Had two small(12in) pizzas the size of a dinner plate. The plain pizza was $16.95 and the margherita was $21!!! Outrageous prices! Their answer to that was they were switching menus and hadn’t changed pricing yet. My answer…then don’t give out the new menu until you’ve changed your pricing. And…offer one size pizza. I bought a large from another local place and it was the same price as the small you sold me.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 5
Tom Allsman
Ordered the cheese pizza and the tomato pie to go and both were excellent! I don't think many people know this place is open and/or changed owners.**New owners - if you're reading this, don't keep your fantastic pizza a secret, get the word out. What you need is a Valpak campaign. Contact me if you'd like to learn how we could boost your business.**
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ben Marcus
The food and atmosphere is
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Caesar, Fries
Matt Palmer
Have been there 3-4 times so far, very friendly and food is delicious. Great pies! Really enjoy it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza
Naor
As a transplant from NJ I've struggled to find good pizza for the last 4 years, but Sauce has finally delivered! Everything from crust to the sauce was perfectly done. Gals on the phone and at pickup were professional and pleasant. Our new favorite pizza place ? ❤️
Food: 5
Service: 5
Libbey Lemm
I arrived to order pizza for eat in. I arrived 10 minutes earlier than my daughter and 3 young grandchildren. The arrived. No other guests eating in.Waited and waited .. went to ask if something was wrong (it was now 40 minutes since I arrived and ordered). I was told they were backed up. I asked if my pizzas were in the oven. They were not. We left as kids were starting to lose it. They prioritize online and call in orders over seated guests. I guess eating in is not a good idea at sauce. Very disappointed.
C P
Really disappointing take out. Caprese salad - tasteless, hard tomato. Pesto pizza had a dull bland pesto with a flat greasy crust. Wanted to like it as it is a small local place but this was not good today. I have had their food before and it had been very good but a big miss this time. Ultimately we threw it out. Staff were friendly and order was on time. July 14, 2022 (evening)
Food: 2
Service: 5
Joey Swope
In my opinion these guys have the absolute best pizza in the whole Yardley area. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
richard
Disclaimer. I don't understand why people like burnt or well done pizza. Went for first time. Read reviews about well done pizza and decided to try anyway. The interior here has no atmosphere very bland for eating in. Got a Brooklyn pie and asked counter person if it was served burnt or well done. I was told no. I got the pizza, looked and smelled very good. Took a bite and very crispy and dry. Looked at crust..almost burnt. Somewhat tasty but cant gey by the dry over cooked pizza. If they took it out of the oven 3 minutes earlier it would have been delicious. Again, i dont understand burnt pizza. I wont be back. A pizza was also 23 bucks. Seems high for pizza that is almost inedible to my family. Wont be back here. If you are a fan of burnt pizza...maybe you will like it
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Denise Turner-Byfield
Was so excited to get our white pie home only to be let down. It tastes like someone put pepper on the pizza. I can't give it to my kids like that. The cheese tasted old. It tasted like a left over pizza. I hope I can give it a 2nd chance but not happy about my first experience especially since the reviews are so good. Just disappointing ?
Not what I expected from a pie this price. Called sauce Yardley but not enough sauce or cheese on the pie. Got the hot pizza and it unfortunately tasted like hot honey bread. The place and people working were nice, quality of the pizza, not so nice.
Jenna P.
Quality control issue.. the entire underside of the pizza was burnt but not in a “wood fired” way. The sausage was crumbled so small on the sausage pizza it was hard to discern it was even there. The meatball dish was tasty especially with the ricotta+long hot so that’s why I gave 3 stars. The garlic knots left something to be desired, they needed salt.
Dean Fiorentino
Friendly staff and great food. My wife and I were really pleased with pizza and garlic knots. The pizza had a nice thin crust and the garlic knots were cooked perfectly! We highly recommend getting the garlic knots with the melted mozzarella on top, definite game changer!
Rachael Decker
This restaurant has so much business that they don’t care about customer service. Everything is always late and something is always missing. The only consistent thing about this place is their ability to disappoint. There are plenty of other places to get pizza from in Yardley and you’ll be doing yourself a favor if you go elsewhere,
Grant Olson
Might be the best pizza I've ever had, and I lived in NYC for 9 years. Yet another incredible restaurant in Yardley. I don't know what they do, but the crust is incredible. It's right up there with DeLorenzo's for best pizza in the area.
