Everything overall was great. The smoked sirloin option was tough and stringy, however everything else was wonderful. Service for a buffet should have been more attentive, however everyone was polite. Pricing was a bit steep.
The only thing worse than the "seafood buffet" was the awful table of people next to us. They were blatantly bad-mouthing everyone around them. That's not the restaurant's fault, though. The best thing on the buffet was the salad bar. Mahi and salmon were so fishy they were inedible. She crab soup had chunks of flour in it. The desserts were left out on a table so flies kept landing on them. The cheesecake and key lime pie were warm and probably not safe to eat. We've had good meals while staying here, I would recommend ordering off the menu.
We are staying at the resort and had dinner here. We were one of 3 tables on a Friday night. Service was great and the food was very good! I had the snapper and it was delicious. My husband had the seafood pasta and my dad had the filet, which he raved about. Highly recommend!
StephenS
The staff were all very friendly and accommodating! The food was absolutely delicious and a great meal to start our trip with. Definitely on the pricer side, but definitely not for nothing. We will definitely be back.
MikeN
Our server, Carlton, was excellent!!! We were disappointed that while we made a reservation for the outdoor terrace, we were seated inside due to a private event. Restaurant should have had the courtesy to inform us. Otherwise, this is a beautiful venue.
MarkM
Wonderful breakfast buffet in a beautiful location. Value listed as "fair" as it is a resort breakfast buffet and comes at a premium price. Regardless, we are local and go there multiple times per year for the food and ambiance.
marysia
I did not know that the restaurant was part of a resort. Even though that this was not a typical Thanksgiving getaway. It was nice that they served a home cooked Thanksgiving dinner. It satisfied the craving for a Thanksgiving dinner without me making it. I am usually the host and I needed a break. Thank You. I left overly full.
SJM1
Carlton was awesome. Food was great (salmon a bit over cooked) we could have done without the horribly loud wedding noise/music-didn't seem appropriate for such a small place and right at pool/rooms surrounding the restaurant where people have no choice but to be subjected to it. But that aside...great!
The food was very delicious. The empanadas for the starters were great and the Black and mahi was great over their Greek salad. The mocktail was just a little too sweet too. Sugary
Rita
Great food and location near the beach. Service was excellent. However, we ordered draught beer and it was warm rather than cold. The server apologized and let us send it back and order bottled beer which was cold.
This was simple American fare we had three people get the Caesar salad with chicken and one had the beyond burger and one had rib-eye steak. So simple dishes that really don't generate much excitement anyway but all was good and reasonably priced compared to some other high priced places on the island.
MiaMoss
Not worth it. We only went to the hotel restaurant because it was raining and it was not it! Food was bland and portions were very small. Pina Colada had no alcohol or at least we couldn't find it or feel it. Wasted money.
The food was poor quality, especially for the price. The chicken on the chicken sandwich was half the size of the bun. The She Crab soup had too many pieces of shell to eat it. I could go on with the other entrees.
Katie
We loved our server the first night! We enjoyed the appetizer but everything else was just okay. My pasta was like soup with noodles and my dads steak wasn't worth the price. I'd go off the resort for dinner!
out2dine
We enjoyed the Seacrest for dinner. The waiter was very friendly and attentive. The ribeye entree was very tender and delicious. Rum cocktails were strong and very good. There were several families dining, but the noise wasn't too loud. Overall a great place to dine and we got right in, compared to other local restaurants with over an hour and a half wait with no reservations.
Everything overall was great. The smoked sirloin option was tough and stringy, however everything else was wonderful. Service for a buffet should have been more attentive, however everyone was polite. Pricing was a bit steep.
The only thing worse than the "seafood buffet" was the awful table of people next to us. They were blatantly bad-mouthing everyone around them. That's not the restaurant's fault, though. The best thing on the buffet was the salad bar. Mahi and salmon were so fishy they were inedible. She crab soup had chunks of flour in it. The desserts were left out on a table so flies kept landing on them. The cheesecake and key lime pie were warm and probably not safe to eat. We've had good meals while staying here, I would recommend ordering off the menu.
We are staying at the resort and had dinner here. We were one of 3 tables on a Friday night. Service was great and the food was very good! I had the snapper and it was delicious. My husband had the seafood pasta and my dad had the filet, which he raved about. Highly recommend!
The staff were all very friendly and accommodating! The food was absolutely delicious and a great meal to start our trip with. Definitely on the pricer side, but definitely not for nothing. We will definitely be back.
Our server, Carlton, was excellent!!! We were disappointed that while we made a reservation for the outdoor terrace, we were seated inside due to a private event. Restaurant should have had the courtesy to inform us. Otherwise, this is a beautiful venue.
Wonderful breakfast buffet in a beautiful location. Value listed as "fair" as it is a resort breakfast buffet and comes at a premium price. Regardless, we are local and go there multiple times per year for the food and ambiance.
I did not know that the restaurant was part of a resort. Even though that this was not a typical Thanksgiving getaway. It was nice that they served a home cooked Thanksgiving dinner. It satisfied the craving for a Thanksgiving dinner without me making it. I am usually the host and I needed a break. Thank You. I left overly full.
Carlton was awesome. Food was great (salmon a bit over cooked) we could have done without the horribly loud wedding noise/music-didn't seem appropriate for such a small place and right at pool/rooms surrounding the restaurant where people have no choice but to be subjected to it. But that aside...great!
The food was very delicious. The empanadas for the starters were great and the Black and mahi was great over their Greek salad. The mocktail was just a little too sweet too. Sugary
Great food and location near the beach. Service was excellent. However, we ordered draught beer and it was warm rather than cold. The server apologized and let us send it back and order bottled beer which was cold.
Restaurantji Recommends
This was simple American fare we had three people get the Caesar salad with chicken and one had the beyond burger and one had rib-eye steak. So simple dishes that really don't generate much excitement anyway but all was good and reasonably priced compared to some other high priced places on the island.
Not worth it. We only went to the hotel restaurant because it was raining and it was not it! Food was bland and portions were very small. Pina Colada had no alcohol or at least we couldn't find it or feel it. Wasted money.
The food was poor quality, especially for the price. The chicken on the chicken sandwich was half the size of the bun. The She Crab soup had too many pieces of shell to eat it. I could go on with the other entrees.
We loved our server the first night! We enjoyed the appetizer but everything else was just okay. My pasta was like soup with noodles and my dads steak wasn't worth the price. I'd go off the resort for dinner!
We enjoyed the Seacrest for dinner. The waiter was very friendly and attentive. The ribeye entree was very tender and delicious. Rum cocktails were strong and very good. There were several families dining, but the noise wasn't too loud. Overall a great place to dine and we got right in, compared to other local restaurants with over an hour and a half wait with no reservations.