I got the upside down pizza when this place was Palmano's and had plenty sauce on top. Now i got same upside down pizza and was lacking sauce this time. I will mention this next time i get another. By the way it's New York city pizza. Close but no cigar.
Joseph J
I went here with a coworker for our break, and the quality of the food kinda shocked me.I'll be honest, I did judge a book by its cover. Shame on me. I got a slice of pizza and 10 wings.Firstly, the slices are huge...so be warned, and them jokers are good too. The wings aren't small either.I'll definitely be back. No complaints.
Customer
called and called for a pizza on a recent Saturday night at 9:05 pm and no one answered- very frustrating cause we were going to the RV park and wanted a pizza - settled for Bojangles and the chicken and service were great.
Linda Chesko
I ordered a traditional 3 cheese calzone. The thing that makes it a calzone is the ricotta cheese. There was not much in this calzone. The crust and sauce were good and there was a lot of mozzerella cheese. I also had them add mushrooms and onions and they used red onions, my least favorite. The staff and atmosphere were nice enough, an average pizza joint.
Adam Housh
Surprisingly good! Got it for my kids birthday party since they’re close. Really good pizza and garlic bread (order a side of marina sauce too). Girl at the register was super nice and my family loved the food. They sell slices as well. Will go again.
Olin Ballentine
Not the end of th me world… but.. they have got my order wrong twice… learned to check it. The little brunette girl up front is aloof and acts like you are disturbing her… just wants to listen to something on her Earbuds. Last time for me tonight… I made the mistake of calling… I was on hold for 10 mins while I was heading that way… I walked in and those little girls were just standing around talking… stood there at least a minute before they acknowledged me…I asked them if they wanted to assist me on the phone or right there? They looked at me like they didn’t know what I was talking about… they looked at their phone. The one girl showed the phone to the brainiac that put me on hold… she turned to me… no apology… “would you like to order?” NO … walked out.
everette smith
Fast and friendly staff. New York style pizza that taste great. Not a long wait time.
Robert Wilson
I really enjoy their pizza especially the New Yorker.
Kristy Dixon Harden
Visiting Lexington for a softball tournament and found this place on Google and decided to give it a shot. The people are super friendly and the pizza is DELICIOUS. Will definitely visit again when in the area. Thank you for the hospitality!
Nathaniel Kelley
Wife and I ordered takeout. Large pie and a small Greek salad. Salad was super cold and crispy, healthy amount of toppings just the way a nice Greek salad should be. I don’t think we will be going anywhere else for pizza around here now. Definitely authentic NY Style pizza. Dough is delicious, slightly tacky but crispy at the same time. Nice little char flavor from the deck oven on the bottom. If you want pizza in the Columbia area, everyone should be flocking here and supporting the local business. You won’t be let down.
THIS PIZZA IS FOR REAL!!IF YOU WANT TRUE ITALIAN PIZZA, YOU GET IT HERE. THE FOOD, THE SERVICE, IS 2ND TO NONE ????????????????✝️??♥️
Robbin Stewart
Best pizza and appetizers. Friendly atmosphere great service good prices
Heather Austin
I ordered a small pepperoni pizza and it took 30 minutes to get it and there were only 5 pieces of pepperoni!! Wth? I spent way too much money on a custom made pizza and I could have gotten a lot more from Mellow Mushroom or Marcos! Never going back! I am saddened that a locality owned company didn’t do better.
Christopher Spires
Family owned and operated New York style pizza is extremely good, as is the other menu options. By far our favorite pizza place!
Wardlaw F.
Love this place. They are closed on Monday and dealing with staffing issues like all other small businesses. My entire family is from New York, and all of them love this place. You can walk in and grab a lunch special two pieces of pizza and a drink for like $6. They're friendly, it's clean, and they really make you feel like they want your business. One of my favorite lunch spots
I got the upside down pizza when this place was Palmano's and had plenty sauce on top. Now i got same upside down pizza and was lacking sauce this time. I will mention this next time i get another. By the way it's New York city pizza. Close but no cigar.
I went here with a coworker for our break, and the quality of the food kinda shocked me.I'll be honest, I did judge a book by its cover. Shame on me. I got a slice of pizza and 10 wings.Firstly, the slices are huge...so be warned, and them jokers are good too. The wings aren't small either.I'll definitely be back. No complaints.
called and called for a pizza on a recent Saturday night at 9:05 pm and no one answered- very frustrating cause we were going to the RV park and wanted a pizza - settled for Bojangles and the chicken and service were great.
I ordered a traditional 3 cheese calzone. The thing that makes it a calzone is the ricotta cheese. There was not much in this calzone. The crust and sauce were good and there was a lot of mozzerella cheese. I also had them add mushrooms and onions and they used red onions, my least favorite. The staff and atmosphere were nice enough, an average pizza joint.
Surprisingly good! Got it for my kids birthday party since they’re close. Really good pizza and garlic bread (order a side of marina sauce too). Girl at the register was super nice and my family loved the food. They sell slices as well. Will go again.
Not the end of th me world… but.. they have got my order wrong twice… learned to check it. The little brunette girl up front is aloof and acts like you are disturbing her… just wants to listen to something on her Earbuds. Last time for me tonight… I made the mistake of calling… I was on hold for 10 mins while I was heading that way… I walked in and those little girls were just standing around talking… stood there at least a minute before they acknowledged me…I asked them if they wanted to assist me on the phone or right there? They looked at me like they didn’t know what I was talking about… they looked at their phone. The one girl showed the phone to the brainiac that put me on hold… she turned to me… no apology… “would you like to order?” NO … walked out.
Fast and friendly staff. New York style pizza that taste great. Not a long wait time.
I really enjoy their pizza especially the New Yorker.
Visiting Lexington for a softball tournament and found this place on Google and decided to give it a shot. The people are super friendly and the pizza is DELICIOUS. Will definitely visit again when in the area. Thank you for the hospitality!
Wife and I ordered takeout. Large pie and a small Greek salad. Salad was super cold and crispy, healthy amount of toppings just the way a nice Greek salad should be. I don’t think we will be going anywhere else for pizza around here now. Definitely authentic NY Style pizza. Dough is delicious, slightly tacky but crispy at the same time. Nice little char flavor from the deck oven on the bottom. If you want pizza in the Columbia area, everyone should be flocking here and supporting the local business. You won’t be let down.
Restaurantji Recommends
THIS PIZZA IS FOR REAL!!IF YOU WANT TRUE ITALIAN PIZZA, YOU GET IT HERE. THE FOOD, THE SERVICE, IS 2ND TO NONE ????????????????✝️??♥️
Best pizza and appetizers. Friendly atmosphere great service good prices
I ordered a small pepperoni pizza and it took 30 minutes to get it and there were only 5 pieces of pepperoni!! Wth? I spent way too much money on a custom made pizza and I could have gotten a lot more from Mellow Mushroom or Marcos! Never going back! I am saddened that a locality owned company didn’t do better.
Family owned and operated New York style pizza is extremely good, as is the other menu options. By far our favorite pizza place!
Love this place. They are closed on Monday and dealing with staffing issues like all other small businesses. My entire family is from New York, and all of them love this place. You can walk in and grab a lunch special two pieces of pizza and a drink for like $6. They're friendly, it's clean, and they really make you feel like they want your business. One of my favorite lunch spots