge and a dining area. I'll give them credit, they actually have two separate entrances so that you can either go into the family friendly side or the bar lounge side. Also as I mentioned in the review, the server did take notice of the kids and make an effort to specifically connect with them and make them feel noticed and important.”

“I have been eating here since they opened. Absolutely fantastic food and service. The tacos are amazing and the guacamole is somehow even better. To top it off, the employees are incredibly friendly and helpful.I have had a great time dining in as well as picking up to go orders for lunch and dinner.”

“Was excited to check out this place as we were in Greencastle for something else. The menu is not overly large, but there are some unique items on there. I was not a huge fan of the pizza, it just didn't have a lot of flavor. It is a wood fired pizza oven, so if that is your thing, give it a shot. They have an okay selection of beers/wines to choose from. Sadly they were out of the cider that I wanted. I did get a pretty tasty sour though. The service was average, would have been nice to get a little more attention since it wasn't busy. I can't say much for the atmosphere since it was early in the day, but it is a pretty cool layout. I would recommend trying, but I don't know if I will frequent this place.”

“Wow! Wow! Wow! November 2024 will be our 18th anniversary of relocating to the this beautiful rapidly growing Antrim Township, inclusive of Greencastle Borough. We soon became a regular right here at Brother’s Pizza (Greencastle)!! THE BEST“REAL” decision made ever!!IF YOU ARE reading this & are making your way through our wonderful little town in Central Pennsylvania STOP OFF by BROTHER’s PIZZA today!!Here are some of the MOST AMAZING dishes we typically order!! WHY? You may be asking? Well my friends… BECAUSE ITS MOUTH WATERING, don’t even stop me from LICKING my FINGERS GOOD!1) GO-TO FAVORITE deliveryTriple Cheese Double Pepperoni Lg Pizza2) Fried Cheesecake3) Lasagna4) Chicken Nachos (no jalapeño)5) Eggplant Parmesan (YUMMY)6) Taco Salad (Beef)extra salsa, extra sour cream, extra jalapeñoSWell, my friends you and your fam! pick you out from of the favorites above and you CANT GO WRONG!FAIR WARNING: be sure to call when you are hungry cuz plan to get your monies worth!DEFINITELY WORTHWHILE!!! PULL OFF RAMP @ EXIT 3 Interstate 81 inside SOUTH CENTRAL PENNSYLVANIA, FRANKLIN COUNTY!! Turn right off exit 3 coming from Maryland side and left off coming from Carlisle area.”

“Best food in town. Food is Delicious and the customer service is amazing. I visited there during the winter break, the girl there (I guess she’s the owner’s daughter). She’s really patient and kind, A+++ customer service. Will definitely order from them.”

“They literally have the best jalapeño poppers I've ever had. My burger was cooked to perfection and their entrée salads are so big and delicious! Service was also great!”

“Godfathers Pizza is delicious! It reminds me of how Pizza Hut tasted in the early 90’s before they messed up their recipe! The sauce and crust are great! I wish they had more locations throughout the country!”

“Went there Sunday night for dinner, which was excellent. We were serenaded by the Jo’ Blues band, which was superb. The service was excellent; made me feel like I was in my living room. Let’s do this again.”

“Service was nice. Food looked good but I was disappointed. I had 4 bites of mushroom Swiss burger and I was done. 3 fries & I was done with them. Coke was excellent.”

“My daughter got the Burrito Grande California Style and it was huge!! It filled her plate! I got the Lunch Fajitas Ricas that came with rice, refried beans and salad. We also ordered the large cheese dip and guacamole. We were very surprised when they brought a soup bowl of each!! Definitely a large serving!! We were there mid-afternoon so we almost had the place to ourselves. Food was very good, service was good and it wasn't too pricey. We'll be going back again!!”

“Fantastic subs!! Picked up two foot long subs 1) Monster Footlong Sub no onions + no ranch and Steak & Cheese on Italian and Herbs both toasted YUMMY! The ladies on duty were phenomenal! Excellent customer service! Very professional and pleasant!Vegetarian options: Vegetarian sub options availableDietary restrictions: Vegetarian and Vegan options are availableParking: Plenty of parking in their parking lot and truck stop parking lot across the street as well.Wheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair accessible”

“I've driven past this place a dozen times, thought I would stop in. my waitress "Bonnie" could not have been sweeter and the food was great. next I need to bring a better appetite, because it was a lot of food. It definitely has a old-school vibe, I was waiting to see Flo come from the back (google it, for the young people). I would recommend,.”