18 Best Pizza Restaurants near Mcsherrystown

“Love seeing a place that is well ran. Immediately get fast service and good food. Been coming here since I was little but now as an adult seem like it’s ran very well! Always a super nice girl up front and pizza is always made right. Never floppy and always has flavor. Tried a cheesesteak from here for the first time the other day. Was super impressed. Definitely keep this spot in ur mind if u want good pizza around hanover!“

“This was our first time here, and we were thoroughly impressed.We were greeted at the door by a smell of cleaning product which makes you feel good about how well a place is kept up. The interior was trendy and well lit. The place was very clean and organized.The server was tremendous. He was friendly, knowledgeable, and helpful when it came to choosing our entrees.The food was the show stopper. Everything was fresh, full of flavor, and well crafted on the plate. There is a great variety of dishes to chose from and even something for vegetarians.Overall great experience!!“

“Delicious food! I recently ordered their new Roberto Pasta (pictured) it was so good. The sweet sausage and sauce were perfect! All their other food is always on point whether you choose one of their subs, pizza, or dinner options! Highly recommend.“

“The gentlemen who work here are SO NICE & welcoming! The pizza was fantastic and actually had seasoning (most cheese pizza around here is just lacking in flavor overall). This is the BEST pizza in the area by far. Perfect temperature and melty cheese but not enough to just slide completely off the slice. I will order here again for sure and try other menu items!“

“As Maryland transplants, my husband and I have spent 2 years trying to find pizza we really liked in the Hanover area. We found it here! We got the Sergios Old Fashioned pizza and it was delicious. The sauce was excellent, with just a hint of spice and the crust was just thin enough to stay a little crispy without getting soggy. The cheesesteak was juicy and cheesy, but not greasy, and the roll it was served on was fresh and nicely toasted. The service was excellent and friendly. Looking forward to trying other menu items.“

“This is a great place to stop. We've driven by many times and finally made the visit. This Family owned and operated business takes great care in preparing their food. The homemade fries are out of this world! Golden and delicious. There are two roll options to consider. Amoroso or Maier's. . We had the Cheesesteak on the Amoroso and the Italian Sub on the Maier's. Each Family Member seemed to watch over all of us in the Dining Room. There are many other options as well. We will never pass by without stopping again.“

“Absolutely delicious. I spoke to the owner who was the nicest guy ever. We talked today about different pizza shops and he was very personable and the pizza was better than A&M in Lebanon PA I must say I was highly surprised A&M was beat but very happy that I brought a whole pizza home. I work for the county and he noticed our van parked out in the parking lot and we just got to talking about what his definition of best pizza and he was telling me how he ate pizza everyday of his life since he was a young boy and I must say when I took the pizza home the Italian white pizza my daughter tried it and she has been bugging me to go back and it's a little drive for us so I told her the next time I travel up that way I will for sure grab a pizza so that's my plan this is the best pizza I've had in a very very long time“

“We have ordered their pizza several times and it's always consistently delicious!!!! It's a very nice place to sit down and have dinner and the owners are very nice people. So happy we have this right around the corner from us!!!!“

“I can not say enough how absolutely delicious the cheesesteak and Italian subs were that we bought today! The staff was friendly, the service was quick and the restaurant was clean and not run down. I didn't think to take pics because I anticipated it to be the same as every other sub shop. Stop in and give them a try!“

“Honestly, the best pizza I had in a long time! And these cheese frie...sooo good. My favorite, gooey gold.The lady taking our order was awesome. You order upfront, and pay before you go. She was awesome, gave us suggestions on our food. Got us a box before I even had a chance to ask. On top of all that, they were busy, but she still had time for us.Parking: There's two spots out front, but a whole lot out back“

“The pizza here is excellent. The cheese steaks are better. And my favorite meal is the salmon with lump crab meat. If you like fish you gotta try it. It's so good. I gave 5 stars because this place deserves it. Now the pasta meals are hot or miss. Anything with noodle I personally believe. My mom and dad recently tried the pasta and didn't like it either. Lacks flavor. Their other meals are very good.“

“I attended a shrimp feed there tonight. The food was excellent. They had french fries, fried chicken, Maryland crab soup, steamed shrimp, veggies with dip, corn on the cob, cold salads, and cookies. We stuck around for a while after the feed and listened to the DJ. Nice crowd, but not overly full.“

“W.York and East Berlin very clean restaurant and also great service. Food is always ready in the time they tell you when you order by phone for pick up. Pleasant to sit and eat in also. Nice customer service always friendly. Delicious food, personally I’ve never been disappointed in any of the food I’ve ordered.“

“My family & I have been enjoying Genova's meals for over 20 years. They have served us on very special occasions, they have been the treat we send to local law enforcement & fire fighters as a thank you. It may be a hectic day/ week, we know they will be polite, consistently delicious and timely. They send us a Christmas gift card!!! In these times, to be a cherished customer is incredible!!!! * The lovely Babette will never stear you wrong if you have questions or need a suggestion. Truly, our family looks forward to their comfort food as if it was baked by our own relatives. Some of our favorites to order are the cheese steak sub, (freshly baked bread!) Veggie sub, any of the appetizers are great, the pizza- yumm, and lately...the chicken parm meal 1/2 red ,1/2 alfredo on angel hair DELICIOUS!Thank you Vita, Babette, your entire staffSincerely, 3234 MainVegetarian options: My hubby gets the veggie sub, loves itKid-friendliness: We have three very unique kiddos with individual special needs..the staff spoil us rotten“

“Chips and salsa to start (hot). We ordered steak tacos Sour Cream*, steak quesi tacos, kids steak tacos, cheese quesadillas, steak quesadillas, 3-pupusas (chicken, pork and loroco) pickled cabbage and tomato sauce on the side. Everything was delicious. Waiter was very helpful with explaining dishes unfamiliar to us. Family friendly.“

“I don’t typically leave reviews, but I just feel like Donatello’s deserves more than 5 stars. My first visit was a little after 8pm last week and they closed at 9. I felt bad being it was close to them closing but the employee greeted me with a smile and was thrilled to take my order. I have never been here, so I didn’t know what to expect. What I didn’t expect was to find my new all time favorite pizza shop. I got the stuffed Italian meat lovers pizza, blew me away. Hands down the best pizza I’ve had in central Pennsylvania. I’ve been back multiple times and I can’t recommend this restaurant enough. If you haven’t tried it, you should definitely plan a visit! I also live 30 minutes away, I happily make the drive knowing I’m getting quality food and such a friendly staff. 50/10 I recommend.“

“Man I can't say enough wonderful things here about this pizza shop. Everytime I go in I forget to take pictures off the masterpieces on the secret menu the cook makes so that I can make everyone else jealous. So often I see couples who return weekly or more it warms my heart to know the local support a small business gets. Clearly they must do well by how many people the owners know by name!A Must Stop family owned restaurant.“

“We have ordered their pizza several times and it's always consistently delicious!!!! It's a very nice place to sit down and have dinner and the owners are very nice people. So happy we have this right around the corner from us!!!!“