Rebecca's Seafood

435 Water St, New Shoreham
(401) 466-5411

Recent Reviews

YESENIA RUIZ

Service was horrible! The girl taking the orders acted as if she hates her job. She was rude and confronational. A oído this place.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Salad

Nathan

Its the place to go for a fast bargain, food is average what you would expect from a place like that.

luke almeida

It's horrible never would go here

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Val

If i could give this place 0 stars, i would.Their breakfast ends at 11:30a, I got there and ordered at 10:52a. After some time waiting I decided to go up and asked what had happened to the food, this is when they tell me they do not know and are no longer cooking breakfast. They literally lost my order and if it wasnt for the fact that I decided to ask, I wouldve wasted so much more time waiting.Will not be returning.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Val G.

If i could give this place 0 stars, i would.Their breakfast ends at 11:30a, I got there and ordered at 10:52a. After some time waiting I decided to go up and asked what had happened to the food, this is when they tell me they do not know and are no longer cooking breakfast. They literally lost my order and if it wasnt for the fact that I decided to ask, I wouldve wasted so much more time waiting.Will not be returning.

Christine Nunziato-Bonenfant

For convenience to the ferry, speed of service, outdoor seating with umbrellas, and price, this is your place to go. Cash only. Breakfast, lunch, dinner, large selection, burgers, sandwiches, wraps, seafood dinners.

Food: 5

debraj ghosal

Good place to have good fried seafood.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

capemate

I don’t know if Rebecca’s is under new management, or they just don’t give a s$@t anymore. For at least 10 years the people I work with have been ordering from there several times a summer. Anywhere between seven to 10 of us. It was always solid, and pre-Covid the least expensive place on Block Island. You got your moneys worth, for fresh seafood cooked well. I’ve been ordering the mahi-mahi there forever. Well today I ordered the blackened mahi sandwich with no tartar sauce. My only regret is I didn’t take a picture of this pathetic sandwich. To start with it was swimming in tartar sauce. The piece of fresh was 1/3 of the size of the bun. Literally about the size of one and a half sardines. Loaded with tartar sauce and shredded browning lettuce. They had the nerve to charge $15 for this crappy excuse of a sandwich. This is the first time I’ve been there this year, and the last. Last week we all decided to go to the beach head. I had the blackened cajun tuna steak sandwich. Mind you it cost $22, and it was worth every cent. A huge thick piece of meat cooked and seasoned perfectly. Also, since we’ve been working over there for the past couple weeks, I’d like to recommend old Island pub, and poor peoples peoples pub. They always were and still are solid choices for lunch. Everyone knows the price of all food stuffs has going up. That’s fine, but the sandwich I got wasn’t worth more than three dollars. Again, I wish I had a picture to post. You could do better at your local McDonald’s.

Sara Ragland

Tiny portions which is fine because the food was aweful. Overpriced and overdone. We went simple with a chowder, wrap and sides and all were bad.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Muela Cascona

Amazing family owned restaurant. Took a little bit to get my food but service was good and it is expected for food to take long to get since they had a lot of orders. Quality of the food was amazing, fresh and tasty. I would definitely go here again.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

C E.

Closed. Not even a sign outside! There is a building but that's it. Someone should shut this biz down online.

Peter Saunders

The atmosphere was lively, filled with excitement and anticipation. We were greeted warmly at the door and we received outstanding service throughout our visit. While the oysters were excellent we were disappointed by bland tasting lobster. Also, we were charged $60 for three glasses of wine. We were surprised since we’ve paid $30 or less for comparable wine in similar restaurants in the Boston area.

Atmosphere: 5

Olya BL

No comments needed! Truly amazing ? ? ❤️ Would call it my second home spot every season Quality of food/seafood/cute spot/pricing is ? ? ?

Kyle Civitello

The Mahi fish tacos were outstanding. Decent prices for seafood

B Johnson

Hot, Tasty, eggs cooked perfect, good value, good service. What more can you ask for?

Load More