We visited Anthony's on the recommendation from a work colleague. Upon entering, we made our way to the bar had a seat. It took a few minutes for for the bartender to greet us, at which point we were already ready to order.My coworker remarked that this would be a good place to bring a group of people after looking around and seeing the rather well-kept dining room. A quick look at the bar area told a different story, though. Granted, it's a bar and prone to spilled drinks, which are often sugary. I got the sense that a thorough cleaning of the bar area wasn't management's top priority. This was confirmed when our food was brought out.I ordered an appetizer of the garlic knots, which were amazing. Good size knots that were well cooked, with plenty of garlic, butter, and salt. They had a good color on top and very crispy, but the insides we're neither overdone nor underdone. It was enough garlic on top to really enjoy but also question if you were going to regret it later. After only a few minutes of sitting there, several small flies seem to appear out of nowhere and start flying around the food. This is what caused me to think that the bar cleanliness wasn't quite Management's priority.Main entrees were brought out and did not disappoint. My colleague got the coal-fired wings and, upon taking his first bite once they had cooled (they seem to have been cooked in a nuclear furnace), declared them to be the best wings he had ever had. I got the coal-fired chicken sandwich which was honestly overcooked. The focaccia was dry, but still fluffy. The chicken was definitely overcooked as well cup of with some corners of the piece almost impossible to bite through. I let the bartender know of the situation, and she immediately asked if I wanted some additional vinaigrette, which I agreed it needed. It was brought out within seconds and helped make the sandwich a little more manageable to chew. I ended up taking some garlic and butter from the garlic knots and adding it to the focaccia which only increased the enjoyment factor.Overall, I give the restaurant four stars. The constant issue of flies hovering around our food really soured us to the whole experience. The wings were amazing, the garlic dots were amazing, and the folks at the bar next to us had a pizza that looked really amazing. I would go back, but definitely not sit at the bar. Overall, do recommend.
Sometimes when you are not sure if the pizza that looks burnt at the edges is good or not... when it comes out and then you taste it and love it.. it's one of those days ..
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michele Sipe
I ordered to go earlier today, and had 40 min to kill. Went on time to pickup, there was no order and girl working was busy talking on her phone. I could tell something was wrong and told her I’d like a refund and don’t have time to wait. She got the manager who said they gave my order to someone else, and making a new order. Manager told me girl was just young and new, but nice. If so, why the heck is she walking around with air buds and talking on the phone the whole time, ignoring me and not explaining? Meanwhile I’m sitting at the dirty bar with invasion of the fruit flies attacking me.I just wanted order or refund, not both. When I left had to shake out 3 times to make sure I didn’t have fruit fly hitchhikers.Food was ok after that but doubt I’ll be back. Clean your restaurant and hire people who pay attention to job NOT phone.
Hayley McGuigan
Delicious coal fired pizza and wings! Must order the garlic bread! Everything is super delicious and comes out fresh.
Service was top notch. Food was top 10 I have had this year.Our server was super on point, and the wings were great.It's been years since I've been and I hope to make it back soon!Get the original wings, the flavors are good, but you are gonna miss out.
The old fashion pepperoni & hot honey is a must! Those small pepperoni that curl up, yum! Great atmosphere, with a casual atmosphere. Friendly, clean & delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matthew Streiff
Pizza was good, drinks were strong, caprese salad was ok, tomatoes were not great. It was super busy, sat at the bar.
This place is amazing. Look I'll give it another star. They HAD FRIES.Update - during covid 19. Man these peole are so professional. They food still making, and update on fries still no fries, but for there amazing staff, im gonna give 5, from my past4.2024 update - man this place still great. I love so much. ?, the pizza and tuna melt out of this world[as some who can't eat meat, this place has many options] one thing still lacking is fresh fries. ^.^.Anthony ya blesses, please let me if i can drop off my novel books. As thank for yall amazing food, amazing staff, and great community Instablishment. 10/10.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Q
roberto at this store is probably the best pizza maker of the 3 Pittsburgh area Anthony’s. Great pizza as always he does the thin and crunch style better. The large cheese pizza is where it’s at from
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bill K.
