The Italian restaurant is great. We just love the pizza, no grease on them and the dinner meal is plentiful plus subs and steak sandwiches. The customer service is also pleasant and helpful, our go-to place when we don't want to cook or need something
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Monica Rivera
Quality of the food is great. The service is great. They will go above and beyond to meet your expectations with the meals and service. Family friendly atmosphere. Will come here again and definitely recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mary Ann Mcgee
I heard the pizza was great picked up a sausage and red pepper pizza 16 inch it was salty and very soggy will not order again very disappointed ?
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
shakie Pete
I just try to order over the phone and the guy got mad and hung up the phone because I asked him if he just started working there because he kept going back to ask if they had or sell what I was ordering. I was working with him until I asked him that. I guess I hurt his feelings.
Service: 1
Lizz Kline
Went once about a year ago and the food wasn’t all that great. Figured I’d give it a second chance and regret doing so.While the pizzas themselves, the meat lovers and the primavera, were good flavor wise and had a generous amount of toppings, the crust just wasn’t hitting. Tastes like it either comes frozen or they make it, freeze it then use it when needed. Doesn’t look like a “fresh” made crust and was suspiciously perfectly round to be fresh made. Last time we got food we got a Sicilian pie and I watched them take pre-made crust out and use it for my pizza. Gave them the benefit of the doubt that they only used it for the Sicilian, but I truly don’t think that’s the case. For what we paid, there are better pizza places in town and only went to Midtown because our normal place was closed and wanted to give them a second chance.I will say, the fries I ordered were very good and you get a huge portion for the price. Give that classic Boardwalk Fries vibe and would be great with salt and vinegar.Hoping they can improve their crust for future customers, as we more than likely won’t be returning.EDIT: if this was an “intentional bad review” I wouldn’t have said the pizzas were good other than the crust. The pizzas were not made in front of me, as I placed the order, left and then came back to pick them up. As I said, flavor was good, topping were generous, but the crust just doesn’t taste like it’s fresh in my opinion.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
In P.
Ordered 2 pizzas, 1 meat lovers and 1 primavera pizza. Also got fries which were portioned way more than expected! You can definitely share with someone else and it'd be more than enough! The meat lover pie wasn't bad by any means. This pie was of the thin crust variety that you'd get from a frozen pizza. The primavera pizza wasn't bad either but the crust was just a bit too thin and didn't really pack that "fresh" made punch that other pizza shops in town deliver. 30$ for these two pizzas and fries. Not bad for the price but, would take my money elsewhere for better pizza!
Fawn Bennett
Extremely disappointed! Midtown has been a staple pizza place in Middletown since I was young.... pizza and subs were bland. Pizza was undercooked and greasy af! Will not return!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Kristen Schreiber
This restaurant needs to be inspected. The bathrooms are not only out of code, but filthy and have a sour smell that can be detected from the tables nearby. Water from the soda machine tasted like chemicals, back dining area and kitchen area were unclean. I threw out the food I ordered and left without eating.
Jordan Hitchens
Great food ..Very impressed with the customer service..Very quick and delicious food..Also well priced..These guys deserve a raise..Parking: Great location easy access
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Lover's Pizza
Jeremiah Gipe
Cheese steaks are amazing. I highly recommend them!
Waited 20 minutes pasted order pick up time for my pizza to look like this. cheese was half slid of the pizza and was barely
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
B Walters
The inside of this restaurant was bigger than it looks from the outside. The food we ordered was pretty good as well as the price. We were able to order via the lunch special...quite a bit of food for the price especially nowadays. My half Italian sub n fries w/drink was pretty good. He ordered a breaded chicken sandwich also w/ fries n drink....although his fries were cold but they replaced them with no problem ?. The staff were very accommodating. The only thing missing was some background music ???it was fairly quiet. We'll definitely be back????.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Nyla Cruz
The loaded fries are awful it literally tastes so sour like the cheese was completely bad. I never thought cheese could taste like that and this place has made me never want to buy loaded fries AGAIN.
Jasmine Burgos
So disappointed pizza was completely destroyed when I got home they blame it on me he knew what he done plus I live 5 minutes from there if anyone gets pizza check it before you leave they didn’t want to refund or give me a new
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Brianna Pinkney
This place has went completely downhill in the last three years. The people running this place are careless and rude. I just got blamed for my own order being messed up lol completely ridiculous. Do yourself a favor and don’t order from here.
