This is our goto pizza place when we come to HHI on vacation. The pizza is really good. Appetizers are good. The wait staff is always great. In addition there is always a good choice of drinks!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Fat Baby Pizza
Daneen Kincaid
2nd visit to this spot. Convenient location and fair prices, especially on the island. Husband ordered a pizza and I had the hot Italian sub.My sub was exactly what I had hoped for. The bread was crusty and fresh. Homemade fries were also a bonus!Hubby's pizza was okay, a nice NY style crust. Buy overall just average.The dining was especially busy, even though it was past 2 pm. The servers were friendly, but it did take too long to get our check. They did a good job with drink refills.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
terry nathan
They need to rethink how they handle pick up orders when it is busy there. Way too slow to check out.
Dakota S.
Great place for lunch or dinner! Some of the best pizza on Hilton Head
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Denis B.
Service: Good Food: Not so good this time Went to Fat Baby's and ordered a Greek salad that was simple iceberg lettuce with all the added that you normally find in a Greek salad. Ordered slices of pizza: My wife ordered cheese and I ordered the Fat Baby slice. The cheese was so thin and soggy that you would've thought it was a wet noodle. My slice was the same because it appeared they took a cheese slice, threw the toppings on and "attempted" to reheat it in the oven. Wasn't even close to being warm and the veggies were completely raw. If my rating was just based on this, they'd receive a one start however, the garlic knots were very good and the server was friendly and attentive for the most part. I did order a beer when our slices were delivered and I finally cancelled when we were about done eating because it never showed up...and they weren't that busy. I know they do better than this but this visit fell flat.
Johnny M.
This was our second time going here, the food is always good and fresh. Our server Julia was great, we never wanted for anything, even the manager Josie came by and sit at our table to ask how our food and service was this visit. We love to look at the pictures drawn of Fat Baby by kids from all over the place.
James Bard
Service was slow. Server saw us but was no urgency to greet us.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Lori Robbins
We had an enjoyable experience at lunch. We came just before the rush on Friday at lunch time and our server quickly got busy but she was on it and kind and didn’t skip a beat. She’s was so great!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, Garlic Knots, The Fat Baby Pizza
Ana Hernandez
Me and my best friends went out to dinner here. You could say we didn't have a fun night out. After deciding to go eat here I was already craving pizza. When we sat down and began to order, our server seemed to have been already annoyed. This through my mood and created a weird vibe the rest of the time we had been there. The food quality was horrible, my pizza was soggy and the garlic knots were atrocious. 0/10 experience any tourists looking for local cuisinse, reconsider Fat Babies.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Richard Moniuszko
I ordered the half chicken and 2 sides, looking for a "meat and three" meal. Chicken was dried out and even Mac and cheese was mediocre. Maybe their pizza and subs are better. Three stars was generous. Background music was too loud, service was ok.
Looks like a great local bar hangoutWe were seated immediately. The server was quick.Food was
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nick
Pizza and chicken Parm sub was great, enjoyed the fries as
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michelle Patricia
Ordered take out and the food was phenomenal. Loved the garlic knots! We ordered 3 pizzas- plain, pepperoni, and the py one . All great and delicious. What we loved the most is that it reminded us of pizza back in NY. The bread and crust were done so fresh and perfect. Ordered a grilled chicken salad- chicken was juicy and well seasoned. I especially loved the chicken tenders. Wow the tenders were amazing. To say this place exceeded our expectations is an understatement. When we went to go pick up our order, they did tell us it would take another 20 mins. So they offered us a drink at the bar and apologized for the inconvenience. Overall friendly and courteous. Will be ordering again soon before we leave SC.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chrissy Diaz
We came for my birthday dinner and ordered enough food to feed an army. We tried everything and it was all AMAZING! The meatballs are divine. Awesome staff, super inviting. Excellent service (thanks Amanda!) and great vibes.
