I placed an order for pizzas and loaded fries during a 2 hour special when they were likely incredibly busy. I had not had what I would determine as good pizza in this area of PA. I mentioned this to the owner because all restaurants here seem to be pizzerias but despite trying everyone’s favorite, none were as good as from restaurants in big cities. I added 2 cannolis at the last minute when checking out at the restaurant. The owner said that their cannolis were amazing. They were freshly piped and not already prepared sitting and getting soft, already a great sign. I should have ordered more! I’ve had cannolis made in Little Italy and homemade by generations of Italian family recipes, this was absolutely one of the best I’ve ever had. I cannot recommend these enough. The pizza was everything I had been missing. The sauce had a little something special to it, the dough was perfectly between thick and thin, and the cheese wasn’t the tasteless junk too many restaurants put on pizzas these days. Now I’m not saying everything on the menu is amazing because I haven’t tried it. You cannot go wrong with the pizza and cannolis though. Their banana peppers were different from anyone else’s I’ve ever tried. They had more spice/heat than most but it only made it better in my opinion. I’m not a huge fan of fries in general, but their loaded fries were abundantly topped and had great flavor. Even better than the food was the owner and staff’s warm attitude. Keep in mind this is a small town so if you want some fancy atmosphere and impeccably dressed waiters, you won’t enjoy it here. If you want to get some of the best take out you’ve ever had though, I definitely recommend the pizza and cannolis. I’ve been dreaming about them ever since.Parking: Parking was plentiful which is incredibly important when carrying a large take out order.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizzas
Tammie Leach
I have lived in this area for 25+ years and have seen changes with Mammas throughout the years. They have it going on again. high five to the cooks and staff! Recommend the Buffalo chicken pizza. I am not a pizza crust eater but I eat their pizza crust.
Rebecca Wagner
The food is so good!! I had a pizzaburger sub. The fries were perfectly golden and crisp. The sub was stuffed with burgers and cheesy...ah I wish my stomach was bottomless and this sub was endless. I don't even remember the service and the atmosphere (they were fine) everything just melted away and it was just me and my pizzaburger. I'm not "Wellsville local" but I might be there so much I'll become one. If you see me, I'll be the one in the corner with my eyes closed savoring every bite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Larry K
Took my oldest son who was heading back to college in a few days for a calzone. Excellent. Their spinach Calzone was amazing. They have so many great items on their menu and their specials look and taste awesome too. Service was fast and friendly. We even had a little bit of "entertainment" (reminded me of when all 3 of my sons were little and we'd go out).So glad to have this gem of a restaurant close by.Go check it out. You won't be disappointed!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
nathan gramm
AWESOME! Great meatlovers pizza, the pretzal boli is the best I've ever had! Delivery was excellent time and friendly! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers
Natasha Mitchell
Great food and super friendly staff!!
shannon murphy
We could not be any more pleased with mamas with lot having many delivery places in dillsburg mamas never disappoints us, sometimes the delivery will be long on the weekends but it’s worth the wait and we’ll appreciated that they deliver to us! We love the two subs and a side specials and one pizza and wings. Always so friendly on the phone and at the door. Thank you for serving us hot delicious food.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheesesteak Pizzazolla, Italian Sub, Chicken Wings
Pete M.
Extremely friendly owner. I did not care for the pizza. The owner's young daughter was playing in the seating area and sat down with us for most of our meal.She was very cute, but very annoying. Mom made 2 attempts to get her to leave us alone, then forgot about it.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 3
Christopher J H.
Ordered wings n ff they were excellent. As far as the subs horrible all roll and very little meat. Boli horrible hardly any meat ends had no meat. Alot of wasted money spent, wont be going again!
Jessica Jacobs
Delicious hot meals and cold subs, salads and more. They have specialty pizzas like a Maryland style "crabby" and Greek Gyro. The owners and staff go above and beyond for the community and are loved by all. When we first moved into town and had to order out, our first night here, we were welcomed by the most caring people around. Just so thankful for this place.Vegetarian options: Great saladsKid-friendliness: Great place for kids
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pasta with Meatballs, Old Bay Fries, Antipesto, Homemade Lasagna, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Cheesesteak Pizzazolla, Custom Pizza, Sausage, Meat Pizza, Meat Lovers, Buffalo Chicken, Garlic Bread, Veggie Pizza, Wings, Veggie Pretzel Stromboli, Italian Sub, Breaded Mushrooms, Lasagna, Rodeo Burger, Chicken Wings
Owner is great, very good pizza and personable excellent
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tom Myers
It sucks when you call and stop for something to eat only to find they closed early because it was a little slow that evening. So many places think they can make up whatever hours they want these days and customer service dies because of it. I’m so disappointed because I usually have good service here.
Joe Kay
A beautiful small town and they have this amazing Italian restaurant. We had the special of a lg 1 topping pizza and 12 wings. The pizza was perfect! And the wings are the best wings I’ve had in a long time. Keep up the great work!!
Michyll B
Love their trio pizza!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
George Potter
I had the mamma special cold cut foot long sub. It was packed with meat and very good. It was so big the next time I go. I'm ordering it again and eating half of it and take the rest of it home. I highly recommend it. Matter of fact I'm going there today.
