Mays Donuts

2406 Wilmington Road, 1214 Butler Avenue, New Castle
(724) 944-5968

Recent Reviews

miguel joseph

Certified new castle classic

Toni Sexton

Yummy!!

Google user

I mean what can you say about them that anyone already knows about. Good prices very fresh donuts. The 1 thing why its 4 stars is the last couple times i was in there they seemed to rush u out and the 1 lady wasn't to nice at the register, when someone says thank you have a nice day, you should at least say you're welcome or same to you.

Shanna Moxley

I mean what can you say about them that anyone already knows about. Good prices very fresh donuts. The 1 thing why its 4 stars is the last couple times i was in there they seemed to rush u out and the 1 lady wasn't to nice at the register, when someone says thank you have a nice day, you should at least say you're welcome or same to you.

Dee DeNome

I've been enjoying their donuts since I was a child.I'm 60 now and still loving itTheir maple frosted creme filled donuts are addicting

Randy Wheeler

Best donuts hands down took them to work and everyone loved them.

Sherrie Sheppeck

Love their donuts but live in Butler and it's a drive wish they had longer hours

Jonny Dean

Best doughnuts in town, local legends!

Hank Ritter

Best donuts you’ve gonna get around here

bill mihalovits

The prices were good and donuts large, but they just tasted okay. Not as good as other May Donuts or even Dunkin,'

David W

Great donuts. But still miss east Washington shop they had.

Jake Aretz

My first time trying these, I grabbed two cinnamon roll.. Very impressive!

Jeff Pennington

Everyone at May's Donuts is awesome & they provide GREAT customer service except for Mary. You can not get a friendly greeting, a smile, or a brief conversation from her as it appears to be an inconvenience for her to be pleasant or smile. Instead of a "good morning" or a "how are you today" the FIRST words from her are typically "how many would you like" or "what do you want". Not sure I will return as this has happened on several occasions.

Jeffrey Baker

There are not better donuts in New Castle PA. They are delicious. Incredibly yummy. Been eating them for over 50 years. Highly recommended.

Doris Baughman

I get the cream sticks and glazed twists. They are all faves at work

Load More