It's the Best Pizza I was in town from Pittsburgh pa ! Cuz Vinny ???????
jean-philippe Cypres
Great little pizza shop! The pizzas are excellents and I had the best Italian hoagie! I would recommend this restaurant to anyone :)
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Nathaniel Kenny
The service provided was excellent, and the price was impressive. However, I personally found that the pizza didn't quite meet my expectations. While it had a nice thin crust, it was overly sweet, and lacked in flavor.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Rich Andrulonis
Been going there forever.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Bruce Heckman
I just ordered 2 Pizzas again two nights ago and Pat was working the ovens. And I can't help the think and remember Rose and Sarah each and every time I go and they don't answer the door they were two of the greatest people that I have had the opportunity to have in my life.
Beatrice K.
The pizza is the best ! Always g We have gone there since teenagers and my brother loves it to Jake Merrell
Brittany Plummer
Great pizza ?
Raquel Mcconnaughey
This pizza is so good!
Brandon Lippert
Great pizza at a great price!
Michele White
Best pizza in Punxsutawney hands down!I grew up on these pizzas and now that I live in Texas I miss them.Always have to get them when I come home. They are AMAZING.
Best pizza I ever had. I love coming to puxy to get this pizza!!
Shelley States
I miss this pizza so much since I moved away! Love it!
Elaine Berry
My family has been getting pizza from Mrs. Defelice since I was a little girl in the 60s. It's not a fancy pizza, only comes with pepperoni (and not very much, at that). But the sauce and the cheese blend is something me, my children, my siblings, my parents, my cousins, everyone in the family, just CRAVE. None of the family live in Punxsy anymore but when we come to town, we always order massive quantities. Always.
Crystal Kempfer
I haven’t had your pizza since I was a kid mention sweet sauce taste
Susi Daugherty
Tucked away on a side residential street you will find this Hometown Secret.You can't Truely experience the whole "Home of Punxsutawney Phil" adventure without having eaten a "Sarah Pie" or a "Sarah Slapper " as they are know to the locals.They'll have your taste buds thanking you..
It's the Best Pizza I was in town from Pittsburgh pa ! Cuz Vinny ???????
Great little pizza shop! The pizzas are excellents and I had the best Italian hoagie! I would recommend this restaurant to anyone :)
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
The service provided was excellent, and the price was impressive. However, I personally found that the pizza didn't quite meet my expectations. While it had a nice thin crust, it was overly sweet, and lacked in flavor.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Been going there forever.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
I just ordered 2 Pizzas again two nights ago and Pat was working the ovens. And I can't help the think and remember Rose and Sarah each and every time I go and they don't answer the door they were two of the greatest people that I have had the opportunity to have in my life.
The pizza is the best ! Always g We have gone there since teenagers and my brother loves it to Jake Merrell
Great pizza ?
This pizza is so good!
Great pizza at a great price!
Best pizza in Punxsutawney hands down!I grew up on these pizzas and now that I live in Texas I miss them.Always have to get them when I come home. They are AMAZING.
Restaurantji Recommends
Best pizza I ever had. I love coming to puxy to get this pizza!!
I miss this pizza so much since I moved away! Love it!
My family has been getting pizza from Mrs. Defelice since I was a little girl in the 60s. It's not a fancy pizza, only comes with pepperoni (and not very much, at that). But the sauce and the cheese blend is something me, my children, my siblings, my parents, my cousins, everyone in the family, just CRAVE. None of the family live in Punxsy anymore but when we come to town, we always order massive quantities. Always.
I haven’t had your pizza since I was a kid mention sweet sauce taste
Tucked away on a side residential street you will find this Hometown Secret.You can't Truely experience the whole "Home of Punxsutawney Phil" adventure without having eaten a "Sarah Pie" or a "Sarah Slapper " as they are know to the locals.They'll have your taste buds thanking you..