Millie's Pizza
$ • Pizza
Hours:
34 Mill St, New Buffalo
(717) 834-6565
Customers' Favorites
Millie's Pizza Reviews
Great place to eat, I ordered a boil no peppers, no onions. They got it wrong the first time, but the second time got it right, along with a hand written note apologizing. You don’t get that type of service from any pizza shop. Food is top notch, boil’s, subs, and pizzas are all great, I’d recommend the garlic hot wing pizza, it’s great.
Millie's is the epitome of small town pizza shop subs... But so much better! You can't get what they offer at Subway or any chain sub shop! I've been ordering for a few months and I have never been disappointed! The value to price comparison can't be beat! I am forever a loyal fan! Keep up the great job guys!
Ratings
Menu
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4 - 9PM |
| Thursday | 4 - 9PM |
| Friday | 4 - 10PM |
| Saturday | 4 - 10PM |
| Sunday | 4 - 8PM |
People in New Buffalo Also Viewed
We just moved to new buffalo and after a day of moving, there was no way I was cooking dinner. We decided to check out our local pizza place and oh my goodness! It was the best sub I’ve ever had! The price point is fantastic and the service even better. I realized half way through eating that I forgot the tip so I walked down to rectify that and check out the location. Super cute! Can’t wait to order again!!