The pie is incredible, and the people are better than the pie. The only thing that could improve this place is if they started selling shortbread cookies, though they’d have to change the name …
Food: 5
Service: 5
Travis Jones
I love this place. They really do have wonderful pie and coffee. I don't generally like quiche, but their breakfast quiche is amazing and I get it almost every time. The crust hits! As the kids would say...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
G. J.
Great pie
Kimberly Hall
Just stopped in to try this cute little place and must say that I will be coming back! The selection of pies are amazing. It was hard to choose just one. I will definitely return to try others in the near future!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amanda Pokrop
Literally, some of the best pie ? I have ever had!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joe Ryer
Great little hangout for pie and coffee.Bill and the gang are great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Robert Galovic
Sour cherry pie! Yummy!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Austin Strohl
The charming atmosphere and friendly owners make this a welcoming spot. Their coffee is delicious and pairs perfectly with the lemon pie. Don't miss the raspberry drizzle!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Liege Waffle
Cara Henry
First time here tonight, my husband and i had THE BEST experience! The staff was so sweet and friendly. The chocolate pb pie was delicious, so rich and creamy! My husband had the apple hand pie. Also, amazing! Flaky crust. Soft apples and warmed up just perfectly. Will definitely be back soon to try the savory pies!
Kassandra O.
My experience with Lancaster Pie & Coffee began before even entering. My husband and I were reading the sign and then when we finally headed in the owner was there opening the door for us, because he saw my husband was using a cane. Once we were inside we were met with the prettiest cafe, local art to peruse, the incredible smell of pie and the warmest smile from the woman behind the bar / register. The vibes were top notch. So what about the pie? If you call yourself a pie place the pie should be, at least- good. Well, the pie is actually quite amazing. We tried the apple, blueberry and the lemon. The lemon was the showstopper, but all three were spectacular. It felt like coming home and home is perfect and has great pie. Their hot chocolate was good and included rustic homemade marshmallows. The tea selection was fantastic. One of my favorite things (and there were many from my experience), was the quiche. I've tried the quiche in just about every establishment in downtown Lancaster that offers it- none compare to the quiche here. I ordered the Swiss mushroom and it was a revelation. I feel bad for all of the other quiche makers everywhere else. So far behind..... Overall, I was immediately love stricken with the business. They deliver on every level. And the kindness and charm of the employees, owner and hostess must not be diminished. I have a handful of businesses in downtown Lancaster I order from or frequent quite a bit and the owners who are always there are rarely ever friendly or chatty, which is fine, but I wish there was more friendliness. Pie & Coffee has amazing food, fantastic pies and beverages and then the staff is so welcoming and sweet. It's all the things.
I've visited this Lanc City gem twice now and both times, I have left 1. impressed with the delicious food 2. having a personalized experience thanks to the sweet management! The owner, Bill, made my waffle (do not sneeze at waffles at a pie establishment! It was seriously the best waffle I've ever had) with an off-the-menu chocolate ganache and kindly delivered it to my table. What a sweet touch. And on my second visit, he made me laugh by photo bombing (you can see in my video). The cafe is tastefully decorated with pie-themed artwork and is a cozy spot with an incredible view of a beautiful tree and morning sunlight (if you choose to dine by the window). Besides coffee, waffles, and dessert pies, you can order quiche or savory pies like Chicken or Brisket or CRAB (a special they had today) which come with a side salad! I can't wait to return and try more of their menu.
Michael Davenport
Fantastic little gem ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Apple Pie
Patrick Denny
Great place and great people. Such an unexpected cute gem in a quick trip to Lancaster.We had the apple pie a la mode and some hot cider to go with it. The pie was a perfect fresh after-dinner dessert.The owners were lovely, funny, engaging— and you could tell they were passionate about their service and the community. Everybody should mark this on your list— best dessert in town!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Blueberry Pie, Apple Pie
Steve Donahue
What a great place! I had heard the pies were off the charts. They didn’t disappoint! Great coffee and hot chocolate too. Thanks to owners Tara and Bill for being so welcoming! I highly recommend a stop in here when in Lancaster.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cherry Pie, Blueberry Pie, Apple Pie
Dannielle Sturgeon
Visited from Baltimore. This place blows our local options out of the water. Lancaster Pie and Coffee will be a staple in our future visits to Lancaster.We had the lemon silk and mixed berry pies. Both were amazing!