I placed an order for pizzas and loaded fries during a 2 hour special when they were likely incredibly busy. I had not had what I would determine as good pizza in this area of PA. I mentioned this to the owner because all restaurants here seem to be pizzerias but despite trying everyone’s favorite, none were as good as from restaurants in big cities. I added 2 cannolis at the last minute when checking out at the restaurant. The owner said that their cannolis were amazing. They were freshly piped and not already prepared sitting and getting soft, already a great sign. I should have ordered more! I’ve had cannolis made in Little Italy and homemade by generations of Italian family recipes, this was absolutely one of the best I’ve ever had. I cannot recommend these enough. The pizza was everything I had been missing. The sauce had a little something special to it, the dough was perfectly between thick and thin, and the cheese wasn’t the tasteless junk too many restaurants put on pizzas these days. Now I’m not saying everything on the menu is amazing because I haven’t tried it. You cannot go wrong with the pizza and cannolis though. Their banana peppers were different from anyone else’s I’ve ever tried. They had more spice/heat than most but it only made it better in my opinion. I’m not a huge fan of fries in general, but their loaded fries were abundantly topped and had great flavor. Even better than the food was the owner and staff’s warm attitude. Keep in mind this is a small town so if you want some fancy atmosphere and impeccably dressed waiters, you won’t enjoy it here. If you want to get some of the best take out you’ve ever had though, I definitely recommend the pizza and cannolis. I’ve been dreaming about them ever since.Parking: Parking was plentiful which is incredibly important when carrying a large take out order.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizzas
I have lived in this area for 25+ years and have seen changes with Mammas throughout the years. They have it going on again. high five to the cooks and staff! Recommend the Buffalo chicken pizza. I am not a pizza crust eater but I eat their pizza crust.
The food is so good!! I had a pizzaburger sub. The fries were perfectly golden and crisp. The sub was stuffed with burgers and cheesy...ah I wish my stomach was bottomless and this sub was endless. I don't even remember the service and the atmosphere (they were fine) everything just melted away and it was just me and my pizzaburger. I'm not "Wellsville local" but I might be there so much I'll become one. If you see me, I'll be the one in the corner with my eyes closed savoring every bite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Took my oldest son who was heading back to college in a few days for a calzone. Excellent. Their spinach Calzone was amazing. They have so many great items on their menu and their specials look and taste awesome too. Service was fast and friendly. We even had a little bit of "entertainment" (reminded me of when all 3 of my sons were little and we'd go out).So glad to have this gem of a restaurant close by.Go check it out. You won't be disappointed!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
AWESOME! Great meatlovers pizza, the pretzal boli is the best I've ever had! Delivery was excellent time and friendly! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers
Great food and super friendly staff!!
We could not be any more pleased with mamas with lot having many delivery places in dillsburg mamas never disappoints us, sometimes the delivery will be long on the weekends but it’s worth the wait and we’ll appreciated that they deliver to us! We love the two subs and a side specials and one pizza and wings. Always so friendly on the phone and at the door. Thank you for serving us hot delicious food.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheesesteak Pizzazolla, Italian Sub, Chicken Wings
Extremely friendly owner. I did not care for the pizza. The owner's young daughter was playing in the seating area and sat down with us for most of our meal.She was very cute, but very annoying. Mom made 2 attempts to get her to leave us alone, then forgot about it.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 3
Ordered wings n ff they were excellent. As far as the subs horrible all roll and very little meat. Boli horrible hardly any meat ends had no meat. Alot of wasted money spent, wont be going again!
Delicious hot meals and cold subs, salads and more. They have specialty pizzas like a Maryland style "crabby" and Greek Gyro. The owners and staff go above and beyond for the community and are loved by all. When we first moved into town and had to order out, our first night here, we were welcomed by the most caring people around. Just so thankful for this place.Vegetarian options: Great saladsKid-friendliness: Great place for kids
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pasta with Meatballs, Old Bay Fries, Antipesto, Homemade Lasagna, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Cheesesteak Pizzazolla, Custom Pizza, Sausage, Meat Pizza, Meat Lovers, Buffalo Chicken, Garlic Bread, Veggie Pizza, Wings, Veggie Pretzel Stromboli, Italian Sub, Breaded Mushrooms, Lasagna, Rodeo Burger, Chicken Wings
Restaurantji Recommends
Owner is great, very good pizza and personable excellent
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It sucks when you call and stop for something to eat only to find they closed early because it was a little slow that evening. So many places think they can make up whatever hours they want these days and customer service dies because of it. I’m so disappointed because I usually have good service here.
A beautiful small town and they have this amazing Italian restaurant. We had the special of a lg 1 topping pizza and 12 wings. The pizza was perfect! And the wings are the best wings I’ve had in a long time. Keep up the great work!!
Love their trio pizza!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I had the mamma special cold cut foot long sub. It was packed with meat and very good. It was so big the next time I go. I'm ordering it again and eating half of it and take the rest of it home. I highly recommend it. Matter of fact I'm going there today.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Italian Sub