The Other Plate-Food + Lifestyle

426 W Coleman Blvd, Mt Pleasant
(843) 971-3510

Recent Reviews

JDNYFL

We stopped here around 10 pm on our way back to our hotel. There weren't many places open at that hour, not even Taco Bell. The employees seemed like they couldn't be bothered. They only had 1 size pizza, it looked to be about 2 1/2 feet wide, maybe more. It cost $36. Well we weren't that hungry and I'm not paying that much for a pizza. We ended up ordering slices which tasted like cardboard that had been sitting there all day. If you're hungry late at night, look elsewhere!

jointfilms

I popped in this place on a weekday to grab some slices for dinner. I expected to see pies lined up behind glads so I could pick what slices I wanted but none were to be found. They had signs up telling you what they offered. Kind of odd but OK. Ordered a plain slice and veggie slice. Prices per slice were about $5-6. They had a nice cooler full of great drink selections including Joe Tea which I love. But tonight was just here for pizza. Kind of a long wait. I don’t quite understand their system. I think they have plain pies made and then when you order say veggie they toss al the veggies on the plain slice and toss in over to heat. Anyway I finally get the slices and they were huge. Gigantic. Didn’t expect that. Had no idea. Certainly get your money’s worth. So how were they? OK. Decent. Not amazing. Very dense crust. Cheese wasn’t gooey, melty. More kind of stiff for lack of better term. I didn’t dislike it but just not that impressed.

521robh

Not sure what some of the the reviewers issues were, but we really enjoyed this place. Not fancy, just eat in or outside at one of the tables. We each ordered one giant slice of pizza each, which was plenty for me, plus they have their own brand beer which was pretty good.

Archer McDonald

I bought some cookies at comic con and I very much recommend them. They are soft but not too soft, have an appropriate amount of chocolate chips, are bigger than my palm and about 1 cm thick. It’s everything you expect a cookie to be and more.

Michael M.

Wow - I've never given a yelp review before but felt compelled to do so after ordering their burritos. Absolutely fantastic food 10/10 recommend.

David S

Here’s an idea. When someone comes in how about little miss 20 something be a bit more helpful and a bit less nonchalant . Instead of acting like you don’t care if the people in your empty restaurant order or not maybe offer a helpful suggestion. This place is way over priced and way short on customer service. The pizza is unremarkable barely average fare not much different from any frozen pizza from a gas station.

Opal D.

Absolutely loved the salads and am obsessed with the blueberry parfait.... I could probably quit sugary desserts and just eat that every day, it's so good. The avocado breakfast sandwich doesn't keep well so if ordering must eat same morning... I probably wouldn't order that one again. Looking forward to trying other things on their menu. Really happy they have delivery.

davidrM3374RH

First and foremost, let me state that I never write negative reviews and would never do so for any business unless I was treated as this company treated me. To make a long story short, the gentleman who rang my girlfriend and I up charged us twice. The reason this happened was because we decided to add drinks and were planning on paying for them separately, but the guy behind the counter stated the first charge hadn't gone through yet, so he went ahead and charged it a second time with a tip. The next day, I looked at my credit card statement and realized he had charged me twice. So I called the restaurant and explained the situation while also sending over a copy of my credit card statement (twice) showing the charges. After two weeks of trying to get this resolved with the GM and her never getting back to me like she said she would multiple times, she finally told me there was nothing she could do for me. I told her that the company clearly charged me twice and that she was mistaken, as evidenced by my credit card statement, and she basically told me again, sorry about my luck, and there was nothing she would do to correct the mistake or even attempt to make it right. Basically, she forced me to go through the hassle of contacting my bank to initiate a chargeback, which I did. Do yourself a favor and go elsewhere. I used to enjoy going to this place, even though the pizza is just average, but now that I know they don't right their wrongs, I'm going elsewhere. It is very disappointing, and there are too many honest restaurants out there to settle for this type of customer service.

sarahcR5274FC

Went in for pizza like I have for several years. I get a cheese pizza like always. I do not eat meat and haven’t for many years and I am half way through my pizza and there are random pepperoni pieces on them. I immediately went to the bathroom and started to hyperventilate and vomited everywhere!! After I go to the register and the young women and man were very nice and tried to see if I could get a refund so they I just went to ask the manger on duty? Who was a light skinned women sitting down wearing AirPods. I suppose she called the owner and he said no refunds. She was absolutely so rude to me and even told me “good luck” as I walked out. She was extremely rude and coming from someone who works in food and bev I would never treat a costumer like that.

BallmomX2

The pizza slices and whole pizzas are HUGE. (Perfect for a bunch of hungry teenage baseball players!) Service "with a smile" leaves a little be desired...staff looked absolutely miserable when the entire baseball team walked in! Not cheap, but definitely get your money's worth. Flavor of the pizza is ok, not the best but not the worst. Will eat here again, just because we love pizza!!!

Unknown

I just purchased two of the amazing chocolate chip cookies that were being sold by this vendor. I am thoroughly impressed by nit only the attention to detail, but the heart and soul put into baking these delicious cookies. I live near this address in Hollywood, so I hope that one day I have the opportunity to eat something special from this restaurant. I hope that it reopens soon.

Jane S

I was craving a slice for lunch and seems a lot of the pizza stops don’t open until 4 so Benny’s it was! Biggest slice of pizza I have had-could not finish it. Crust was delicious and the sauce and cheese just right. Will definitely order again.

Leigh Anne Conto

Delicious ? Will be on the lookout for your next pop up!

Olivia Addington

the chocolate chip cookies were truly the best ever! i didn't catch her name, but the woman who made them was so kind and genuine!

632alecb

It was a friday. It was after a wedding. It was after a lot of beer. We were starving after all the dancing, drinking, and socializing and only Benny's was ready to deliver beyond mcdonalds or arby's. We ordered just 3 slices for the two of us and it was plenty, these things are HUGE. The crust is crispy, but not crackery, was a satisfying bite. Excellent cheese to sauce and toppings ratio. Would absolutely order again.

Load More