Lucky Luciano's Pizzeria

600 Chestnut St, York
(717) 771-1077

Recent Reviews

saphronia Seay

What happen? The shop has been closed for 2 months. Concern customer..

Atmosphere: 5

Raymond Richards

Every time we order our order gets canceled for whatever reason issue needs to be fixed or they just need to shut

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 1

aucool786

Best deep dish pizza in the city!For Muslim customers, the store is now staffed by a Muslim brother and I was told by him that the pepperoni here is now beef! Be sure to ask for it!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amilynn Duran

The pizza itself was disgusting. Undercooked and too saucy… the place didn’t have any seating but online it said it did. Very expensive for two small fries and 2 personal pizzas it was 25 dollars !!!!!!!!! Horrible placeKid-friendliness: Too small about 3 people could fit there Max

Angela Faith

Ordered a pizza and kids cheeseburger with fries (kids menu) instead got a pizza and sub ????? super disappointed and unhappy. Dont make my mistake and just assuming and take the wrong

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

Michelle Y.

I ordered homemade chicken noodle soup and got Campbell's canned chicken noodle soup.

Stephen Jacoby

Avoid At all costs! Completely false online menu. No refunds given for wrong orders. Ordered a regular cheesesteak and received shrimp. Had to call my bank and had my money pulled from them instantly. Customer service is 2 guys smoking pot on the front deck in front of customers. If you want reliable service and quality food, i suggest to avoid this place at all costs.

Hanna Davis

Ordered a California cheesesteak and got a steak with shrimp. I’m also allergic to shellfish. I called and asked if I could come and get the cheesesteak I had originally ordered and they wanted to charge me and extra 9 dollars and refused to give me a refund. I definitely do not recommend going here. Save yourself the trip.

Sherry King

We ordered a deep dish pizza and the crust was burnt so bad the whole pizza tasted burned. Not knowing it was no longer a dine in restaurant as it says online my family and I walked to eat there. There was no where to sit so we stood for 45 mins while waiting for our food. The whole time the 2 people working were more interested in doing other side business then watching the food. I regret not checking the food before leaving. I will never eat here again

Andrew Shissler

Traveling and staying in the area and I had a craving for a Chicago deep dish pizza.Google took me here. It's in a quiet little multicultural neighborhood. Very nice vibe. I ordered my pizza and sat out on the stoop while it was baking.The pizza shop is also a bodega type store with limited selection of sundries, beverages and the like.This Chicago deep dish pizza was absolutely worth the wait.It's a 12-in pizza. He handed me the box. It must have weighed 5 lb! This thing is like a lasagna with pizza crust.Also this thing should have cost $5 more. I can't believe the value for the amount of food.It's a good thing I have plastic forks and knives in my suitcase!The guy and the lady were super nice and friendly too.If you want a good Chicago pizza, come here! I think next time I will give their New York style a try.The only reason I give it five stars is because I can't give it six.Excellent.

Jason Larbi

Amazing food! Easy ordering processI was in the mood for deep dish pizza and I have to admit this place knocked it out of the park I also got an order of cheese fries and OMG the fries were hot and crispy and cheese was all over the top and bottom can't wait to try the other food on the menu.

Stacie Gordon

Best pizza in York! Perfect amount of cheese and the sauce has flavor. French fries are great too and they give you a good amount. Haven’t tried anything else yet because we can’t get past how good the pizza is here. Must try!

Lequilla English

The cheese steaks and pizza ?is very good ?i would give 5 stars but they're never open!

Adam Dischert

Good pizza real old school feel! Front counter person was very welcoming!

Wade Housseal

Excellent food. Decent pricing. Some of the best pizza I've ever tasted. Very friendly owner. Polite service. I will definitely be a repeat customer.

Load More