Nina's Five Star Pizza

1429 Pittston Ave, Scranton
(570) 344-2255

Recent Reviews

Catherine Valene Taylor

Pizza is delicious. Love the fresh garlic he adds to the slice.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

Exsert Spring88

Pizza is very good and the owner is really nice, Nina's is my favorite place to get pizza in Scranton 10/10 would

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

Shaquanna Jordan

Poor customer service and unsanitary….

iiPro 2.0

Didn’t dine in but, Wow! Tasted Amazing!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza

Analisa Hoskins

The owner was very kind to us. The food was 10 out of 10. We got a pizza, a calzone, and gnocchi and it was all amazing. The food is made with care and fresh ingredients!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Christina Mills

Order a cheese steak Stromboli no sauce just plain it was amazing ,very

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Potato Cortes

My fiancé and I have been looking for the “perfect” pizza since we moved to Scranton and this pizza cheeks out on everything from the perfect crispy crust, to the flavorful home made sauce, great mozzarella. I really don’t see why this place wasn’t blown up. It’s perfect in every aspect. I recommend a thousand times to eat here.

MKMansur _

Delicious pizza and great customer service! ?

Justin M.

I ordered pizza to be delivered to my hotel room from this location. I told the guy to put $10 on for delivery and when he arrived he charged me $15. I told the deliver driver that was not correct so he told me he was going to get me $5 so I would sign the credit card receipt. I'm the meantime, the store called me and told me I told them $15 and they would prove it via their recording. I told them to play the recording so we can better understand what I said and make it right. He didn't have the recording and argued with me. Then he sent the driver back to the hotel to take pictures of our family in the pool area, underage kids on the pool were having their picture taken by a delivery driver. STAY AWAY!!!! NOT HONEST PEOPLE.

Patrick Neville

Another pizza Gem in Scranton talk about pride of ownership,cleanliness,and delicious new york style thin crust!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Michael Caswell

The pizza was great and very tasty. Real Ny style pizza in south side the owner was very friendly. This place definitely gets 5 stars

Karen Charles

Great pizza flavorful plenty of toppings perfect crust hard find perfect pizza place but this most definitely will be 1 on my list

Keren Green

Always incredible food, thank you for always making our trips special! -your red headed friends from Buffalo

Christopher J.

I moved to Avoca 2yrs ago and have been looking for a good slice of pie that isn't Old Forge style (no offense) to those who like that type but it's just not for me. I've tried numerous places that say they have NY style pizza and not one reminded me of NY!! Not gonna name names but I'm talking at least 10 different spots. I found Nina's about a month ago and was surprisingly shocked that this little red building on the corner that I've driven by a million times has THE BEST PIZZA in Scranton!!! You might be asking yourself what are my qualifications to say such a bold statement? I made pizza for 13yrs 7days a week in West By God Virginia where they have no clue what NY pizza is unless they actually been to NY. Three Egyptian fellas who learned how to make pizza in the Bronx/ Brooklyn/ and Miami opened up a place in the little town of Beckley, WV and are making a killing still to this day! I know pizza!!! I ordered another pie yesterday picked up after work went home and took a bite and immediately called the owner and told him that his pizza in my opinion is the best pizza I've had in Scranton. So far. The price is reasonable and the ingredients are fresh. I don't eat the crust off of pizza but I ate his. It might even be Top 5 in all the pizza I've ate. Def better than the one I use to make and my pizza was on point! Plus the owner and his lovely wife were very friendly and he will give a good conversation if u hav the time. I hardly ever write a review but I couldn't go another day without telling my story. If you like good old fashion NY style pizza don't cheat yourself treat yourselfI see why he named it 5. Not posting a pic bc all pizza looks good in a pic and I ate it already

N K

Guy who answers phone is extremely arrogant and rude. Called to ask if they delivered and guy was a complete tool. I’ll never order from here. Learn some customer service or at the least some human decency.

Load More