Passed by this place on my way to Hershey and was in the mood to try a different restaurant than the usual Piazza Sorrento. Ordered a cheesesteak with a side of Old Bay fries. Hands down, one of the better places that makes a good cheesesteak. Exactly as the business name states: Stuffed! Packed with meat in every bite....even the end piece. Cheese was nicely blended in the meat; not like some places that cook the meat and place the cheese on top of the meat and serve it to you. Not greasy so you don't have to worry about a soggy bottom roll. The old bay fries came out hot with just enough seasoning. The side of ranch was the perfect dipping combination. Although the restaurant will be moving to a different location, it's a good lunch option if you're in the Hershey area. Wish I would have tried this place sooner!
Erin Dautrich
This is without a doubt, hands down, bar none the best steak you will find this far out of Philly. The cooper and whiz combo is next level. I wish them the best, it seems they are being forced to move locations.
The real deal. Cheesesteaks and fries were delicious. I wish we lived closer, but then my pants wouldn't fit. :)
Scott S.
Rolls were good but were neither stuffed nor tasty. Steak meat was very big, and tough and not seasoned very well. I grew up in the Philadelphia area and was excited to hear about Philly style steaks in the area. These are not even close to what I grew up with. On top of that the parking lot is weird and not very easy to maneuver around. No need to go back
Mine N.
I have wanted to try this place for a while. I had a chance the other day after taking the afternoon off. I tried the cheese steak. I was happy to hear that they do not have the baine of my cheesesteak existence... sauce! I will say if you're gonna order fries it's not a takeout item. That's something you need to eat in the restaurant. The steak, however, was good. I would try it again but it's also something that can't go further than Hershey for me. If it's going to taste good.
Malik B.
The cheesesteaks were excellent and the service was top tier. Too bad I love so far away else I would eat here regularly.
Robert
For the price point I thought it would be sliced ribeye but no!! Very average I won't be back!
Bob Ancharski
Amazing steaks and fries. But more importantly, an incredible community partner that support so many including Palmyra Athletics!Kid-friendliness: Love the food!
First time trying this place. We got The OG, chicken ranch and an Italian.Bread is top notch along with the ingredients. Excellent all around!!We made the 2 hour drive from Maryland, would definitely comeback.Parking: They have a few spots up front, if you need more they have some in the back, they share with the adjoining beer store
Stopped here after visiting for the Blake Shelton concert. I knew they had to be good since they informed us it was a 45 minute wait for it to go order. I didn't eat mine until about six hours later and it was absolutely amazing I asked for cheese whiz and fried onions. Best cheesesteak I've had in a long time!
Neel K.
This place is awesome!!!! I got a chicken cheesesteak with the sharp cheddar, whiz, jalapeños and grilled onions and I was blown away. The bread was chewy and saturated with flavor. The chicken was perfectly cooked with an excellent balance of cheese and other flavors. The staff was amazing. Super friendly and extremely helpful for someone who has never been there. They have some cool sports memorabilia on the walls that you can buy. Overall, I will definitely be back again. It is absolutely worth the drive from Hershey if you are visiting. Can't wait to go back and try one of their burgers.
Danielle Bangert
Had the fish & chipsOver cookedThe fries were oldThe tarter sauce was goodShould of had some Cole slaw
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Richard Hlavacek
Very well executed cheesesteaks! They supported a fundraiser we attended, so a portion of the proceeds went to the fundraiser. I ate the entire sandwich, it was that good! I went with a diy cooper sharp, onions and mushrooms. If I lived closer I'd be trying all their variations though. Well done Stuffd Steaks!
Alden R.
I've tried a lot of "Philly" cheesesteaks before and this might be the worst one I've tried in awhile. Probably about half the size of a normal cheesesteak for the same price you can get in Philly or other places around here. Super dry felt like there was no cheese on it at all.
Passed by this place on my way to Hershey and was in the mood to try a different restaurant than the usual Piazza Sorrento. Ordered a cheesesteak with a side of Old Bay fries. Hands down, one of the better places that makes a good cheesesteak. Exactly as the business name states: Stuffed! Packed with meat in every bite....even the end piece. Cheese was nicely blended in the meat; not like some places that cook the meat and place the cheese on top of the meat and serve it to you. Not greasy so you don't have to worry about a soggy bottom roll. The old bay fries came out hot with just enough seasoning. The side of ranch was the perfect dipping combination. Although the restaurant will be moving to a different location, it's a good lunch option if you're in the Hershey area. Wish I would have tried this place sooner!
This is without a doubt, hands down, bar none the best steak you will find this far out of Philly. The cooper and whiz combo is next level. I wish them the best, it seems they are being forced to move locations.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best quality, service and food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Cheesesteak, Cheesesteak, Fresh Cut Fries
The real deal. Cheesesteaks and fries were delicious. I wish we lived closer, but then my pants wouldn't fit. :)
Rolls were good but were neither stuffed nor tasty. Steak meat was very big, and tough and not seasoned very well. I grew up in the Philadelphia area and was excited to hear about Philly style steaks in the area. These are not even close to what I grew up with. On top of that the parking lot is weird and not very easy to maneuver around. No need to go back
I have wanted to try this place for a while. I had a chance the other day after taking the afternoon off. I tried the cheese steak. I was happy to hear that they do not have the baine of my cheesesteak existence... sauce! I will say if you're gonna order fries it's not a takeout item. That's something you need to eat in the restaurant. The steak, however, was good. I would try it again but it's also something that can't go further than Hershey for me. If it's going to taste good.
The cheesesteaks were excellent and the service was top tier. Too bad I love so far away else I would eat here regularly.
For the price point I thought it would be sliced ribeye but no!! Very average I won't be back!
Amazing steaks and fries. But more importantly, an incredible community partner that support so many including Palmyra Athletics!Kid-friendliness: Love the food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fries, Chicken Cheesesteak, Cheesesteak
First time trying this place. We got The OG, chicken ranch and an Italian.Bread is top notch along with the ingredients. Excellent all around!!We made the 2 hour drive from Maryland, would definitely comeback.Parking: They have a few spots up front, if you need more they have some in the back, they share with the adjoining beer store
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Philly Cheese Steak
Restaurantji Recommends
Stopped here after visiting for the Blake Shelton concert. I knew they had to be good since they informed us it was a 45 minute wait for it to go order. I didn't eat mine until about six hours later and it was absolutely amazing I asked for cheese whiz and fried onions. Best cheesesteak I've had in a long time!
This place is awesome!!!! I got a chicken cheesesteak with the sharp cheddar, whiz, jalapeños and grilled onions and I was blown away. The bread was chewy and saturated with flavor. The chicken was perfectly cooked with an excellent balance of cheese and other flavors. The staff was amazing. Super friendly and extremely helpful for someone who has never been there. They have some cool sports memorabilia on the walls that you can buy. Overall, I will definitely be back again. It is absolutely worth the drive from Hershey if you are visiting. Can't wait to go back and try one of their burgers.
Had the fish & chipsOver cookedThe fries were oldThe tarter sauce was goodShould of had some Cole slaw
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Very well executed cheesesteaks! They supported a fundraiser we attended, so a portion of the proceeds went to the fundraiser. I ate the entire sandwich, it was that good! I went with a diy cooper sharp, onions and mushrooms. If I lived closer I'd be trying all their variations though. Well done Stuffd Steaks!
I've tried a lot of "Philly" cheesesteaks before and this might be the worst one I've tried in awhile. Probably about half the size of a normal cheesesteak for the same price you can get in Philly or other places around here. Super dry felt like there was no cheese on it at all.