I wasn't very happy with my service today, ordered a few slices of pepperoni, they looked good in the case and was excited to try it. What I got though was not what I thought I was ordering. Apparently there is big pepperoni and small pepperoni (which was never explained nor was I asked which I wanted), the big pepperoni has far less on a slice and either way I wasn't happy that I didn't get what I was expecting. I asked the owner, as I was confused at the time and shared my displeasure with what I received, to be fair I didn't ask for him to remake the slices I thought I was getting but I made it apparent that I wasn't happy and as an owner you need to be able to read the situation and make the offer to remake it. It might seem like a little thing but because of this situation I wouldn't go back. The pizza was decent, nothing amazing but not the worst I've had in the area either.
Food: 3
Service: 1
Deborah Jesic
Great food, but I don't like when food service places touch dirty money or credit cards, then handle my food! You either have a check out person in front doing transactions and have the other's handling the food, 2 yrs ago I ate there and I know for a fact I got covid.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
JB
Always great pizza coming out of this place, some of the best food you can get at the market. Always fresh ingredients. Stopped in today and ordered a pizza, took a little bit longer than usual as they were getting crushed with orders. Over heard other patrons complaing that they had to wait an extra 10 minutes for they're pie. what I will say is GET OVER IT! They have one oven, this isn't your big box pizza shop you'll get your pie, and it will be better than any other pizza in the area! Order when you come in and spend sometime with the other vendors. Shout out to the Casero staff you folks do a great job, keep up the hard work! Cheers!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza
Samuel Ortega
Pizza was GREAT! It took a while to get my order but it was def worth the wait. Best pizza in Harrisburg for sure.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Christie Carr
Normally, I visit the Broad Street Market in Harrisburg. Since the recent fire I decided to travel across the river and visit the WS farmers market. Decided to give this place a try after admiring their beautiful pizzas on display not to mention the long line was a sure sign that the pizza would be delicious. It was delicious! So good my oldest asked for it again the following day. So I drug a few other family members with me and we picked up 2 pies to bring home. We are all now instant fans. It reminds me of the thin crust old-school pizza you would find in Philadelphia. Give it a try, they have a great variety of pies to please all pizza lovers.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ikeoikeo ME
Was wondering why there is always a long line here. My son and I said "what the heck let's try it"! We got the Roma. OMG! The cheese just pulls when you bite it! Sauce is flavorful! This is now our favorite pizza and will be getting a whole pie tomorrow!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Renee Long
Hands down BEST Pizza I have ever had. Detroit Deep Dish...wow, lobster ravioli, shrimp and crab ravioli, skewers....breads...wow! Everything's fresh....take and make....Tasty!!! Thank you for the market convenience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
David Heckard
Saturday we were in the market and my son wanted a slice so we stopped. That pizza was amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rachel Campbell
Pizza was delicious. I had the thin crusty. It was crispy but not overdone. I didn't wait long at all but I also picked up my order at 11:00 on a Friday.
Delicious. Love the thin and crispy crust. Excellent quality of ingredients. 2 slices were almost too much for me as each slice is a really decent size. The staff is also lovely. I will definitely be a repeat customer
thetaco lover
Best pizza in the entire area!!My entire family loves this place!!
Kyle Patton
Absolutely the greatest pizza you'll have ! just taste different that makes it better than everywhere else. I go out of my way just to get their pizza every Friday!
Jackie Lane
I been to all different states and places and this by far is the absolutely the best pizza I ever had..My hubby is funny about pizza but this 1,he loves.Indrive 40mins just to get it and they r only open 3days a week
Nicole
WOW. Best pizza joint I've been too in a long time. Thin crust, good on the sauce, lots of cheese, not over-seasoned. The only disappointment is that I didn't find this spot sooner. It is located in the West Shore farmer's market, FYI. I got an XL plain pizza for about $18 and some change, not bad. The wait is about 20-25 minutes, but you can call ahead. You could also go shop and then stop back at their stand for pick up. Definitely, really, really, really good pizza.