The Italian restaurant is great. We just love the pizza, no grease on them and the dinner meal is plentiful plus subs and steak sandwiches. The customer service is also pleasant and helpful, our go-to place when we don't want to cook or need something
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Quality of the food is great. The service is great. They will go above and beyond to meet your expectations with the meals and service. Family friendly atmosphere. Will come here again and definitely recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I heard the pizza was great picked up a sausage and red pepper pizza 16 inch it was salty and very soggy will not order again very disappointed ?
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
I just try to order over the phone and the guy got mad and hung up the phone because I asked him if he just started working there because he kept going back to ask if they had or sell what I was ordering. I was working with him until I asked him that. I guess I hurt his feelings.
Service: 1
Went once about a year ago and the food wasn’t all that great. Figured I’d give it a second chance and regret doing so.While the pizzas themselves, the meat lovers and the primavera, were good flavor wise and had a generous amount of toppings, the crust just wasn’t hitting. Tastes like it either comes frozen or they make it, freeze it then use it when needed. Doesn’t look like a “fresh” made crust and was suspiciously perfectly round to be fresh made. Last time we got food we got a Sicilian pie and I watched them take pre-made crust out and use it for my pizza. Gave them the benefit of the doubt that they only used it for the Sicilian, but I truly don’t think that’s the case. For what we paid, there are better pizza places in town and only went to Midtown because our normal place was closed and wanted to give them a second chance.I will say, the fries I ordered were very good and you get a huge portion for the price. Give that classic Boardwalk Fries vibe and would be great with salt and vinegar.Hoping they can improve their crust for future customers, as we more than likely won’t be returning.EDIT: if this was an “intentional bad review” I wouldn’t have said the pizzas were good other than the crust. The pizzas were not made in front of me, as I placed the order, left and then came back to pick them up. As I said, flavor was good, topping were generous, but the crust just doesn’t taste like it’s fresh in my opinion.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Ordered 2 pizzas, 1 meat lovers and 1 primavera pizza. Also got fries which were portioned way more than expected! You can definitely share with someone else and it'd be more than enough! The meat lover pie wasn't bad by any means. This pie was of the thin crust variety that you'd get from a frozen pizza. The primavera pizza wasn't bad either but the crust was just a bit too thin and didn't really pack that "fresh" made punch that other pizza shops in town deliver. 30$ for these two pizzas and fries. Not bad for the price but, would take my money elsewhere for better pizza!
Extremely disappointed! Midtown has been a staple pizza place in Middletown since I was young.... pizza and subs were bland. Pizza was undercooked and greasy af! Will not return!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
This restaurant needs to be inspected. The bathrooms are not only out of code, but filthy and have a sour smell that can be detected from the tables nearby. Water from the soda machine tasted like chemicals, back dining area and kitchen area were unclean. I threw out the food I ordered and left without eating.
Great food ..Very impressed with the customer service..Very quick and delicious food..Also well priced..These guys deserve a raise..Parking: Great location easy access
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Lover's Pizza
Cheese steaks are amazing. I highly recommend them!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Fries, Cheesesteak
Restaurantji Recommends
Waited 20 minutes pasted order pick up time for my pizza to look like this. cheese was half slid of the pizza and was barely
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
The inside of this restaurant was bigger than it looks from the outside. The food we ordered was pretty good as well as the price. We were able to order via the lunch special...quite a bit of food for the price especially nowadays. My half Italian sub n fries w/drink was pretty good. He ordered a breaded chicken sandwich also w/ fries n drink....although his fries were cold but they replaced them with no problem ?. The staff were very accommodating. The only thing missing was some background music ???it was fairly quiet. We'll definitely be back????.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Grilled Chicken Sandwich
The loaded fries are awful it literally tastes so sour like the cheese was completely bad. I never thought cheese could taste like that and this place has made me never want to buy loaded fries AGAIN.
So disappointed pizza was completely destroyed when I got home they blame it on me he knew what he done plus I live 5 minutes from there if anyone gets pizza check it before you leave they didn’t want to refund or give me a new
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
This place has went completely downhill in the last three years. The people running this place are careless and rude. I just got blamed for my own order being messed up lol completely ridiculous. Do yourself a favor and don’t order from here.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1