12 Best Pizza Restaurants near Milroy

“We couldn't wait to come down to Milroy OIP after all the great things we've heard. Let me tell you - they didn't disappoint! The pepperoni pizza was fantastic. The real star of the show was the Sassy Sissy wings - OMG, that sauce was excellent. We had such a great experience, we decided to get this gorgeous Buffalo Chicken Pizza to-go. We can't wait to come back.“

“Great place in the middle of Main Street to stop in and have a bite. Many people come here including local court house workers. Also great place for a first date or any date.Vegetarian options: With all the different diets now. You may want to look or call ahead.Kid-friendliness: The do accommodate children. Booster seats and kindness.“

“Great food and a very friendly waitress but it took awhile to get our food. All we got was 2 large pizzas and some appetizers, some other people came in about 5 minutes after we got there and ordered some hot subs. They got their food about 10 minutes before us, even though we ordered way before them. But to be honest the food was good and I will go there again. Also the price was very reasonable. Keep up the good cooking guys!?????“

“My dad would surprise us and bring Gus's along when he would visit me!My cousin Gayle is married to the owner of this it, who's father owned it before him!Locally owned & operated! It's pretty much the same exact way it was from the beginning! U can order by the pie or square cuts!We usually get a "Half Sheet" which is 14 cuts!!Help Support our local businesses!Ur kids will thank you for it!“

“First of all, I was in this area on a Friday and the sign showed a Friday night special, two large one toppings for 17.99. So I ordered take out. While waiting, I noticed the food being taken to patrons and I saw the biggest and yummiest looking cheese steak! I knew we had to eat in one of these times. Anyway, the pizza was awesome and the service was great so I knew I would be back!We returned a few weeks later to try these subs. The place was pretty busy but only one table didn't have their food. I do not know how long they were there before me but it was a long time until they finally got their food. We ordered our food. We waited, waited, waited. Another couple came in and placed their order. We waited. Another couple came in and ordered. We waited. The second couple that came in, had their food within 10 minutes. We waited, we're getting mad, it's going on an hour. The first couple that came in had their food about 20 minutes after the second couple got their food. Our sodas went empty, we were not asked one time if we needed a refill. We finally got our food. We got two cheese steaks and two sodas, that's it. The steak was only warm, the bun was a little hard on the outside. We were not checked on at all. I was very disappointed in that second trip. I don't know if I will try it again. Part of me wants to since our first experience was good but I don't know“

“The food is excellent, everything, subs on homemade rolls, excellent cosmos, delicious pizza we like a thin NY style crust. My tastes lend themselves to the toppings. The crust is the vehicle that gets the toppings to my mouth! Their lunch specials are as reasonably priced as it gets. Service is fast and courteous. This place is a best kept secret and in my all time top three pizza shops.“

“I absolutely love this place. It was the first time I was at this restaurant.As soon as you walk in, you can smell the beautiful sauces! It is by far the best Italian restaurant I have been in for years. We will definitely go back to try more items on their menu.Parking: The place we parked was 45 degree angle out front of the restaurant which is near an intersection. You can't really see to well when you back out. I don't know if there is parking elsewhere. The food makes it worth any inconvenience.“

“This time was pickup, but last time we ate in the dining room. Salad was good and the Italian dishes were too.The only negative was the Pasta Fagiola. It was ok, but the noodles were mushy and we were disappointed with it.The service is always friendly even with the folks in the take out area.We did try to come a couple Sundays ago, but they are closed on Sunday's. Not a big deal, but customers should know they are closed Sunday's.“

“Vince's Pizza is a first class establishment from top to bottom. I have never had nor have I yet to ever hear of anyone else ever fall victim to bad service or subpar food, with prices so low that the quality of product is severely undefined.“

“I don't normally write reviews, but I was super impressed with the service at this location today. I stopped in for lunch with my parents and 5-month-old, and we were warmly welcomed and seated quickly. I have lived in a city for quite some time, and I'm always nervous about bringing a baby into a restaurant - especially during the lunch rush! The staff was accommodating, the food was delicious (and fast), and the overall feel was "homey". Very appreciated. Thank you!“

“I always get take out since we live too far from the store. Maybe that's why the food is always hot, at any rate our orders are always hot and the staff answers my questions and is patient with me while I try to make up my mind, the kids like to change their minds at the last minute and the staff never makes my feel like I'm being rushed.John K.“

“I'm NOT happy with y'all. But bc I rock with people JUST as hard during the hard as I do the good, were alright ?? Sorry I got a little mad, but in my defense, I waited forever and so did my kids. Have a good night. #stillmypeeps“