You're going to go here for Cheesecake...and that's great. In fact...that's more than great-that's wonderful, amazing, a terrific choice. I highly recommend the chocolate cheesecake and the strawberry cheesecake. Really, the best thing to do is get a sampler with an assortment of minis to try. BUT When you go for the cheesecake pinky promise me you will also try the carrot cake. Can you do that? It's the second best carrot cake I have ever had in my entire existence. The cream cheese frosting was absurdly good. Super tangy and just sweet enough. Everything tastes exceptional and what really knocks this out of the park is their attention to customer service. Without boring you with too many details I'd like to just note that Nicoletto's went above and beyond to "problem solve" for us after a little snafu with a pre-order , and I am equal parts grateful and impressed. It's been 4 days since I ate this carrot cake and I am still thinking about it-it's good.
Nicole B.
We've enjoyed Momma Nik's on several occasions but unfortunately we had a big letdown with a recent order. My husband called and placed an order for a cheesecake for my 40th birthday. When he went to pick it up during normal publicized business hours and it was closed. He called numerous times with no response and the next day also when stated it would be open it was still closed and no answer to numerous calls and a Facebook message. I understand COVID could have an impact on hours but to take an order and then not be open for pick up and not respond to numerous attempts at contact is just unacceptable.
Candice B.
The cheesecake here is so good. Minis, mediums (which you can eat alone if you're feeling the need to binge on something really good), and whole family sizes are available. The whiskey caramel and chocolate chip favors are my favorite.
Chloe T.
Highly recommended the mini cheesecakes. They have crust all the way around. These are good for breakfast with coffee (or really anytime), but they're not good for your waistline!I have never had a cheesecake I didn't really like from here.
Britney T.
My sister and I stumbled upon this cute place when in the area! We were immediately intrigued (huge cheesecake lovers over here!!). We decided to share two of the individual portions of the s'mores and plain with chocolate fudge on top. They were to die for!! Absolutely delicious and so creamy. You can really taste the decadence of the chocolate in the top layer of the s'mores. Can't wait to go back and try their other flavors!
Angie Bragg
Some of the best cheesecake in town &a decent assortment of flavors as well. I will say they will do their best to accommodate last minute orders. My only one thumbs down would be that it's priced a bit high. I would recommend them even though because it's so damn good!
Sarwar Abdullatif
Best cheesecake I’ve ever had!! The triple chocolate one is my personal favorite!
Liza Haroldson
Amazing. Will definitely be back. Owners were friendly. The cheesecake (I had the blackberry) was delicious and the space was pleasant. Nom.
Dave Whipple
Fantastic cheesecake. Kind owner. Well run, cute little shop. Small business done right.
Launa Tidwell
The best cheesecake I’ve ever had. Super friendly staff, cute shop. I can’t wait to try every flavor!
Great selection and pretty good cheesecakes (we give it an 8/10 overall). We've tried maybe 10 flavors now and for favorites my husband loves the triple chocolate and I adore the white chocolate raspberry! There's an espresso one we both highly disliked and threw out due to the heavy and funky chocolate icing swirl on top, but everything else has been worth trying.
Tambra C.
Great selection and pretty good cheesecakes (we give it an 8/10 overall). We've tried maybe 10 flavors now and for favorites my husband loves the triple chocolate and I adore the white chocolate raspberry! There's an espresso one we both highly disliked and threw out due to the heavy and funky chocolate icing swirl on top, but everything else has been worth trying. The only real downside is that its pretty pricey, but I have no idea how much work goes into them so maybe its still worth it? We both definitely recommend trying them regardless.
Chip Hubbard
So my wife and I WERE happy to use them for our wedding. The wedding day went off without a hitch. The only issue that arose was the fact that we ran out of dessert!
Steve Freitag
2 words, Mmm-mmm good! Just a little hard to find but worth it when you do! Wife got this single "slice" of BlackBerry cheesecake. It almost didn't make it home.
Jen Hubbard
We were set on having cheesecake at our wedding. Momma Nik's came to our rescue! Most bakeries we spoke with told us that cheesecake for a wedding wasn't going to be do-able, but Nikki proved them wrong. We had a 9inch round for us & the bridal party & offered mini cheesecakes of varying flavors to our guest. The cheesecake was an absolute hit!!
