I Love Donuts

601 N Main St C, Shelbyville
(931) 685-1200

Recent Reviews

Brent Knott

Best donuts, kind and humble people. The old fashioned, rich, yeast donuts with crusty glaze.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Linda W.

Looked yummy. Very clean with friendly, local staff who told us the history of this busy place. Lots of pre-ordered boxes piled on the pick-up table. It all looked and sounded so promising. However, after sampling a dozen various donuts, unfortunately, our expectations were not met. Edible but almost bland. Their chocolate was almost vanilla. There was not even a teaspoon of cream in the cream filled. No chunks or even bits of apple in the apple fritters. Almost a whole teaspoon in the jelly filled. The search continues...

Nash W.

Surfing for a local donut shop that actually makes their own variety of donuts is a challenge now a days. This place had great pictures and I had to try it. Entering, the staff was extremely friendly and welcoming. I heard a little about the history of the shop and the occupants. I was able to get a dozen donuts for just under $15. A bit more than I expected....for what I saw. I sampled the pigs in the blanket and they were good. Fresh and warm..... Getting back to my place I sampled both old fashions, maple and glazed. All small, decent and fresh. The apple fritter was a disappointment as I'm not sure I ever tasted a piece of apple. The cream filled as you can see by the pictures was a huge disappointment. The cream that is there was good.... Just very very short supply. The jelly filled was almost as bad. Let me help here..... when it says "Filled" FILL THE DONUT! How hard is that?? Comparing to Peterson Donut Corner, which is my go-to place, is a tough bar to reach. I'd say this store was worth a trip if you're looking for small fresh donuts and a friendly staff. If you're hoping it will be the next best thing? Not so much......you'll be disappointed as I am. Unfortunately most of these will not be eaten. I would have been better off just getting a glazed or two....

Diana Medley

They always have the freshest donuts will keep going back to get there donuts

Lee Dawn

Donuts were good but cold, the lady who served us also felt a little cold. She offered to warm up everyone else's breakfast who was ahead of us, she was also starting at us a lot, and we felt rushed also, could work on customer service a little. Editing to reply: there were only two people ahead of us and we were the only ones in the store when we were being helped so I don't think us being rushed out and being given a rude tone is appropriate either way, if I go again I'll make sure to ask for my things to get warmed up though, that one is on me.

Rachael Thompson

Most amazing donuts!!!!! Soft and perfectly glazed. Not too much glaze were you can't taste the sweet savory fried dough. Just enough glaze to make it just enough sweet. Amazing. Dunkin has nothing on these.....

Angela P.

I visited at 10:00 am and the chocolate covered glazed donut tasted like it was days old - so bad I almost took it back in for a refund but instead I just threw it away.The glazed donut was fresher, but still not very good. This was my first visit and I would not return to or recommend this business. I gave them one star only because I couldn't post this review with no stars. The one star is truly a gift.

Shane Park

I missed my hometown donut and walked in then realised the taste a few thousand miles away. Sausage donut

Dennis Wholey

Apple fritter was no apples, the cinnamon twist I bought the roll and twist, sometimes was off how their fried... wont be going back..

Nicole Sullivan

Came here for the first time today, and I’m blown away. The staff is so friendly, and they have a great selection of donuts. Definitely going to be a regular here now. If you haven’t stopped by here yet, I highly recommend it!

John P.

Sometimes the donuts are fresh, sometimes the apple fritters are stale. Sometimes you get sick for a few days after eating pigs in a blanket. Sometimes 8 bucks for a small stale apple fritter and two small P-in-B is too rich for my blood. Gonna have to step up your game to get back in my good graces. God may not be through with you, but I am. I Don't Love Donuts!

Lesli Fitzgerald

This is by far the best donut place that I have been to in my whole life! And will continue to go back<3

Johnna Nicole

Came here for the first time today, and I’m blown away. The staff is so friendly, and they have a great selection of donuts. Definitely going to be a regular here now. If you haven’t stopped by here yet, I highly recommend it!

Annette Sweeney

They have the best donuts and pigs in a blanket.The staff are always so kind and courteous.

Missie Ross

Amazing customer service and wonderful donutsGreat experience with the employees and donuts all together ? plus experience

Load More