We celebrated my parents 50th wedding anniversary with 16 people. Waitress was very good, food was excellent and everyone was very helpful/accommodating for all of us. Thank you
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Shannon Hannah
I have to stay
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Todd Peck
Excellent food enormous portion and fabulous
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Markus Pohl
Love this place!!! I come here once a year.......from Germany!!! The food is very very good .........Love the Bananapie ???
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
J Sun
What a wonderful and pleasant experience. On a whim I drove into Waterford to check out a spot from a local legend. Upon seeing this Resteraunt and "Hotel" in town, I decided to stop here for dinner. What a great decision. The person who seated me and the person who served me were courteous and super friendly. Inquired and asked quite a few questions about the building, which they happily answered. Asked a few more questions around the food then I normally do, to which the server was also extremely pleasant about answering. Wound up with the seafoor platter, dressing, baked beans. All were super tasty. The portions were... Large. Large enough I'll get 3 meals off it! The coleslaw was incredible, understood why both the people i chatted with suggested it, and, their homemade pie list was... Extensive. I wound up saving room for the fruit of the forest piece and had it heated up with some ice cream. Super delicious! Sometimes we make last minute choices and they sure do pay off. I wasn't planning on doing to much with my last day of vacation, but I sure am happy I made the choice to persue that local legend and stop at the Eagle "Hotel" for dinner. If you are anywhere near Waterford and are looking for a great experience stop here. Food was awesome. Service was great and the preservation of this incredibly historic building is impeccable!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kate G
Small town, rustic, casual. The food was amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
James F
We drive an hour north to eat here. Always great
Diane C
Every time I come home to visit I get tubs of their chicken salad. It’s literally the best out there.
Carollee Silakowski
Such good food and great service
Cher B.
Delicious Amish made food, all freshly prepared. I love the ambiance if this historic hotel.
The food was delicious, and ample quantity, glad we made reservations, because it was very busy
Cheryl B.
Delicious Amish made food, all freshly prepared. I love the ambiance if this historic hotel.
Kelly Varvel
Food was ok.The interior decoration on the other hand. Let's just say a very bad try at trying to reuse old doors as decoration. The place looks shabby not clean
J R
Never had a bad meal or bad service here! WONDERFUL place. Love ? it!
Queen Of Whimsy
Sugar 'N Spice (Located at the Eagle Hotel) serves the best pork chops I have ever had in my entire life! The building was very neat. I love the historic town and it's significance to the George Washington legacy.
We celebrated my parents 50th wedding anniversary with 16 people. Waitress was very good, food was excellent and everyone was very helpful/accommodating for all of us. Thank you
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I have to stay
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent food enormous portion and fabulous
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love this place!!! I come here once a year.......from Germany!!! The food is very very good .........Love the Bananapie ???
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
What a wonderful and pleasant experience. On a whim I drove into Waterford to check out a spot from a local legend. Upon seeing this Resteraunt and "Hotel" in town, I decided to stop here for dinner. What a great decision. The person who seated me and the person who served me were courteous and super friendly. Inquired and asked quite a few questions about the building, which they happily answered. Asked a few more questions around the food then I normally do, to which the server was also extremely pleasant about answering. Wound up with the seafoor platter, dressing, baked beans. All were super tasty. The portions were... Large. Large enough I'll get 3 meals off it! The coleslaw was incredible, understood why both the people i chatted with suggested it, and, their homemade pie list was... Extensive. I wound up saving room for the fruit of the forest piece and had it heated up with some ice cream. Super delicious! Sometimes we make last minute choices and they sure do pay off. I wasn't planning on doing to much with my last day of vacation, but I sure am happy I made the choice to persue that local legend and stop at the Eagle "Hotel" for dinner. If you are anywhere near Waterford and are looking for a great experience stop here. Food was awesome. Service was great and the preservation of this incredibly historic building is impeccable!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Small town, rustic, casual. The food was amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We drive an hour north to eat here. Always great
Every time I come home to visit I get tubs of their chicken salad. It’s literally the best out there.
Such good food and great service
Delicious Amish made food, all freshly prepared. I love the ambiance if this historic hotel.
Restaurantji Recommends
The food was delicious, and ample quantity, glad we made reservations, because it was very busy
Delicious Amish made food, all freshly prepared. I love the ambiance if this historic hotel.
Food was ok.The interior decoration on the other hand. Let's just say a very bad try at trying to reuse old doors as decoration. The place looks shabby not clean
Never had a bad meal or bad service here! WONDERFUL place. Love ? it!
Sugar 'N Spice (Located at the Eagle Hotel) serves the best pork chops I have ever had in my entire life! The building was very neat. I love the historic town and it's significance to the George Washington legacy.