I'd give it more of a 7/10.Cheese Pizza+Cheese Bread to give a good review of the bases of pizza.0 - Taste was okay, but it didn't bring much flavor to the pizza. Very chewy with near no crisp. I arrived 3 minutes after estimated 40min time the email gave me, so that could have affected the crisp level.0 - Tasted like a basic pre-made sauce. A little bit of that can taste to it. Quite acidic.Cheese: 8/10 - Cheese had decent flavor. It did break down and oil broke out from overcooking. Common issue, though, so not taking much off for that.For the price point and location with limited competition, it'll do for basic pizza. Would work with beer and a game.But I wouldn't go out of my way for it. I've honestly had Little Caesars (on a good night) that was better.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Bread
Am-Berlyn Salinas
It's been 22 years since I've eaten here and since I was working near by I thought I'd visit Castrillos again. I'm so glad I did. Still absolutely phenomenal pizza. I've missed the food. Thank you for still being open.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Kitchen Sink Supreme Pizza
Andrew Barger
Castrillos has become my favorite pizza place. No dine
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Daniel Ferro
One of the best BBQ chicken pizzas I’ve ever
Food: 5
Kamerine S.
Prices are high for little food, weird ambiance, not nice service, portions are small
Mel
I understand you have humans working there but the humans shouldn't have let that leave the kitchen. We can go back n forth but the reason I didn't post photos from the beginning is bc I was in a terrible place and was so disappointed in everything from that day/night I simply did not want to get up and take the photos. I will delete my review so the 4.5 million + views I have on all of my other reviews don't see this. I am sorry but that food shouldn't have never left your establishment.Edit: If the owner likes to be rude on the reviews, then here are photos of the terrible food. What was I to do? Call, complain, yall remake the food and spit in it or do something nasty to it. No, thank you.I have been ordering food from Castrillo's for many years when I lived in East Nashville for 8 years. It was always delicious. It's been maybe 2 years since I have gotten food from here. While taking care of a friend's home, I ordered a calzone and cinnamon sticks. Both were absolutely terrible. The calzone was overcooked, the sauce tasted gross and the cinnamon sticks was overcooked as well, it was hard to even get a bite of one stick and it was covered in so much cinnamon one could almost suffocate on it. I was so disappointed that I will NEVER order from here again.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Elizabeth King
The food was delicious. There is no dine in anymore and no plates. I would definitely eat here
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cameron V.
We love their pizza and their service. Great neighborhood spot with delicious pizza and great people working there! Get the bbq chicken pizza!
Timothy T
First time here. Great pizza. Got a thin crust Supreme, was not disappointed.
Kayla G.
Amazing staff! Absolutely wonderful customer service here. They are so incredibly kind. Pizza is phenomenal as well!
My favorite local pizza place in Nashville. Check out the daily carry out deals! The staff are also really nice.
Cameron Murray
This place wouldn’t know a thin crust if they ordered one from Domino’s.
Food: 1
Bettie Renda
Ordered meat lovers pizza! The best we have had. Flavorful, cooked perfect. The crust was seasoned and so yummy, and I never eat the crust on other pizzas!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers Pizza
Corie Prater
It has been over a decade since I've eaten here and the baked spaghetti and meatballs are just as delicious as I remember! The service was amazing, the food was amazing. My small person who doesn't eat pizza crust ate the entire slice, crust and all! Thank you for an awesome birthday meal!Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly! I mentioned it was my daughter's birthday and they were so excited to pull out the box of stickers that are for kids (regardless of birthdays).
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Donna Suter
Don’t get over there a lot since moving, but so worth the trip when we can! Had a meaty pizza & wings today & they were absolutely delicious!
I'd give it more of a 7/10.Cheese Pizza+Cheese Bread to give a good review of the bases of pizza.0 - Taste was okay, but it didn't bring much flavor to the pizza. Very chewy with near no crisp. I arrived 3 minutes after estimated 40min time the email gave me, so that could have affected the crisp level.0 - Tasted like a basic pre-made sauce. A little bit of that can taste to it. Quite acidic.Cheese: 8/10 - Cheese had decent flavor. It did break down and oil broke out from overcooking. Common issue, though, so not taking much off for that.For the price point and location with limited competition, it'll do for basic pizza. Would work with beer and a game.But I wouldn't go out of my way for it. I've honestly had Little Caesars (on a good night) that was better.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Bread
It's been 22 years since I've eaten here and since I was working near by I thought I'd visit Castrillos again. I'm so glad I did. Still absolutely phenomenal pizza. I've missed the food. Thank you for still being open.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Kitchen Sink Supreme Pizza
Castrillos has become my favorite pizza place. No dine
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
One of the best BBQ chicken pizzas I’ve ever
Food: 5
Prices are high for little food, weird ambiance, not nice service, portions are small
I understand you have humans working there but the humans shouldn't have let that leave the kitchen. We can go back n forth but the reason I didn't post photos from the beginning is bc I was in a terrible place and was so disappointed in everything from that day/night I simply did not want to get up and take the photos. I will delete my review so the 4.5 million + views I have on all of my other reviews don't see this. I am sorry but that food shouldn't have never left your establishment.Edit: If the owner likes to be rude on the reviews, then here are photos of the terrible food. What was I to do? Call, complain, yall remake the food and spit in it or do something nasty to it. No, thank you.I have been ordering food from Castrillo's for many years when I lived in East Nashville for 8 years. It was always delicious. It's been maybe 2 years since I have gotten food from here. While taking care of a friend's home, I ordered a calzone and cinnamon sticks. Both were absolutely terrible. The calzone was overcooked, the sauce tasted gross and the cinnamon sticks was overcooked as well, it was hard to even get a bite of one stick and it was covered in so much cinnamon one could almost suffocate on it. I was so disappointed that I will NEVER order from here again.
Food: 1
Service: 1
The food was delicious. There is no dine in anymore and no plates. I would definitely eat here
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
We love their pizza and their service. Great neighborhood spot with delicious pizza and great people working there! Get the bbq chicken pizza!
First time here. Great pizza. Got a thin crust Supreme, was not disappointed.
Amazing staff! Absolutely wonderful customer service here. They are so incredibly kind. Pizza is phenomenal as well!
Restaurantji Recommends
My favorite local pizza place in Nashville. Check out the daily carry out deals! The staff are also really nice.
This place wouldn’t know a thin crust if they ordered one from Domino’s.
Food: 1
Ordered meat lovers pizza! The best we have had. Flavorful, cooked perfect. The crust was seasoned and so yummy, and I never eat the crust on other pizzas!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers Pizza
It has been over a decade since I've eaten here and the baked spaghetti and meatballs are just as delicious as I remember! The service was amazing, the food was amazing. My small person who doesn't eat pizza crust ate the entire slice, crust and all! Thank you for an awesome birthday meal!Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly! I mentioned it was my daughter's birthday and they were so excited to pull out the box of stickers that are for kids (regardless of birthdays).
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Don’t get over there a lot since moving, but so worth the trip when we can! Had a meaty pizza & wings today & they were absolutely delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mild, Meat Lovers Pizza