I wasn't very happy with my service today, ordered a few slices of pepperoni, they looked good in the case and was excited to try it. What I got though was not what I thought I was ordering. Apparently there is big pepperoni and small pepperoni (which was never explained nor was I asked which I wanted), the big pepperoni has far less on a slice and either way I wasn't happy that I didn't get what I was expecting. I asked the owner, as I was confused at the time and shared my displeasure with what I received, to be fair I didn't ask for him to remake the slices I thought I was getting but I made it apparent that I wasn't happy and as an owner you need to be able to read the situation and make the offer to remake it. It might seem like a little thing but because of this situation I wouldn't go back. The pizza was decent, nothing amazing but not the worst I've had in the area either.
Food: 3
Service: 1
Great food, but I don't like when food service places touch dirty money or credit cards, then handle my food! You either have a check out person in front doing transactions and have the other's handling the food, 2 yrs ago I ate there and I know for a fact I got covid.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Always great pizza coming out of this place, some of the best food you can get at the market. Always fresh ingredients. Stopped in today and ordered a pizza, took a little bit longer than usual as they were getting crushed with orders. Over heard other patrons complaing that they had to wait an extra 10 minutes for they're pie. what I will say is GET OVER IT! They have one oven, this isn't your big box pizza shop you'll get your pie, and it will be better than any other pizza in the area! Order when you come in and spend sometime with the other vendors. Shout out to the Casero staff you folks do a great job, keep up the hard work! Cheers!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza
Pizza was GREAT! It took a while to get my order but it was def worth the wait. Best pizza in Harrisburg for sure.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Normally, I visit the Broad Street Market in Harrisburg. Since the recent fire I decided to travel across the river and visit the WS farmers market. Decided to give this place a try after admiring their beautiful pizzas on display not to mention the long line was a sure sign that the pizza would be delicious. It was delicious! So good my oldest asked for it again the following day. So I drug a few other family members with me and we picked up 2 pies to bring home. We are all now instant fans. It reminds me of the thin crust old-school pizza you would find in Philadelphia. Give it a try, they have a great variety of pies to please all pizza lovers.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Was wondering why there is always a long line here. My son and I said "what the heck let's try it"! We got the Roma. OMG! The cheese just pulls when you bite it! Sauce is flavorful! This is now our favorite pizza and will be getting a whole pie tomorrow!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hands down BEST Pizza I have ever had. Detroit Deep Dish...wow, lobster ravioli, shrimp and crab ravioli, skewers....breads...wow! Everything's fresh....take and make....Tasty!!! Thank you for the market convenience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Saturday we were in the market and my son wanted a slice so we stopped. That pizza was amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza was delicious. I had the thin crusty. It was crispy but not overdone. I didn't wait long at all but I also picked up my order at 11:00 on a Friday.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best pizza!! Never disappointed.
Restaurantji Recommends
Delicious. Love the thin and crispy crust. Excellent quality of ingredients. 2 slices were almost too much for me as each slice is a really decent size. The staff is also lovely. I will definitely be a repeat customer
Best pizza in the entire area!!My entire family loves this place!!
Absolutely the greatest pizza you'll have ! just taste different that makes it better than everywhere else. I go out of my way just to get their pizza every Friday!
I been to all different states and places and this by far is the absolutely the best pizza I ever had..My hubby is funny about pizza but this 1,he loves.Indrive 40mins just to get it and they r only open 3days a week
WOW. Best pizza joint I've been too in a long time. Thin crust, good on the sauce, lots of cheese, not over-seasoned. The only disappointment is that I didn't find this spot sooner. It is located in the West Shore farmer's market, FYI. I got an XL plain pizza for about $18 and some change, not bad. The wait is about 20-25 minutes, but you can call ahead. You could also go shop and then stop back at their stand for pick up. Definitely, really, really, really good pizza.