The pie is incredible, and the people are better than the pie. The only thing that could improve this place is if they started selling shortbread cookies, though they’d have to change the name …
Food: 5
Service: 5
I love this place. They really do have wonderful pie and coffee. I don't generally like quiche, but their breakfast quiche is amazing and I get it almost every time. The crust hits! As the kids would say...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pie
Just stopped in to try this cute little place and must say that I will be coming back! The selection of pies are amazing. It was hard to choose just one. I will definitely return to try others in the near future!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Literally, some of the best pie ? I have ever had!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great little hangout for pie and coffee.Bill and the gang are great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sour cherry pie! Yummy!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The charming atmosphere and friendly owners make this a welcoming spot. Their coffee is delicious and pairs perfectly with the lemon pie. Don't miss the raspberry drizzle!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Liege Waffle
First time here tonight, my husband and i had THE BEST experience! The staff was so sweet and friendly. The chocolate pb pie was delicious, so rich and creamy! My husband had the apple hand pie. Also, amazing! Flaky crust. Soft apples and warmed up just perfectly. Will definitely be back soon to try the savory pies!
My experience with Lancaster Pie & Coffee began before even entering. My husband and I were reading the sign and then when we finally headed in the owner was there opening the door for us, because he saw my husband was using a cane. Once we were inside we were met with the prettiest cafe, local art to peruse, the incredible smell of pie and the warmest smile from the woman behind the bar / register. The vibes were top notch. So what about the pie? If you call yourself a pie place the pie should be, at least- good. Well, the pie is actually quite amazing. We tried the apple, blueberry and the lemon. The lemon was the showstopper, but all three were spectacular. It felt like coming home and home is perfect and has great pie. Their hot chocolate was good and included rustic homemade marshmallows. The tea selection was fantastic. One of my favorite things (and there were many from my experience), was the quiche. I've tried the quiche in just about every establishment in downtown Lancaster that offers it- none compare to the quiche here. I ordered the Swiss mushroom and it was a revelation. I feel bad for all of the other quiche makers everywhere else. So far behind..... Overall, I was immediately love stricken with the business. They deliver on every level. And the kindness and charm of the employees, owner and hostess must not be diminished. I have a handful of businesses in downtown Lancaster I order from or frequent quite a bit and the owners who are always there are rarely ever friendly or chatty, which is fine, but I wish there was more friendliness. Pie & Coffee has amazing food, fantastic pies and beverages and then the staff is so welcoming and sweet. It's all the things.
Restaurantji Recommends
I've visited this Lanc City gem twice now and both times, I have left 1. impressed with the delicious food 2. having a personalized experience thanks to the sweet management! The owner, Bill, made my waffle (do not sneeze at waffles at a pie establishment! It was seriously the best waffle I've ever had) with an off-the-menu chocolate ganache and kindly delivered it to my table. What a sweet touch. And on my second visit, he made me laugh by photo bombing (you can see in my video). The cafe is tastefully decorated with pie-themed artwork and is a cozy spot with an incredible view of a beautiful tree and morning sunlight (if you choose to dine by the window). Besides coffee, waffles, and dessert pies, you can order quiche or savory pies like Chicken or Brisket or CRAB (a special they had today) which come with a side salad! I can't wait to return and try more of their menu.
Fantastic little gem ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Apple Pie
Great place and great people. Such an unexpected cute gem in a quick trip to Lancaster.We had the apple pie a la mode and some hot cider to go with it. The pie was a perfect fresh after-dinner dessert.The owners were lovely, funny, engaging— and you could tell they were passionate about their service and the community. Everybody should mark this on your list— best dessert in town!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Blueberry Pie, Apple Pie
What a great place! I had heard the pies were off the charts. They didn’t disappoint! Great coffee and hot chocolate too. Thanks to owners Tara and Bill for being so welcoming! I highly recommend a stop in here when in Lancaster.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cherry Pie, Blueberry Pie, Apple Pie
Visited from Baltimore. This place blows our local options out of the water. Lancaster Pie and Coffee will be a staple in our future visits to Lancaster.We had the lemon silk and mixed berry pies. Both were amazing!