Such a wonderful bakery! Ordered a cake and balloons for my PSU student’s birthday and they couldn’t have been easier and more pleasant to work with. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Keisha Contee
Cheri is the owner and she was awesome to work with. She helped me customize my daughter’s birthday cake. I sent her a couple pictures and we spoke over the phone to create the perfect cake. The end result was just what my daughter wanted!Dietary restrictions: The cake was gluten free.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sean Karp
Nice lady on the inside, but her reticence about tech & keeping up to date seems to have spilled over to the rest of the establishment. She kept people in the shop waiting while on the phone for reasons unknown (I wasn't particularly bothered but it is unprofessional). Messy, disorganized, selling stale overpriced tasteless food. I checked and she's up to snuff on food safety, however the presentation of the shop doesn't breed confidence in the safety of the goods sold.2 stars as she's a nice person, but that isn't enough reason to ever bring my custom there again. Competition is fierce and this shop isn't long for this world if anyone comes for its lunch.
Tara Rittler
The owner Cheri, helped me today. What a lovely bakery and lovely owner. The cookies and Oreos were fantastic!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Quinn Favo
Very nice lady when I went inside, they have a few things like cookies inside that you can buy on the spot. Other things will need to be ordered in advance.
Amanda Hicks
Called this place on a whim because I didn't want to go with a store brought cake. They did such a fabulous job on a beach themed cake! Oh and it tasted so good too! I would recommend!
Helena Mariquinhos
I highly recommend Sweet Tooth Bakery!!! My daughter, a PennState student just turned 21 on April 26th! I live in Philadelphia, I called the bakery to order a cake and ballons to be delivered to my daughter, they were amazing!!! The cake was beautiful and delicious plus they mailed me the receipt and pictures of the cake and ballons also a thank you card from the owner!!! Thank you!!! A beautiful experience!!!
Sheila Eckroth
Sweet Tooth Bakery made a BEAUTIFUL cake for our daughter’s birthday! My daughter said the cake was so delicious and she loved it!! Cheri was wonderful to work with and was so accommodating to our requests. This was a quick request on an already busy week for her bakery. Thank you Cheri for helping this out-of-state mom surprise our daughter with an amazing cake that also looked like a piece of art! And a shout-out to your delivery driver for making sure the cake was left in a secure way while my daughter was in class. Highly recommend this bakery!
Ryan D.
Super unprofessional - nothing else to say here. My friends and family are disappointed by this service.
Nancy Starr
I wanted to do something special for my daughter, on Valentines Day, who is a student at Penn State. Cheri was great to work with and provided delicious and beautiful sweets. My daughter told me how nice Cheri was to her. The treats were absolutely delicious and beautifully done. Thanks Cheri for a great experience! I would definitely recommend you to anybody that wants quality goods and great customer service!!
Cherie was a pleasure to talk to & made a delicious cake for my son’s 21st birthday with a mug of beer in the design. She delivered it to his off campus house. She sent me a picture which I will upload…
kayla parks
Custom gym themed cake "Hard work betrays no one". Very good ?
Haley P.
They did a great job on my custom cake! I was just a bit disappointed in the size. It was supposed to be two layers with a filling, but it was essentially two half layers with a small amount of filling, so it was short. Still good quality!
Ryan McMurtrie
Owner was very rude and inconsiderate. Terrible experience do not recommend!
Michael Waldhier
My father was visiting us and wanted a Black Forest cake for his 70th birthday. I called a few other local cake shops and none were interested in taking a custom order that deviated from their standard menu, but Cheri at Sweet Tooth was happy to give it a try. The cake she made for us was outstanding - it was moist, flavorful, and my dad loved it. Very highly recommended!
Such a wonderful bakery! Ordered a cake and balloons for my PSU student’s birthday and they couldn’t have been easier and more pleasant to work with. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cheri is the owner and she was awesome to work with. She helped me customize my daughter’s birthday cake. I sent her a couple pictures and we spoke over the phone to create the perfect cake. The end result was just what my daughter wanted!Dietary restrictions: The cake was gluten free.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nice lady on the inside, but her reticence about tech & keeping up to date seems to have spilled over to the rest of the establishment. She kept people in the shop waiting while on the phone for reasons unknown (I wasn't particularly bothered but it is unprofessional). Messy, disorganized, selling stale overpriced tasteless food. I checked and she's up to snuff on food safety, however the presentation of the shop doesn't breed confidence in the safety of the goods sold.2 stars as she's a nice person, but that isn't enough reason to ever bring my custom there again. Competition is fierce and this shop isn't long for this world if anyone comes for its lunch.
The owner Cheri, helped me today. What a lovely bakery and lovely owner. The cookies and Oreos were fantastic!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very nice lady when I went inside, they have a few things like cookies inside that you can buy on the spot. Other things will need to be ordered in advance.
Called this place on a whim because I didn't want to go with a store brought cake. They did such a fabulous job on a beach themed cake! Oh and it tasted so good too! I would recommend!
I highly recommend Sweet Tooth Bakery!!! My daughter, a PennState student just turned 21 on April 26th! I live in Philadelphia, I called the bakery to order a cake and ballons to be delivered to my daughter, they were amazing!!! The cake was beautiful and delicious plus they mailed me the receipt and pictures of the cake and ballons also a thank you card from the owner!!! Thank you!!! A beautiful experience!!!
Sweet Tooth Bakery made a BEAUTIFUL cake for our daughter’s birthday! My daughter said the cake was so delicious and she loved it!! Cheri was wonderful to work with and was so accommodating to our requests. This was a quick request on an already busy week for her bakery. Thank you Cheri for helping this out-of-state mom surprise our daughter with an amazing cake that also looked like a piece of art! And a shout-out to your delivery driver for making sure the cake was left in a secure way while my daughter was in class. Highly recommend this bakery!
Super unprofessional - nothing else to say here. My friends and family are disappointed by this service.
I wanted to do something special for my daughter, on Valentines Day, who is a student at Penn State. Cheri was great to work with and provided delicious and beautiful sweets. My daughter told me how nice Cheri was to her. The treats were absolutely delicious and beautifully done. Thanks Cheri for a great experience! I would definitely recommend you to anybody that wants quality goods and great customer service!!
Restaurantji Recommends
Cherie was a pleasure to talk to & made a delicious cake for my son’s 21st birthday with a mug of beer in the design. She delivered it to his off campus house. She sent me a picture which I will upload…
Custom gym themed cake "Hard work betrays no one". Very good ?
They did a great job on my custom cake! I was just a bit disappointed in the size. It was supposed to be two layers with a filling, but it was essentially two half layers with a small amount of filling, so it was short. Still good quality!
Owner was very rude and inconsiderate. Terrible experience do not recommend!
My father was visiting us and wanted a Black Forest cake for his 70th birthday. I called a few other local cake shops and none were interested in taking a custom order that deviated from their standard menu, but Cheri at Sweet Tooth was happy to give it a try. The cake she made for us was outstanding - it was moist, flavorful, and my dad loved it. Very highly recommended!