21 Best Pizza Restaurants near Newmanstown

“These local/family owned Italian spots with good lunch are the heart and soul of SE rural PA. Justino’s is absolutely top tier. Based. Unequivocally BUSSIN if you will. They make their own homemade hoagie rolls, hand cut their French fries, and the lettuce and meats on the Italian I got were delicious and fresh tasting. Not to mention… their lunch special (1/2 cold sandwich, small fries (it’s a lot of fries), and a bottled drink…) is only $6. That’s crazy, right!? Def the spot for lunch if you’re in the area.“

“I get the grandma pizzas every week and holy SMOKES…very good quality ingredients, masterfully proportioned cheese and toppings like REAL ITALIANS do…not sloppy with way too much stuff…just exactly right so the crust has some crisp but nothing is dry. The bruschetta has fresh, real, raw garlic in it (which is always a good sign of real Italian food flair!). This is my new place, and they’re gonna have to try real hard to get ridda me!“

“The tavern was very well designed with the original brick walls and beams. Food and service was very good. Will definitely be back !!“

“Found this little pizza shop on our travels. Delicious pizza, really nice customer service, they were so kind to take 2 slices of pizza and cut them again so little Dex could have his own slice of pizza fit for him. Is definitely worth the stop if you are In the area.“

“Met the owner who said he is from Sicily. The pizza was great, we had the Mealovers and a Cheese Sicilian style, both here very tasty. I also had a Chicken parmigan hoagie, the bread was wierd looking at first, but it tasted amazing with just the right crunch. My kids loves the garlic knots but for me they needed the sauce for me to like and the Canoli was yummy! Great atmosphere, very friendly and if I lived up here I would go often“

“Great pizza and a good atmosphere“

“Loved the pizza, especially the amount of toppings. Crust was the perfect thickness. Also recommend the salmon salad. Some of the lettuce wasn't great, but the grilled salmon made up for that!! Definitely want to visit this shop again! Our server was so sweet and kind, and quite attentive to our every need. Thank you! You folks have great service.“

“The food was very good. We were happy with the service and will be our go-to pizza place.“

“Great Food, Great Service“

“Good food,good price,truck parking“

“Great employees. Our waitress was so nice and the food was excellent. Huge portions! You will be happy.“

“Was out with friends to the Christmas village. We were hungry afterwards and this was the only place near us that was open. We aren’t from around this area and drove 3hrs to get here.The pizza shop was once a barn and it’s tucked back in the middle of no where.Service was good, food was good. Glad we stopped. If you’re in the area and looking for a place, check them out.“

“We just happened to stumble upon this place when we had trouble with our tour bus. While our bus was being serviced at Elite Bus.The owner and his wife were just opening and were able to accommodate 49 people. Just the two of them. Food was great and they made us feel so welcome. Great job!“

“There's an old saying. "Nobody Knows Pizza. Better Than Domino's." Well, they were right! Just take a look at this pick two deal. An italian sandwich ? , fully loaded, and exploding with goodies. Plus, a two topping chicken and bacon thin crust pizza ? to go with it. Yummy ?. Definitely recommend ?.“

“The pizza is very good. I had the Margherita pizza. I loved it.“

“Visited there a lot on and off for a few years now. Their pepperoni rolls are quite good. I've had the pizza there and it's also very good. Recently I've been getting cheese steaks with their lunch special. Great every single time and generous portions, especially for the price.The service is impeccable. They go above and beyond to make sure you're happy. I really want to stress how good it actually is. The atmosphere itself isn't anything very special. It's small, but it's very clean and gets the job done. The parking is also a bit sparse, but it's to be expected since it's a smaller place.I recommend their lunch specials. Can't beat a large sandwich, a while lot of fries, and a drink for under $10. Better than fast food and you get a lot more for your money.“

“We are so happy to have the original owners back the best people ? HER PEPES SPECIAL CHEZZE STEAK IS HANDS DOWN BETTER THAN ANY GUS CHESSE STEAK AND PEPES PIZZA HAS ? ? FREE FRENCH FRIES ? ON FRIDAYS WITH any SUB you order only on Friday it's worth the drive ? God bless“

“Ordered wings and an Italian pasta dinner with Italian sausage. Food was great. Soup was amazing. Definitely coming back.“

“Had this place as a kid back in ‘10 when they were in Wernersville. We always thought they just shut down. Randomly thought about it today and come to find out they were here all along! 30 min drive was totally worth it. 10/10. Cheeseburger sub is just how we remembered! We‘ll be back for sure!“

“Honestly BEST Family owned and operated Pizza and Italian restaurant I ever been at many times. Wish they delivered further but worth it for the great flavor and friendly family atmosphere.Kid-friendliness: Very friendly family they make everybody feel welcome even children and they do have a children’s menu“

“My husband and I are sitting here, while I write this review. The food was delicious, the ladies whom took our order were beyond friendly and just so kind and had a smile while taking our order. I will be coming back here and will bring my boys with me. Thank you ladies for delicious pizza and subs, for having an amazing attitude with us and for making my birthday lunch special even tho we did not mention it! Thank you again!“