Had two small(12in) pizzas the size of a dinner plate. The plain pizza was $16.95 and the margherita was $21!!! Outrageous prices! Their answer to that was they were switching menus and hadn’t changed pricing yet. My answer…then don’t give out the new menu until you’ve changed your pricing. And…offer one size pizza. I bought a large from another local place and it was the same price as the small you sold me.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 5
Ordered the cheese pizza and the tomato pie to go and both were excellent! I don't think many people know this place is open and/or changed owners.**New owners - if you're reading this, don't keep your fantastic pizza a secret, get the word out. What you need is a Valpak campaign. Contact me if you'd like to learn how we could boost your business.**
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food and atmosphere is
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Caesar, Fries
Have been there 3-4 times so far, very friendly and food is delicious. Great pies! Really enjoy it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza
As a transplant from NJ I've struggled to find good pizza for the last 4 years, but Sauce has finally delivered! Everything from crust to the sauce was perfectly done. Gals on the phone and at pickup were professional and pleasant. Our new favorite pizza place ? ❤️
Food: 5
Service: 5
I arrived to order pizza for eat in. I arrived 10 minutes earlier than my daughter and 3 young grandchildren. The arrived. No other guests eating in.Waited and waited .. went to ask if something was wrong (it was now 40 minutes since I arrived and ordered). I was told they were backed up. I asked if my pizzas were in the oven. They were not. We left as kids were starting to lose it. They prioritize online and call in orders over seated guests. I guess eating in is not a good idea at sauce. Very disappointed.
Really disappointing take out. Caprese salad - tasteless, hard tomato. Pesto pizza had a dull bland pesto with a flat greasy crust. Wanted to like it as it is a small local place but this was not good today. I have had their food before and it had been very good but a big miss this time. Ultimately we threw it out. Staff were friendly and order was on time. July 14, 2022 (evening)
Food: 2
Service: 5
In my opinion these guys have the absolute best pizza in the whole Yardley area. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Disclaimer. I don't understand why people like burnt or well done pizza. Went for first time. Read reviews about well done pizza and decided to try anyway. The interior here has no atmosphere very bland for eating in. Got a Brooklyn pie and asked counter person if it was served burnt or well done. I was told no. I got the pizza, looked and smelled very good. Took a bite and very crispy and dry. Looked at crust..almost burnt. Somewhat tasty but cant gey by the dry over cooked pizza. If they took it out of the oven 3 minutes earlier it would have been delicious. Again, i dont understand burnt pizza. I wont be back. A pizza was also 23 bucks. Seems high for pizza that is almost inedible to my family. Wont be back here. If you are a fan of burnt pizza...maybe you will like it
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Was so excited to get our white pie home only to be let down. It tastes like someone put pepper on the pizza. I can't give it to my kids like that. The cheese tasted old. It tasted like a left over pizza. I hope I can give it a 2nd chance but not happy about my first experience especially since the reviews are so good. Just disappointing ?
Food: 2
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
Not what I expected from a pie this price. Called sauce Yardley but not enough sauce or cheese on the pie. Got the hot pizza and it unfortunately tasted like hot honey bread. The place and people working were nice, quality of the pizza, not so nice.
Quality control issue.. the entire underside of the pizza was burnt but not in a “wood fired” way. The sausage was crumbled so small on the sausage pizza it was hard to discern it was even there. The meatball dish was tasty especially with the ricotta+long hot so that’s why I gave 3 stars. The garlic knots left something to be desired, they needed salt.
Friendly staff and great food. My wife and I were really pleased with pizza and garlic knots. The pizza had a nice thin crust and the garlic knots were cooked perfectly! We highly recommend getting the garlic knots with the melted mozzarella on top, definite game changer!
This restaurant has so much business that they don’t care about customer service. Everything is always late and something is always missing. The only consistent thing about this place is their ability to disappoint. There are plenty of other places to get pizza from in Yardley and you’ll be doing yourself a favor if you go elsewhere,
Might be the best pizza I've ever had, and I lived in NYC for 9 years. Yet another incredible restaurant in Yardley. I don't know what they do, but the crust is incredible. It's right up there with DeLorenzo's for best pizza in the area.