The pizza is ok. It was like a really salty Grotto look a like. The price and speed of service were right. I could see other folks really liking it, it just wasn't for me. This isn't a bad review, I just can't give 5 stars to something I didn't like.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Jeff T.
Delicious. How do they get so much flavor from such a thin pizza? I'll be back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Scott Jones
My favorite pizza been going to Shelley's sense I was 12 yrs. old!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Caleb Keegan
Their bacon pizza is delicious and service was amazing
David Richardson
Awesome cheap pizza. Plus theyre open pretty late! I got no complaints. Plus the really pretty woman working there was super friendly!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stephen Dule
I have to say, I've had Shelly's before and never really enjoyed it. However, my family got some for the Super Bowl and I was highly impressed. Not sure if they changed their recipe, but it just hit different. The cheese blend was very flavorful, and the crust was cooked well but not over crunchy. The sauce did its job, nothing impressive. Pizza was a solid 7.5/10.
Food: 5
no id
This is a very unique pizza in that it has a taste and flavor all it's own thin yet packs a lot of flavor the best pepperoni and mushroom pie in this area very pleasing to the palate. I also enjoy getting onions as a topping or even a plain pie. Theres a reason this pizzeria has been around for 40 plus years.
Really delicious steak stromboli! Ordered mine w/ everything (steak/cheese/onions/sweet peppers). Large comes with 2 large cups of marinara sauce, I got mild banana peppers on the side as well. As others said, it does look very "flat" but the flavor is on point! The texture of the crust is soft and chewy in the inside but slightly crunchy on the outside. Even if it gets a little soggy, it's delish.Pizza is Def similar to an NYC style flavor and crust! Similar crust to the boli...and the price was right. Def will be back!
Brett Robinson
Awesome pizza everytime I order! The two ladies are very nice and friendly!
Monique Dakin
first time going last week and the food was amazing pizza and the boli will be back again
Just had my first pizza from Shelley’s …. FANTASTIC ?
Josh Cohen
The pizza here reminds me a bit of the dollar slices in NYC. The dough has more of the texture than many of the other pizza spots in the area.
Phil125
Always one of my favorite places to get pizza. Good crust and sauce. One of the best in town.
Jake S
Decent pizza if Gerry and Angelo’s are in a 2 he wait. I recommend the sausage w extra cheese.
Andrew Platt
I am from New Jersey, and I always miss the Pizza. From the places I’ve tried, this has most closely resembled the flavor I seek. Very good, will be back. CASH ONLY
The pizza is ok. It was like a really salty Grotto look a like. The price and speed of service were right. I could see other folks really liking it, it just wasn't for me. This isn't a bad review, I just can't give 5 stars to something I didn't like.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Delicious. How do they get so much flavor from such a thin pizza? I'll be back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
My favorite pizza been going to Shelley's sense I was 12 yrs. old!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Their bacon pizza is delicious and service was amazing
Awesome cheap pizza. Plus theyre open pretty late! I got no complaints. Plus the really pretty woman working there was super friendly!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I have to say, I've had Shelly's before and never really enjoyed it. However, my family got some for the Super Bowl and I was highly impressed. Not sure if they changed their recipe, but it just hit different. The cheese blend was very flavorful, and the crust was cooked well but not over crunchy. The sauce did its job, nothing impressive. Pizza was a solid 7.5/10.
Food: 5
This is a very unique pizza in that it has a taste and flavor all it's own thin yet packs a lot of flavor the best pepperoni and mushroom pie in this area very pleasing to the palate. I also enjoy getting onions as a topping or even a plain pie. Theres a reason this pizzeria has been around for 40 plus years.
Really delicious steak stromboli! Ordered mine w/ everything (steak/cheese/onions/sweet peppers). Large comes with 2 large cups of marinara sauce, I got mild banana peppers on the side as well. As others said, it does look very "flat" but the flavor is on point! The texture of the crust is soft and chewy in the inside but slightly crunchy on the outside. Even if it gets a little soggy, it's delish.Pizza is Def similar to an NYC style flavor and crust! Similar crust to the boli...and the price was right. Def will be back!
Awesome pizza everytime I order! The two ladies are very nice and friendly!
first time going last week and the food was amazing pizza and the boli will be back again
Restaurantji Recommends
Just had my first pizza from Shelley’s …. FANTASTIC ?
The pizza here reminds me a bit of the dollar slices in NYC. The dough has more of the texture than many of the other pizza spots in the area.
Always one of my favorite places to get pizza. Good crust and sauce. One of the best in town.
Decent pizza if Gerry and Angelo’s are in a 2 he wait. I recommend the sausage w extra cheese.
I am from New Jersey, and I always miss the Pizza. From the places I’ve tried, this has most closely resembled the flavor I seek. Very good, will be back. CASH ONLY