Gators Pizza & Wings

40 Folly Field Rd, Hilton Head Island
(843) 842-0004

Recent Reviews

Shaun Pitcher

Waited 5 minutes to be seated. The employees just looked at me and went back to what they were doing. After asking around, I should probably be thankful!

Service: 1

Hawk

Best pizza I've had in a while. I recommend getting the white

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Pizza with Pepperoni Sausage and Black Olives

Jorgensen Norge

Overpriced thin crust pizza with no toppings as ordered. Go somewhere else.

Food: 2

Tasim Muca

Their hours are WRONG. They close earlier NOTTTTTTT 12:00 am.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Chauncey g.

Top quality pizza 7.6

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kandace Krantz

Placed our order with our waiter. Waited an hour for a food (which is fine) the waiter came out and asked if we needed to go boxes, we hadn’t even gotten our food yet. He came back out 20 minutes later and asked us what we had ordered … He had never even put the order for our food in. When I told him we were just going to leave because I couldn’t wait another hour with a 3 year old. He didn’t even apologize for forgetting for over an hour that he never put our food in. I can’t speak on if the food is good or not because we never actually got to eat anything, but with the service alone we will not be returning. This is the first place on Hilton Head I have ever been unhappy with.

Dolly Cominsky

Food was awesome... planning to go back for my next trip to Bluffton. Alligator bites were the best!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Matthew G

Was surprised that this pizza place was so below average as many good reviews - pizza tasted like cardboard with no sauce and could buy frozen pizza that is much better or just order dominoes. I only write this as an FYI, as the service of the restaurant was fine, but just again the pizza was hard to eat.

ryanw152

Pizza and wings was very good. Had to wait 20 minutes before allowed to place an order due to kitchen back up. Little pricey but over all good food.

Todd McFarlin

Placed an order via phone, and when we arrived they told us the order never went through. Complete waste of our time.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

Laura Gold

Delivery guy was very honest and polite. Food was good and enjoyed for lunch day after.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kurt Meierdierks

Great pizza, large, tasty, and great price, considering how much you get.

Mike Z

Ordered pizza because it was a convenient location. It was no good. Would recommend going somewhere else.

Shelby M

Pretty good and friendly staff! I enjoyed what we ordered.

Alex Srodowski

I’ve never eaten a worse pizza in my life. The place is horrendously overpriced as well.There’s a Circle K gas station down the street that blows the food out of the water if you’re left with no other options.The staff was absolutely miserable, and the food matches the mood. Please do yourself a favor and save yourself the stomach aches both figuratively and literally.

Load More