Dodge City Steakhouse

1037 Paxton St #1645, Harrisburg
(717) 236-2719

Recent Reviews

Travis Dougherty

Best steak around. Forget the roadhouse or longhorn Eat

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Terry Passeno

Good value, great food, staff was little slow, but would give them a

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 2

Dawn Graham

We didn't get the chance to try their food. We were planning to eat there before attending an event nearby, however, we were unaware of their reservation only policy. The place was far from full, yet no attempt was made to seat us and even worse, the woman there was extremely rude. They don't serve food at the bar area like EVERY other restaurant in the area does. Robert Irvine may have saved the food, but someone needs to show that woman how to treat a potential customer. I will never go there now.

Service: 1

Adam Bergenstock

I don't know what I expected, but it surpassed anything I imagined. Everything was fantastic.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Marnie Duncan

Great place for lunch or dinner! We arrived just before 3pm, so Alaina gave us the option to order lunch or dinner. She was super sweet and friendly. And the food was DELICIOUS! The owner / manager even stopped by our table to chat. Highly recommend!!!

Harvey Tegeler

Really interesting specialty menu during the GAOS in February.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Balsamic Marinated Hanger Steak

Jeff Futer

Had one of the best steaks I ever ate!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mindy Burger

Disappointed in the food! We ordered there “homemade” chips with cheese sauce, I swear they were Herr’s chips! Horrible and with barely any cheese, which was cold! I wanted to send back but my husband was starving by then cause it took that about 45 minutes to get!!!! The literally took over another hour and 15 minutes for us to finally get our food, to only be cool. You could tell it sat in the kitchen. It was not busy, there were plenty of empty tables the whole time we were there. We both ordered med rare steaks which I do have to say were cooked great! I think Robert Irvine would be disappointed as well!!!!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

Ashley Gallman

Currently at the restaurant and our waitress is absolutely rude!She tried to skip over us but not seating my companion and I. Then a few of the people waiting stated we were there first and as she sat us she stated very rudely this is why you make reservations! Rolled her eyes and walked off. Yet no one waiting with us made reservations or the people prior to us that got seated. We tried to overlook it because she's playing hostess and waitress but when she took or order I went to ask a question regarding the salad and she immediately cut me off as if she was speaking to her child. She is being unnecessarily rude and it's ticking me off. It's like we were pre-judged and she tried avoiding us altogether. Her attitude is unnecessary and we came here to celebrate a friend's birthday and she is such a sour pos in out experience here. No one in this restaurant is receiving the same treatment and we are watching her interactions.I'll be back to further update.

Atmosphere: 4

Service: 1

John Crutchfield

Great staff! Steaks were very well prepared! We also had Elk sliders which were also delicious. Best priced steak in Harrisburg!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Henry Mow

Full house, luckily we made a reservation earlier today; several parties arrived after us and turned away. Food was excellent and worth waiting for!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Surf and Turf, Fried Shrimp

Beth Lobdell

Overall, the food was excellent. However, my husband's steak was over salted and a bit chewy for Prime at that

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Blue Cheese Burger

Dana Sander

We were from out of town so I called ahead to see if the place was kid friendly, since we were bringing 3, and what the dress was like. The lady on the phone was very nice and recommended we make reservations, so we did. Once we got there, it wasn't nearly as busy as I thought it would be since we were told to make reservations. Once we got seated, it took about 10 minutes for a waitress to come over so we all had our order ready by that point. When she asked what she could get us to drink, I said we are ready for the whole order if you are and her response was "you might be ready, but the kitchen isn't" and only took our drink order. We got our appetizer and it was delicious, but the food was taking forever. My husband ordered a wine that he never ended up getting. We have small kids, and screen time can only keep them entertained for so long, so when we had been sitting there for an hour and a half waiting on food, we decided to leave. Our waitress never came over to give us an update on when our food would be out, or apologize for it taking so long, there was no communication at all. The restaurant was not busy at all so why such a long wait, made no sense to me. When my husband asked the bartender to wrap up our bill she was surprised at how long we had been waiting. The bill ended up listing the glass of wine on it because it had actually been poured and ready, but our waitress never brought it to our table. I'm sure the food would have been delicious, but we never made it that far due to the poor service.Leaving a restaurant without getting the food we ordered is not something we have ever done, but a combination of the wait time and our very unfriendly waitress was reason enough.Overall terrible experience and I'm not sure how their rating is so high.

Atmosphere: 2

Service: 1

Charles Terry

I'd eat there

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sυɳƚσɾɳ Pσɠαʂιƈ

Can't believe I live 5 minutes from this hidden gem. Best culinary establishment around imo. Took my fiance and 7yo princess there tonight, and we ate way too much lol. We ordered and all split crab dip, onion soup, fried mozz, garden salad, 12oz prime rib with mash taters, and a brisket sandwich with fries, complimentary rolls with cinnabutter. The staff were delightful and fun! Very professional indeed, very clean. My 7yo daughter is very picky, and she said the steak melted in her mouth. Keep in mind, excellent tasting food, takes more time to prepare. I feel like i got great value for my money for once, and we will be returning.Parking: Parking lot was packed full, I arrived 10 min before reservation time, and lit was full, but emmediately took the spot off a leaving patron.Kid-friendliness: The staff loved my 6 yo girl, and treated her like a princess.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Dodge City Crab Dip, Prime Rib Sandwich

Load More