It was our first time getting a pizza here. I always like to get a plain cheese pizza from a new place. If you can’t do a plain pizza right you have got some issues. With that said I found the pizza be unique and delicious. We will definitely be going back!
JOHN MCLAUGHLIN JR
Fantastic pizzas, the phone answering needs a little polish !
Carley Graham
Don’t order a margherita pizza. We love Steel Peel’s Neopolitan but trying something different back fired.
jida ooj
Alot of weird flavored pizzas on counter. I guess they want u to try new stuff, but it just looks old n dry. Too much like leftovers
Wayne Pizano
Recently got a Caesar salad and all the cheese was moldy. Usually a great place, but a little weary now. I called to tell them and all I got was an “okay”.
Randy Sosa
A GOOD PLACE TO ENJOY GOOD FOOD AND SPEND A RELAXING TIME... COURTEOUS STAFF.. LOVE THIS ESTABLISHMENT
Chris R.
Pizza was excellent. So we're the toppings. We had the plain, garlic butter parm cheesesteak, sausage and pepperoni. The pepperoni pizza had TONS of pepperoni
Debra B.
This is my favorite pizza. Always great. Love all the veggie combos. I also appreciate all the caution they have taken during the pandemic.
Kasi A.
Husband and I came in last night for some food before heading out. We came in around 630 and it was pretty dead, but slowly picked up. Most people were coming in for take out orders. A lot of college kids coming in to grab a slice. We had the Mac and cheese pizza and an order of wings. The pizza was phenomenal. The flavor was so good. It was also a hearty piece and the chicken on it was an added bonus. The wings were good and large for boneless wings. We couldn't finish them because we were so full. The pizza was def the winner though. Service was fast and friendly and for everything plus a fountain soda we paid $20 which is very good. The only thing I didn't care for was the sign that said "no refills on the fountain soda" which I thought was odd but maybe it was a COVID thing? Would return for pizza!
Jennifer Jumbelick
These people are awesome!!! They made a special pizza for me that was gluten free and dairy free!!! It tasted perfect.
Overall the ingredients are good quality. However I ordered pasta twice and the amount of salt was overwhelming both times. Like a bucket of salt taste. I think you need to evaluate this as it is so strong it is almost a hazard. Salads are perfect though.
quiet storm
omg the best ? im from jersey i could not find any good places to go out here in Lancaster to get good pizza and cheesestak It was like a needle in a haystack to find ? this place yes ? i will keep ordering from steel peel pizza ?
CM A.
Decided last minute mid-week we didn't want to cook and Steel Peel did not disappoint. We got one of the specialty pizzas and it was DELISH!
Kayla Danielle
It’s been a long time since I’ve gotten delivery pizza that was too hot to eat. Also, the boardwalk pizza sauce is perfect- slightly sweet and full of flavor. This place is climbing to my favorite pizza spot quickly!
Jeff Dave
Really good pizza and cheesesteaks .. like really really good ...
It was our first time getting a pizza here. I always like to get a plain cheese pizza from a new place. If you can’t do a plain pizza right you have got some issues. With that said I found the pizza be unique and delicious. We will definitely be going back!
Fantastic pizzas, the phone answering needs a little polish !
Don’t order a margherita pizza. We love Steel Peel’s Neopolitan but trying something different back fired.
Alot of weird flavored pizzas on counter. I guess they want u to try new stuff, but it just looks old n dry. Too much like leftovers
Recently got a Caesar salad and all the cheese was moldy. Usually a great place, but a little weary now. I called to tell them and all I got was an “okay”.
A GOOD PLACE TO ENJOY GOOD FOOD AND SPEND A RELAXING TIME... COURTEOUS STAFF.. LOVE THIS ESTABLISHMENT
Pizza was excellent. So we're the toppings. We had the plain, garlic butter parm cheesesteak, sausage and pepperoni. The pepperoni pizza had TONS of pepperoni
This is my favorite pizza. Always great. Love all the veggie combos. I also appreciate all the caution they have taken during the pandemic.
Husband and I came in last night for some food before heading out. We came in around 630 and it was pretty dead, but slowly picked up. Most people were coming in for take out orders. A lot of college kids coming in to grab a slice. We had the Mac and cheese pizza and an order of wings. The pizza was phenomenal. The flavor was so good. It was also a hearty piece and the chicken on it was an added bonus. The wings were good and large for boneless wings. We couldn't finish them because we were so full. The pizza was def the winner though. Service was fast and friendly and for everything plus a fountain soda we paid $20 which is very good. The only thing I didn't care for was the sign that said "no refills on the fountain soda" which I thought was odd but maybe it was a COVID thing? Would return for pizza!
These people are awesome!!! They made a special pizza for me that was gluten free and dairy free!!! It tasted perfect.
Restaurantji Recommends
Overall the ingredients are good quality. However I ordered pasta twice and the amount of salt was overwhelming both times. Like a bucket of salt taste. I think you need to evaluate this as it is so strong it is almost a hazard. Salads are perfect though.
omg the best ? im from jersey i could not find any good places to go out here in Lancaster to get good pizza and cheesestak It was like a needle in a haystack to find ? this place yes ? i will keep ordering from steel peel pizza ?
Decided last minute mid-week we didn't want to cook and Steel Peel did not disappoint. We got one of the specialty pizzas and it was DELISH!
It’s been a long time since I’ve gotten delivery pizza that was too hot to eat. Also, the boardwalk pizza sauce is perfect- slightly sweet and full of flavor. This place is climbing to my favorite pizza spot quickly!
Really good pizza and cheesesteaks .. like really really good ...