27 Best Pizza Restaurants near South Williamsport

“the bread is amazing“

“my husband grew up on Riverside every. Saturday was pizza night and now I'm hoked love the hoagies the best sometime I get hot and cold summer time I like cold subs“

“Absolutely a must stop for ice cream. They do serve other foods like pizza and hot dogs, etc. The shop atmosphere sends you back to the 50's! Everything was great, including the friendly service. We'll be frequenting Weaver's on our regular trips between Virginia and western NY.“

“In from NJ for a few days and needed some Pizza and Cheese steaks. Did a pick up from Long Island Pizza and the cheese steaks were excellent. Pizza was also excellent. Very nice people great value for the food you get. Would definitely go again when in “

“This is a great place to grab food. Pizza is great and Ice cream selection is out of this world. Always something to try....“

“Shout out to Pudgies Montoursville employees for their excellent customer service. I always get smiles, “thank you” and “ have a good day” when I go in there. It’s the little things like this that make it special. Hard to find that elsewhere, these days. Keep up the great work!“

“So there Good, then theres Humpty Dumpty meaning no need to try anywhere else. I always get a half of the dirty pol cosmo and it blows my mind Everytime. My wife who eats mainly gluten free got the dirty poly in salad form and she repeatedly couldn't express how happy she was with how they did it. She also commented with how clean the prep tables and etc were kept. Great people, great food and the prices are beyond reasonable for what you get.“

“Came from Florida to PA to visit family for Spring Break. Wanted some really good pizza, different than Florida. I searched for a few hours and finally settled on Venice. The pizza was AMAZING. I am a cheese girl and so is my daughter. The cheese and sauce was PERFECT“

“While in town for work I also tried The Stonehouse Wood Fired Pizza. It was fresh and amazing probably in my top 1or 2 spot out of all of the other pizza places I've had in my life from brick oven to coal fired I would definitely recommend them to anyone from or coming to Williamsport PA.“

“It's Pudgies!! Their stuff is always good! I have never gotten bad food there! I have, however, screwed up my own order! Haha. I have placed an order wanting one thing, went to pick it up and it was the wrong size Pudgie pack. I ordered a Pudgie pack wanted a Family pack .. they were so kind about it! Even offered to help me out by wanting to make my mix up right!! I took what I ordered and left! I will always go to Pudgies!!“

“First time I stopped and will definitely be going back. Food was delicious and hot. Great prices and very nice staff. Had a wonderful experience. I always like to support the small businesses in the area and this is a place I will definitely be supporting!!!!!!“

“Very clean and bright. Staff friendly and accommodating. Food is excellent and portions large. Thin sliced meats on subs and salads tastes excellent. Overall, extremely pleased with this restaurant and will definitely return.“

“So I decided to stop on by here after work today. I ordered a slice of thin crust cheese and a beer to go. It hit the spot. I ended up ordering a large thick crust pizza. Best pizza I've had since I moved up here. Everybody runs their mouth about Marcos, B*!#$ please. This here is the real deal y'all. ❤️‍?❤️‍?❤️‍?“

“Paid $21.40 for a large cheese pizza and two Hanks sodas. Me and my friend decided to stop by and try the Pizza. We got a large cheese pizza and it was very good, piping hot. And was served in a very good amount of time given we were a walk in order. The staff and the customers were very nice and always had a smile on their face. Also they have Hank's soda which I got to try and it's soda made with actual cane sugar, it was very nice and it's the only place in town that I think has it, also for a very good price. A quote from my friend, " Parks Pizza is one of my favorite places in town to go get pizza". He has been going there since he was a kid with his mom and then going to the park and playing which is right next door. Perfect place for kids the staff is very accommodating. So if you just want to take your kids out for pizza and then take them to the park afterwards it's a perfect place for it.“

“I have been ordering from Joe's for YEARS. FOOD QUALITY IS EXCEPTIONAL. Some of the best pizza in town, amazing cheesesteaks and the BREAD?! DID YOU KNOW YOU CAN BUY THAT SEPARATELY?! Now, for as long as I've been ordering here, yeah I've run into occasional issues BUT the fact that they make sure you're taken care of, everything is rectified and you are satisfied, speaks volumes for me as a customer. These interactions are positive for the most part and the effort is more than many other places. Thanks for being such a great place to order in!“

“Our go-to lunch spot at work. I have heard good things about all of their food but I can't steer myself away from their excellent wraps (hot wing wrap and ranch chicken wrap in particular). Always order a side of chips when placing a lunch order!“

“Excellent food !“

“Usually get the pepperoni pizza. Joe's does huge slices and is pretty filling after 2-3 pieces. A little greasy but pizza tastes amazing. Subs are also a plus and most of its at a reasonable price. Staff is also very welcoming and great with addressing customers.“

“Really great food. Have patronized this place for many years. I enjoyed all the food with past owners- things changed for awhile with the new ownership, but I stopped in last week and was really impressed. High quality subs at great prices. The staff is quick and attentive and honestly I’ve never had an incorrect order.“

“Huge fan of their cheesesteaks….homemade bread, yummy! The pizza is awesome….always delivered hot, the girls are super nice and polite. Definitely recommend.“

“A decent family owned sub shop in the Newberry section of Williamsport. Mileto’s offers all of the classic varieties of sub sandwiches and also has pizza and appetizers. The cheesesteaks are loaded with meat and very tasty. Parking can be hard to find at peak times.Parking: Very limited parking outside the shop“

“This was my first time at Buzz's!! My wife had been coming there for years! We were passing the area, hungry and she said ..Hey! Let's go to Buzz's I haven't been there in years!! She was so pleasantly surprised by the way they remodeled it from her last time there .... The waitress, Zoey, I believe, was a true delight! Very helpful and obviously enjoys her job there. Just watching her banter with other customers, with us and hearing her laughing from the back of the house. She is a keeper! The place is decorated with nice bright white walls, with a lot of "For Sale" Americana type wall hangings. It's very bright and clean! For me that is a plus!Our food, a cheese steak for me and a Turkey club for her, came out in a timely manner! OMG was it good!!! The bread was fresh, the steak was tender, the sandwich assembled as requested, for both of us. Even the fries n onion rings were on point!I had to ask ... Why wait so long to show me this spot, 15 yr together and I am just getting to this wonderful spot!We will return! Maybe y'all can add a Ruben to the menu ?.... Maybe !??!“

“Absolutely amazing food. The burgers were cooked perfectly and the fries as well. We will definitely be back to try more of their food. The man there said they sell a lot of the toasted cheese burger and there is a good reason for that. Highly recommend, not much indoor seating so this is not meant for a large crowd but is definitely good for a “date” idea.Wheelchair accessibility: No stairs, as a wheel chair user I can’t say it would be easy however.“

“Great Food and Bread Sticks are out of the world, definitely going back soon“

“We stopped in for lunch to try it out, as we heard about it through the grapevine. We both agreed that it was delicious! Every employee was very nice and asked how we are or if needed anything. Upon leaving the establishment the owner personally came out to ask how our visit was and if we enjoyed our meal. We’ll make a stop in again. Unfortunately, we live a good distance away. If we’re in the area again, it’ll sure be on our list. Again, Thank You!“

“First time here 1/29/2023 _was a great experience walked in and was surprised it was very cool bowling alley and was very good atmosphere , the employees running the counters were very patient and helpful and the lanes were clean and a lot of space to spread out definitely recommend and definitely will be returning.“