We had an amazing lunch. Had their pizza and wife had chicken wrap. Wife said best chicken wrap she had in a long time. And the pizza is what I imagine what new York pizza would taste like. Best little place on pur trip.Would love to come back again.BTW our host who was the bartender as well was A1 best server I have ever had.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Buffalo Chicken, Chicken Fingers with Hand Cut Chips & Honey Mustard, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, The Fat Baby Pizza
This is our goto pizza place when we come to HHI on vacation. The pizza is really good. Appetizers are good. The wait staff is always great. In addition there is always a good choice of drinks!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Fat Baby Pizza
2nd visit to this spot. Convenient location and fair prices, especially on the island. Husband ordered a pizza and I had the hot Italian sub.My sub was exactly what I had hoped for. The bread was crusty and fresh. Homemade fries were also a bonus!Hubby's pizza was okay, a nice NY style crust. Buy overall just average.The dining was especially busy, even though it was past 2 pm. The servers were friendly, but it did take too long to get our check. They did a good job with drink refills.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
They need to rethink how they handle pick up orders when it is busy there. Way too slow to check out.
Great place for lunch or dinner! Some of the best pizza on Hilton Head
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Service: Good Food: Not so good this time Went to Fat Baby's and ordered a Greek salad that was simple iceberg lettuce with all the added that you normally find in a Greek salad. Ordered slices of pizza: My wife ordered cheese and I ordered the Fat Baby slice. The cheese was so thin and soggy that you would've thought it was a wet noodle. My slice was the same because it appeared they took a cheese slice, threw the toppings on and "attempted" to reheat it in the oven. Wasn't even close to being warm and the veggies were completely raw. If my rating was just based on this, they'd receive a one start however, the garlic knots were very good and the server was friendly and attentive for the most part. I did order a beer when our slices were delivered and I finally cancelled when we were about done eating because it never showed up...and they weren't that busy. I know they do better than this but this visit fell flat.
This was our second time going here, the food is always good and fresh. Our server Julia was great, we never wanted for anything, even the manager Josie came by and sit at our table to ask how our food and service was this visit. We love to look at the pictures drawn of Fat Baby by kids from all over the place.
Service was slow. Server saw us but was no urgency to greet us.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
We had an enjoyable experience at lunch. We came just before the rush on Friday at lunch time and our server quickly got busy but she was on it and kind and didn’t skip a beat. She’s was so great!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, Garlic Knots, The Fat Baby Pizza
Me and my best friends went out to dinner here. You could say we didn't have a fun night out. After deciding to go eat here I was already craving pizza. When we sat down and began to order, our server seemed to have been already annoyed. This through my mood and created a weird vibe the rest of the time we had been there. The food quality was horrible, my pizza was soggy and the garlic knots were atrocious. 0/10 experience any tourists looking for local cuisinse, reconsider Fat Babies.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I ordered the half chicken and 2 sides, looking for a "meat and three" meal. Chicken was dried out and even Mac and cheese was mediocre. Maybe their pizza and subs are better. Three stars was generous. Background music was too loud, service was ok.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Looks like a great local bar hangoutWe were seated immediately. The server was quick.Food was
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza and chicken Parm sub was great, enjoyed the fries as
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered take out and the food was phenomenal. Loved the garlic knots! We ordered 3 pizzas- plain, pepperoni, and the py one . All great and delicious. What we loved the most is that it reminded us of pizza back in NY. The bread and crust were done so fresh and perfect. Ordered a grilled chicken salad- chicken was juicy and well seasoned. I especially loved the chicken tenders. Wow the tenders were amazing. To say this place exceeded our expectations is an understatement. When we went to go pick up our order, they did tell us it would take another 20 mins. So they offered us a drink at the bar and apologized for the inconvenience. Overall friendly and courteous. Will be ordering again soon before we leave SC.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We came for my birthday dinner and ordered enough food to feed an army. We tried everything and it was all AMAZING! The meatballs are divine. Awesome staff, super inviting. Excellent service (thanks Amanda!) and great vibes.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fried Mozzarella, Buffalo Chicken Pizza
We had an amazing lunch. Had their pizza and wife had chicken wrap. Wife said best chicken wrap she had in a long time. And the pizza is what I imagine what new York pizza would taste like. Best little place on pur trip.Would love to come back again.BTW our host who was the bartender as well was A1 best server I have ever had.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Buffalo Chicken, Chicken Fingers with Hand Cut Chips & Honey Mustard, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, The Fat Baby Pizza