Fellinis Pizzeria

1229 PA-51, Jefferson Hills
(412) 405-9359

Recent Reviews

Pizza Guru

Not a bad pie.

Garret Nikolich

I'm only torn because everything was delicious but I want a gas brick oven experience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Italian

Ken Z.

Fellinis does not know the size of a slice and I do wonder if the sizes in their pizza is a scam...look at this slice...and I don't have giant hands

Nicole Williams

Great food, great staff, great service!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Any Two Whole Hoagie, Wing Dings, Buffalo Chicken Fries, Hawaiian, Broccoli and Chicken, Mozzarella Sticks 5, Steak Calzone, Salad, Steak, Buffalo Chicken, Italian, Wedgies, Build Your Own Pizza - Small 12' '

Sergio Moreyra

Great staff super friendly and pizza was done within the time frame they said online. Pizza was delicious we got the combo, the cheese tasted good and all the veggies and meats were packed with flavor. My only complaint is wish the crust was a little crispier, but that’s a personal opinion, might ask for it well done next time, but overall very good pizza. Free breadsticks when you order over 30$ worth of food. Bread sticks were delicious! Garlicky, crispy outside and soft pillowy inside. Wings were decent, good spice.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Martin Hieber

It was way too expensive. Orders are usually missing a side of ranch or marinara even though you'll pay for it. Food is usually above average, but one-out-of-three times, it might be lower end concerning quality, and there's a good chance they forgot a sauce or two.I paid nearly $40 for a large 3 topping pizza (large, not XL either).

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 2

Dwayne Cox

We like the white / spinach pizza with tomatoes and fetta cheese delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jamie C

second time ordering from here- seriously some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. a little pricey but 100% worth it!!!

Christopher Clark Sr

Great food at a moderate price and very friendly and courteous service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Steak

Devin Kennedy

Delivery took over an hour with the hostess saying the delivery driver was soon to be on the

Service: 1

Ulyana K.

I'm surprised the place is so poorly rated. Yes, the seating isn't that great, and the atmosphere isn't either. But the food itself is quite good. Nothing amazing, but certainly not bad. I tried their plain cheese calzone and a brownie with caramel. The calzone was quite interesting. It's probably the greasiest calzone I've had in a while, but surprisingly, it was still really good. Most of the grease had already spilled out of the calzone by the time I bit in. It's topped with a ton of garlic, so the bread part tasted like garlic bread. It was really good. Plus, the calzone was stuffed with an adequate amount of cheese (mozzarella mostly, and a little bit of ricotta as well). Quite good. Portion size was great for the small, and price was around $14 so not too bad. Sauce on the side was sweet but cold when served. The brownie was really good. It was super fudgey and had large chunks of chocolate scattered throughout it. Very soft. It's absolutely delicious and honestly one of the best brownies I've had in a while. And, it's huge! It's like four brownies in one order for $5. All in all, I think this place is underrated. Atmosphere isn't the best, but the people are kind (they came out with my food while I was waiting in the car and were courteous). The calzone tasted like a garlic bread with cheese filling and brownie was amazing.

Lindsey Rae

Well if you have all day to waste this is the place for you, it took over an hour for them to make a very basic large pizza. This is the second time I have ordered from them, and because I like to give second chances, I ordered a second time from them. they had taken inexcusably long and the workers there are not very courteous and anyway.It seems super unorganized, that's probably their problem. The pizza is not horrible but pretty average compared to the area. It should not be this complicated to make their pizza considering their standards lol

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Gary P.

We placed an order with multiple errors. I ordered a salad and I did not even get it. My co worker ordered a gyro but got no sauce on it, and who puts a gyro on a hoagie bun?? We also order chicken boneless but got bones. We will never be ordering from this place again. But hey at least the breadsticks were ok.

Chelsea Sherman

Called owner told him what I received he refused to remake pizza don’t not order customer service

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 2

Tyler D.

Such a solid spot. Ordered medium garlic white sauce with chicken pizza. Service was so kind and personal. Place looked so classic, like from a recent homestyle bygone era. They've improved from whoever/whatever was going on a year or so ago.

Load More