I think their salads are very good their subs are OK unfortunately for me I don’t care for the lasagna or the spaghetti prices are very reasonable the restaurant is clean and the service is very nice
Robert Mueller
I love eating local.Old Guy's Italian is just great.The food tasted fantastic.The prices were reasonable.The restaurant was clean.The gentleman that served us was very friendly.I am in town frequently for work. I will definitely be eating here again.I know it's nestled in a part of town that may be considered "the bad part" but I highly recommend giving this place a try regardless.
George S.
We're originally from Chicago and since moving to Sumter, we've struggled to find a decent pizza like we used to get. We're not huge fans of nationwide pizza chains, so we decided to try Old Guy's and boy, am I glad we did! The pizza was fantastic. The Fried Mushroom appetizer was delightful as well. The restaurant was clean and pleasant and the staff was extremely helpful. An all-around top-notch experience. We will definitely be back! The only thing I would change on our next order is that I will ask them to party-cut the pizza (smaller square pieces) instead of the larger pie cut. But that doesn't affect the taste or quality of the food one bit.
Victoria
Always tastes great and has amazing customer service
Tyler Bench
Pasta was bad and gave me food poisoning.
Cynthia Spinella
Real authentic Sicilian cooking at its best. They really know what they are doing here. Highly recommend anyone vusiting Sumter SC to stop in and try the delicious food.
Robert Coleman
Take out or eat in, you can't go wrong here. Consistently excellent
Dwain B
Great service and the food is good.
Charles Salvatore
Did a pizza review on this place crust was amazing but something was very very salty so I asked them if they wanted to remake the pie and after 10 min of waiting the owner was very very rude dont waste your time here rated 2.4 on crust alone
Lori Aamold
We really enjoyed going to Old Guy's for Sunday dinner. The food is great and the prices are very reasonable. They are also very friendly and the service was exceptional.We both liked the spaghetti with sausage and meatballs as well as the lasagna. I would definitely recommend going to Old Guy's for a family dinner. The atmosphere isn't what you would think of for "date night".
This spot probably has the best wings in Sumter, South Carolina. It was truly a great experience overall, the staff was very friendly to all. Dining in during this ongoing pandemic didn't veer us away either, as the tables and chairs were cleans and necessary precautions were taken. 10/10 experience!
Donna Gacek
Great spaghetti and salads. Going away full that's for sure.
Dray Welch
This is our favorite restaurant in Sumter and has the best ranch around. And with their menu you can't order anything bad. Any and everything they make is awesome! I give all the stars.
SilverZ350
Got a calzone and was not happy with it... pretty much frozen food quality
t dub
Placed an order for pick up. I was given 15-20 mins wait time. I go to pick up the order 25 mins later,and it's not ready. I ask for an est time because most of the place is closed off and there are several people waiting in a tight area, the young girl was very rude and just told me to wait. Well they can wait for a dollar from me because I wont pay someone to be rude to me
I think their salads are very good their subs are OK unfortunately for me I don’t care for the lasagna or the spaghetti prices are very reasonable the restaurant is clean and the service is very nice
I love eating local.Old Guy's Italian is just great.The food tasted fantastic.The prices were reasonable.The restaurant was clean.The gentleman that served us was very friendly.I am in town frequently for work. I will definitely be eating here again.I know it's nestled in a part of town that may be considered "the bad part" but I highly recommend giving this place a try regardless.
We're originally from Chicago and since moving to Sumter, we've struggled to find a decent pizza like we used to get. We're not huge fans of nationwide pizza chains, so we decided to try Old Guy's and boy, am I glad we did! The pizza was fantastic. The Fried Mushroom appetizer was delightful as well. The restaurant was clean and pleasant and the staff was extremely helpful. An all-around top-notch experience. We will definitely be back! The only thing I would change on our next order is that I will ask them to party-cut the pizza (smaller square pieces) instead of the larger pie cut. But that doesn't affect the taste or quality of the food one bit.
Always tastes great and has amazing customer service
Pasta was bad and gave me food poisoning.
Real authentic Sicilian cooking at its best. They really know what they are doing here. Highly recommend anyone vusiting Sumter SC to stop in and try the delicious food.
Take out or eat in, you can't go wrong here. Consistently excellent
Great service and the food is good.
Did a pizza review on this place crust was amazing but something was very very salty so I asked them if they wanted to remake the pie and after 10 min of waiting the owner was very very rude dont waste your time here rated 2.4 on crust alone
We really enjoyed going to Old Guy's for Sunday dinner. The food is great and the prices are very reasonable. They are also very friendly and the service was exceptional.We both liked the spaghetti with sausage and meatballs as well as the lasagna. I would definitely recommend going to Old Guy's for a family dinner. The atmosphere isn't what you would think of for "date night".
Restaurantji Recommends
This spot probably has the best wings in Sumter, South Carolina. It was truly a great experience overall, the staff was very friendly to all. Dining in during this ongoing pandemic didn't veer us away either, as the tables and chairs were cleans and necessary precautions were taken. 10/10 experience!
Great spaghetti and salads. Going away full that's for sure.
This is our favorite restaurant in Sumter and has the best ranch around. And with their menu you can't order anything bad. Any and everything they make is awesome! I give all the stars.
Got a calzone and was not happy with it... pretty much frozen food quality
Placed an order for pick up. I was given 15-20 mins wait time. I go to pick up the order 25 mins later,and it's not ready. I ask for an est time because most of the place is closed off and there are several people waiting in a tight area, the young girl was very rude and just told me to wait. Well they can wait for a dollar from me because I wont pay someone to be rude to me