You're going to go here for Cheesecake...and that's great. In fact...that's more than great-that's wonderful, amazing, a terrific choice. I highly recommend the chocolate cheesecake and the strawberry cheesecake. Really, the best thing to do is get a sampler with an assortment of minis to try. BUT When you go for the cheesecake pinky promise me you will also try the carrot cake. Can you do that? It's the second best carrot cake I have ever had in my entire existence. The cream cheese frosting was absurdly good. Super tangy and just sweet enough. Everything tastes exceptional and what really knocks this out of the park is their attention to customer service. Without boring you with too many details I'd like to just note that Nicoletto's went above and beyond to "problem solve" for us after a little snafu with a pre-order , and I am equal parts grateful and impressed. It's been 4 days since I ate this carrot cake and I am still thinking about it-it's good.
We've enjoyed Momma Nik's on several occasions but unfortunately we had a big letdown with a recent order. My husband called and placed an order for a cheesecake for my 40th birthday. When he went to pick it up during normal publicized business hours and it was closed. He called numerous times with no response and the next day also when stated it would be open it was still closed and no answer to numerous calls and a Facebook message. I understand COVID could have an impact on hours but to take an order and then not be open for pick up and not respond to numerous attempts at contact is just unacceptable.
The cheesecake here is so good. Minis, mediums (which you can eat alone if you're feeling the need to binge on something really good), and whole family sizes are available. The whiskey caramel and chocolate chip favors are my favorite.
Highly recommended the mini cheesecakes. They have crust all the way around. These are good for breakfast with coffee (or really anytime), but they're not good for your waistline!I have never had a cheesecake I didn't really like from here.
My sister and I stumbled upon this cute place when in the area! We were immediately intrigued (huge cheesecake lovers over here!!). We decided to share two of the individual portions of the s'mores and plain with chocolate fudge on top. They were to die for!! Absolutely delicious and so creamy. You can really taste the decadence of the chocolate in the top layer of the s'mores. Can't wait to go back and try their other flavors!
Some of the best cheesecake in town &a decent assortment of flavors as well. I will say they will do their best to accommodate last minute orders. My only one thumbs down would be that it's priced a bit high. I would recommend them even though because it's so damn good!
Best cheesecake I’ve ever had!! The triple chocolate one is my personal favorite!
Amazing. Will definitely be back. Owners were friendly. The cheesecake (I had the blackberry) was delicious and the space was pleasant. Nom.
Fantastic cheesecake. Kind owner. Well run, cute little shop. Small business done right.
The best cheesecake I’ve ever had. Super friendly staff, cute shop. I can’t wait to try every flavor!
Restaurantji Recommends
Great selection and pretty good cheesecakes (we give it an 8/10 overall). We've tried maybe 10 flavors now and for favorites my husband loves the triple chocolate and I adore the white chocolate raspberry! There's an espresso one we both highly disliked and threw out due to the heavy and funky chocolate icing swirl on top, but everything else has been worth trying.
Great selection and pretty good cheesecakes (we give it an 8/10 overall). We've tried maybe 10 flavors now and for favorites my husband loves the triple chocolate and I adore the white chocolate raspberry! There's an espresso one we both highly disliked and threw out due to the heavy and funky chocolate icing swirl on top, but everything else has been worth trying. The only real downside is that its pretty pricey, but I have no idea how much work goes into them so maybe its still worth it? We both definitely recommend trying them regardless.
So my wife and I WERE happy to use them for our wedding. The wedding day went off without a hitch. The only issue that arose was the fact that we ran out of dessert!
2 words, Mmm-mmm good! Just a little hard to find but worth it when you do! Wife got this single "slice" of BlackBerry cheesecake. It almost didn't make it home.
We were set on having cheesecake at our wedding. Momma Nik's came to our rescue! Most bakeries we spoke with told us that cheesecake for a wedding wasn't going to be do-able, but Nikki proved them wrong. We had a 9inch round for us & the bridal party & offered mini cheesecakes of varying flavors to our guest. The cheesecake was an absolute hit!!