A friend and I meet here every once in a while to grab lunch. It has always been good. I walked in today and could not understand why the restaurant was basically empty. A few minutes later, I noticed a fruit fly had entered my drink. I thought nothing of it until we got our pizza. We had to brush away the fruit flies the whole time we ate. As far as we could tell nothing landed on the food. We are finding a new spot to meet next time. On a positive note, the pizza and service were good. Thanks,
We visited Anthony's on the recommendation from a work colleague. Upon entering, we made our way to the bar had a seat. It took a few minutes for for the bartender to greet us, at which point we were already ready to order.My coworker remarked that this would be a good place to bring a group of people after looking around and seeing the rather well-kept dining room. A quick look at the bar area told a different story, though. Granted, it's a bar and prone to spilled drinks, which are often sugary. I got the sense that a thorough cleaning of the bar area wasn't management's top priority. This was confirmed when our food was brought out.I ordered an appetizer of the garlic knots, which were amazing. Good size knots that were well cooked, with plenty of garlic, butter, and salt. They had a good color on top and very crispy, but the insides we're neither overdone nor underdone. It was enough garlic on top to really enjoy but also question if you were going to regret it later. After only a few minutes of sitting there, several small flies seem to appear out of nowhere and start flying around the food. This is what caused me to think that the bar cleanliness wasn't quite Management's priority.Main entrees were brought out and did not disappoint. My colleague got the coal-fired wings and, upon taking his first bite once they had cooled (they seem to have been cooked in a nuclear furnace), declared them to be the best wings he had ever had. I got the coal-fired chicken sandwich which was honestly overcooked. The focaccia was dry, but still fluffy. The chicken was definitely overcooked as well cup of with some corners of the piece almost impossible to bite through. I let the bartender know of the situation, and she immediately asked if I wanted some additional vinaigrette, which I agreed it needed. It was brought out within seconds and helped make the sandwich a little more manageable to chew. I ended up taking some garlic and butter from the garlic knots and adding it to the focaccia which only increased the enjoyment factor.Overall, I give the restaurant four stars. The constant issue of flies hovering around our food really soured us to the whole experience. The wings were amazing, the garlic dots were amazing, and the folks at the bar next to us had a pizza that looked really amazing. I would go back, but definitely not sit at the bar. Overall, do recommend.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Coal Fired Chicken Wings, Garlic Knots
Incredible pizza and wings.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sometimes when you are not sure if the pizza that looks burnt at the edges is good or not... when it comes out and then you taste it and love it.. it's one of those days ..
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered to go earlier today, and had 40 min to kill. Went on time to pickup, there was no order and girl working was busy talking on her phone. I could tell something was wrong and told her I’d like a refund and don’t have time to wait. She got the manager who said they gave my order to someone else, and making a new order. Manager told me girl was just young and new, but nice. If so, why the heck is she walking around with air buds and talking on the phone the whole time, ignoring me and not explaining? Meanwhile I’m sitting at the dirty bar with invasion of the fruit flies attacking me.I just wanted order or refund, not both. When I left had to shake out 3 times to make sure I didn’t have fruit fly hitchhikers.Food was ok after that but doubt I’ll be back. Clean your restaurant and hire people who pay attention to job NOT phone.
Delicious coal fired pizza and wings! Must order the garlic bread! Everything is super delicious and comes out fresh.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Pizza, Garlic Knots, Garlic Bread
Service was top notch. Food was top 10 I have had this year.Our server was super on point, and the wings were great.It's been years since I've been and I hope to make it back soon!Get the original wings, the flavors are good, but you are gonna miss out.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Coal Fired Chicken Wings, Garlic Knots, Focaccia
Visited this place on a date and everything was good.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Garlic Knots
Vegetarian options: We needed no meat options for lent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Garlic Knots, Anthony's Classic Italian Salad
The best pizza and food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Great food, fair prices! Love this place when I can go.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Caprese Salad, Garlic Knots
Restaurantji Recommends
The old fashion pepperoni & hot honey is a must! Those small pepperoni that curl up, yum! Great atmosphere, with a casual atmosphere. Friendly, clean & delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza was good, drinks were strong, caprese salad was ok, tomatoes were not great. It was super busy, sat at the bar.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Caprese Salad, Pepperoni Pizza
This place is amazing. Look I'll give it another star. They HAD FRIES.Update - during covid 19. Man these peole are so professional. They food still making, and update on fries still no fries, but for there amazing staff, im gonna give 5, from my past4.2024 update - man this place still great. I love so much. ?, the pizza and tuna melt out of this world[as some who can't eat meat, this place has many options] one thing still lacking is fresh fries. ^.^.Anthony ya blesses, please let me if i can drop off my novel books. As thank for yall amazing food, amazing staff, and great community Instablishment. 10/10.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
roberto at this store is probably the best pizza maker of the 3 Pittsburgh area Anthony’s. Great pizza as always he does the thin and crunch style better. The large cheese pizza is where it’s at from
Food: 5
Service: 5
A friend and I meet here every once in a while to grab lunch. It has always been good. I walked in today and could not understand why the restaurant was basically empty. A few minutes later, I noticed a fruit fly had entered my drink. I thought nothing of it until we got our pizza. We had to brush away the fruit flies the whole time we ate. As far as we could tell nothing landed on the food. We are finding a new spot to meet next time. On a positive note, the pizza and service were good. Thanks,