I didn’t even purchase anything from here, but the place nexts doors restroom was broken. They let us come in and use it and we’re just SO kind. I wish we had gotten food from here, too!!!
Scottye B.
I have been a customer of the pie shop since it opened in Johnson City and it is delicious. There's not a bad pie in the case or on the counter. The girls working the front are sweet as can be and so welcoming. I only wish the banana cream was year around.
Scott G.
I hadn't been here in awhile but I can tell the pies have gotten really small. A yogurt or a pudding pack is bigger and a lot cheaper! not interested in going back! also the staff was not helpfu.
LL0206
Both the key lime and Granny’s apple are my absolute favorites from here. Whenever I want a sweet treat and it’s pie, Buttermilk Sky Pie never disappoints me. The store associates are always eager to help and friendly. Y’all should check them out and try the Granny’s Apple pie ?Parking: Parking is free and plenty of spaces are available.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Granny's Apple Pie and September's Pie of the Month Caramel Turtle, Key Lime Pie
K. N.
We love homemade pies and couldn't wait to try BSPS. Went in for a pumpkin and they were sold out, so we got a cherry and went home. You can certainly tell the quality of the ingredients and real butter. Howeve, we were disappointed with the taste; which surprised us. At approx $30 for the pie, we expected execellent and was disappointed instead.
Melissa Owens
Ordered and paid for a peanut butter pie a week ahead. Get there to pick it up today and it is sheer chaos and they are out of peanut butter pie?
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Mark Nash
Most awesome pies in the tri cities!!!
Leslie Buchanan Renfro
Ya'll need to check your reviews firstly because the amount of spam is insane. My husband and I make the quick trip from Bristol because I wanted to visit. The staff was rude and it seemed as if we coming at 5:00 on a Saturday was an inconvenience to them. We purchased 4, 4 inch pies and they were not good at all. The peanut butter had an odd flavor that made it inedible. The chocolate was reminiscent of the pies you buy for a dollar in the grocery store. The I-40 tasted like pure karo syrup and we didn't bother with the coconut. Maybe it's because the pies weren't fresh and these were the ones left before closing for a couple of days? Regardless, I hope they weren’t saved to be sold later.
John Cash
Everyone loves PIE! These are homemade delicacies. All of them are delicious.
Elizabeth Wilson
Perfect size mini pies! Hubby tried I-40 and I tried strawberry, and we’re both pleasantly surprised how yummy these pies are. We are visiting the area for a short time & will definitely be back to try some other flavors. They also carry Meg’s Macs, which I confirmed after I’d left but next time I’ll be sure to get some because they’re some of the best macs we’ve had!
Bought 2 pies. The key lime was okay, tho a little too sweet but the strawberry was terrible. For $30 a pie, I expected much more. Strawberries were definitely not fresh. Like eating a sugary pure tasteless paste. Tried calling and emailing to return, no response after 1 week.
Mike Oswalt
The I-40 is by far the best pie!
James Reyes
I love this place like I love trashy reality TV. Mostly in secret, so people don't judge me on how passionately I enjoy it. The pies are amazing and the staff super helpful.
Shelby C.
We just stopped by this yummy spot. From the moment we opened the door we knew we were in the right spot. The smells coming from this shop will make you instantly hungry. We passed by the shop the other day but didn't have time to stop so I'm really happy we went back today. Our pies (chocolate chip, lemon and peanut butter) were absolutely delish and our interaction with whom I'm assuming is the owner was so heartwarming. My youngest daughter was having a rough morning after a drs check up so we figured a tasty treat would cheer us all up. We are definitely coming back and I'll be dreaming of these pies until then.
Paul Compton
We went to TN for a family weekend. We were going to stop by and try a pie and forgot. When we got home, my wife ordered a pack of mini pies. They showed up at our doorstep a couple days later. These little pies are excellent and don’t let their size fool you, they’re so filled with rich goodness, you’ll be completely satisfied!
I didn’t even purchase anything from here, but the place nexts doors restroom was broken. They let us come in and use it and we’re just SO kind. I wish we had gotten food from here, too!!!
I have been a customer of the pie shop since it opened in Johnson City and it is delicious. There's not a bad pie in the case or on the counter. The girls working the front are sweet as can be and so welcoming. I only wish the banana cream was year around.
I hadn't been here in awhile but I can tell the pies have gotten really small. A yogurt or a pudding pack is bigger and a lot cheaper! not interested in going back! also the staff was not helpfu.
Both the key lime and Granny’s apple are my absolute favorites from here. Whenever I want a sweet treat and it’s pie, Buttermilk Sky Pie never disappoints me. The store associates are always eager to help and friendly. Y’all should check them out and try the Granny’s Apple pie ?Parking: Parking is free and plenty of spaces are available.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Granny's Apple Pie and September's Pie of the Month Caramel Turtle, Key Lime Pie
We love homemade pies and couldn't wait to try BSPS. Went in for a pumpkin and they were sold out, so we got a cherry and went home. You can certainly tell the quality of the ingredients and real butter. Howeve, we were disappointed with the taste; which surprised us. At approx $30 for the pie, we expected execellent and was disappointed instead.
Ordered and paid for a peanut butter pie a week ahead. Get there to pick it up today and it is sheer chaos and they are out of peanut butter pie?
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Most awesome pies in the tri cities!!!
Ya'll need to check your reviews firstly because the amount of spam is insane. My husband and I make the quick trip from Bristol because I wanted to visit. The staff was rude and it seemed as if we coming at 5:00 on a Saturday was an inconvenience to them. We purchased 4, 4 inch pies and they were not good at all. The peanut butter had an odd flavor that made it inedible. The chocolate was reminiscent of the pies you buy for a dollar in the grocery store. The I-40 tasted like pure karo syrup and we didn't bother with the coconut. Maybe it's because the pies weren't fresh and these were the ones left before closing for a couple of days? Regardless, I hope they weren’t saved to be sold later.
Everyone loves PIE! These are homemade delicacies. All of them are delicious.
Perfect size mini pies! Hubby tried I-40 and I tried strawberry, and we’re both pleasantly surprised how yummy these pies are. We are visiting the area for a short time & will definitely be back to try some other flavors. They also carry Meg’s Macs, which I confirmed after I’d left but next time I’ll be sure to get some because they’re some of the best macs we’ve had!
Restaurantji Recommends
Bought 2 pies. The key lime was okay, tho a little too sweet but the strawberry was terrible. For $30 a pie, I expected much more. Strawberries were definitely not fresh. Like eating a sugary pure tasteless paste. Tried calling and emailing to return, no response after 1 week.
The I-40 is by far the best pie!
I love this place like I love trashy reality TV. Mostly in secret, so people don't judge me on how passionately I enjoy it. The pies are amazing and the staff super helpful.
We just stopped by this yummy spot. From the moment we opened the door we knew we were in the right spot. The smells coming from this shop will make you instantly hungry. We passed by the shop the other day but didn't have time to stop so I'm really happy we went back today. Our pies (chocolate chip, lemon and peanut butter) were absolutely delish and our interaction with whom I'm assuming is the owner was so heartwarming. My youngest daughter was having a rough morning after a drs check up so we figured a tasty treat would cheer us all up. We are definitely coming back and I'll be dreaming of these pies until then.
We went to TN for a family weekend. We were going to stop by and try a pie and forgot. When we got home, my wife ordered a pack of mini pies. They showed up at our doorstep a couple days later. These little pies are excellent and don’t let their size fool you, they’re so filled with rich goodness, you’ll be completely satisfied!