Called on the phone to a woman who could barely speak English and was constantly 'mistaking" our order for more expensive items on the menu. We ordered one large cheese pizza, and she tried to upsell us multiple times to get stuffed crust, then to buy wings, etc.Finally we caved and got stuffed crust- she did not tell us it cost extra- but she charged us for "Xtra garlic stuffed crust" we got a plain stuffed crust pizza that was undercooked in the middle and not garlicky at all.30 bucks for an undercooked pizza and some bread sticks?? Outrageous.Go here if you want to get upsold and then scammed. ?
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Avey Henderson
I mean I believe this picture speaks for itself. Like it’s not even halfway full and that’s what you’re advertising on the app? But yet I get just a layer, barely. Lmao. Just sad and inconsistent. And I’m supposed to be full off of this ?? Papa and John need to do something about this cause the workers ain’t doing it.
Food: 1
Ben Richards
Please save yourself the time and go to a gas station for better pizza. I typed a respectable review which bashed this location and then decided to delete it and save anyone reading this the time. Pizza quality is garbage, wings are garbage. Thanks for the credit, which was used as a second chance, and again everything was garbage. Honestly, risk the chance of food borne illness and go with food from the Exxon down the road.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Rebeckah Reisinger
Only order from here if you want to wait 2 hours for food and then receive it cold!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Danielle Reitz
Two hours for delivery and didn’t even end up getting our food. Terrible service every time we order.Would 100% NOT recommend ever ordering from this location.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Stephanie Gibson
I placed an order 1 min before close and I didn’t think I would get it but I’m so glad I ordered. My food was Hot,Fresh,Tasty. Amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Cheese Pizza
Asona-Le Aponte
I placed an order for delivery through the app and waited an hour just for them to void my order because they “got a call that it was a prank order” and when I called about it the delivery driver said that he knocked on my door twice but couldn’t even tell me what door he knocked on.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Mary Bennet
I placed and order tonight the women who answered the phone was very friendly and nice when taking my order.The delivery came quicker then the estimated time.The delivery guy was a sweetheart very polite also.The pizza was fresh and hot will
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wayne Beach
This store and more importantly- the staff - was outstanding and very service oriented - I was so pleased. They responded and assisted me, quickly when I needed fast service. Without having to ask- their service was refreshing!!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Cheese Pizza
Karen Niles
Ordered 3 pizzas, all regular crust. 1 was very thin, crispy and dried out! The other 2 had very little sauce sparce meat. ( one was pepperoni the other sausage). We were very disappointed in this order. Sure not like the Papa John's in Carlisle!!
Went above and beyond to fix what appeared to be a technology glitch, great service and friendly.
Robert Steinmetz
Abdi, corie, Matt we’re very friendly great customer service will be back again.
Maria Wright
Thursday night my husband and I ordered through the app. Originally for delivery, but Cody helped us change to pick up since it was going to take 70-90 minutes. There was a little confusion when my husband went to pick it up. They were slam packed, but Cody and Jason were still super pleasant and did their best to help us with our order. Thanks guys!P.s. the Shaqaroni is my new favorite pizza
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dennis Kohler
Without a doubt the worst horrible pizza I've ever eaten ,even my dog wouldn't eat it!!!!!!!! It was a thin crust pizza the box would have been more appetizing¡!!!
Moe B.
Order tracker showed my order as ready. When I got there I was told my pizza is still in the oven. I only had to wait 5 minutes so that's not bad. However, I wish that was the only issue. When I got home and opened the box I was so disappointed. I ordered a pizza with bbq sauce, Canadian bacon and chicken. 1st issue, there wasn't any chicken. 2nd issue there was so much dough not covered with sauce or topping. If you're able to zoom in on my pictures take a look. It's a shame I wasted my money here. I'll stick with the ma and pa shops.
Called on the phone to a woman who could barely speak English and was constantly 'mistaking" our order for more expensive items on the menu. We ordered one large cheese pizza, and she tried to upsell us multiple times to get stuffed crust, then to buy wings, etc.Finally we caved and got stuffed crust- she did not tell us it cost extra- but she charged us for "Xtra garlic stuffed crust" we got a plain stuffed crust pizza that was undercooked in the middle and not garlicky at all.30 bucks for an undercooked pizza and some bread sticks?? Outrageous.Go here if you want to get upsold and then scammed. ?
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I mean I believe this picture speaks for itself. Like it’s not even halfway full and that’s what you’re advertising on the app? But yet I get just a layer, barely. Lmao. Just sad and inconsistent. And I’m supposed to be full off of this ?? Papa and John need to do something about this cause the workers ain’t doing it.
Food: 1
Please save yourself the time and go to a gas station for better pizza. I typed a respectable review which bashed this location and then decided to delete it and save anyone reading this the time. Pizza quality is garbage, wings are garbage. Thanks for the credit, which was used as a second chance, and again everything was garbage. Honestly, risk the chance of food borne illness and go with food from the Exxon down the road.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Only order from here if you want to wait 2 hours for food and then receive it cold!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Two hours for delivery and didn’t even end up getting our food. Terrible service every time we order.Would 100% NOT recommend ever ordering from this location.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I placed an order 1 min before close and I didn’t think I would get it but I’m so glad I ordered. My food was Hot,Fresh,Tasty. Amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Cheese Pizza
I placed an order for delivery through the app and waited an hour just for them to void my order because they “got a call that it was a prank order” and when I called about it the delivery driver said that he knocked on my door twice but couldn’t even tell me what door he knocked on.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I placed and order tonight the women who answered the phone was very friendly and nice when taking my order.The delivery came quicker then the estimated time.The delivery guy was a sweetheart very polite also.The pizza was fresh and hot will
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This store and more importantly- the staff - was outstanding and very service oriented - I was so pleased. They responded and assisted me, quickly when I needed fast service. Without having to ask- their service was refreshing!!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Cheese Pizza
Ordered 3 pizzas, all regular crust. 1 was very thin, crispy and dried out! The other 2 had very little sauce sparce meat. ( one was pepperoni the other sausage). We were very disappointed in this order. Sure not like the Papa John's in Carlisle!!
Restaurantji Recommends
Went above and beyond to fix what appeared to be a technology glitch, great service and friendly.
Abdi, corie, Matt we’re very friendly great customer service will be back again.
Thursday night my husband and I ordered through the app. Originally for delivery, but Cody helped us change to pick up since it was going to take 70-90 minutes. There was a little confusion when my husband went to pick it up. They were slam packed, but Cody and Jason were still super pleasant and did their best to help us with our order. Thanks guys!P.s. the Shaqaroni is my new favorite pizza
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Without a doubt the worst horrible pizza I've ever eaten ,even my dog wouldn't eat it!!!!!!!! It was a thin crust pizza the box would have been more appetizing¡!!!
Order tracker showed my order as ready. When I got there I was told my pizza is still in the oven. I only had to wait 5 minutes so that's not bad. However, I wish that was the only issue. When I got home and opened the box I was so disappointed. I ordered a pizza with bbq sauce, Canadian bacon and chicken. 1st issue, there wasn't any chicken. 2nd issue there was so much dough not covered with sauce or topping. If you're able to zoom in on my pictures take a look. It's a shame I wasted my money here. I'll stick with the ma and pa shops.