Johnny's Italian Steakhouse

19333 David Memorial Dr, Shenandoah
(346) 331-2060

Recent Reviews

Mike Rentfrow

Very nice intimate dining. Great service. Food was very good. Portions were generous. The presentation was also very good. Our waiter, Phillip, was excellent. The lasagna was very good with a generous amount of meat in it. Thank you.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Créme Brulee

Vijcha Roongruangmanirat

Food was good but the price was quite expensive. Service was ok but comes with multiple mistakes, repeats and confusions. Menu has two prices. The private table we got was ok but felt cramped

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 3

Rob Zelinka

Went for brunch, it was nice. Only complaint is when you spend $55 a person a tea or coffee should be included

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Charles Pearson

Awesome place up until about a year ago . Prices way too high charging $69.00 for a bone in ribeye. So many other options, and BTW bartenders can't make a decent cocktail. No more Johnny's for friends and family, unfortunately.

Sian Gray

I took my son out for a great meal based on online recommendations. When we pulled up, I was a little concerned that it was a hotel restaurant. Trust me, there was nothing to be concerned about. Food is great!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Adam Schmitt

The customer service was excellent, and the complimentary bread was a nice touch. The menu offered a decent variety of common options, with a focus on meats.I tried the MINESTRONE soup, which had tender meat but the vegetables needed more cooking, and the dish lacked something.For the CHICKEN PROSCIUTTO, priced at $25, it contained more bacon than expected from the description. The chicken was slightly tough, and the pasta was overcooked. I had to add cheese, salt, and pepper to enhance the flavor.The kids' meal was fairly sensible value, but the spaghetti was too soft, and the tomato sauce tasted like it was from a jar and not as fresh as desired.Overall, it fell short of the quality I expect from good Italian cuisine.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 5

Michael Newell

Awesome Service! Avril took great care of us and Luis was great with recommendations ! Stayed for a couple days and will definitely be back again. Fun times and great conversations with the staff.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tracey Schneider

We went for lunch. Atmosphere & service are excellent. We tried the Monte Cristo & were disappointed. Cheddar's has the best Monte Cristo. The fries served at Johnny's were awesome! Would go back, but would try something different on the lunch menu.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

kevin katc auto

Very good food, margaritas and cold beer were

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Mashed Potatoes

Love and War

The food is great but it's overpriced and there are roaches.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 5

Ron Raymaker

Always great service and food!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Aaron Santoro

Went here for Valentine’s Day dinner and was pretty disappointed. We made the reservation about a month in advance and were never told that it was going to be a preset menu. The portions were ridiculously small. We had to stop at a drive through on our way home because we were still so hungry.. We also were there for under an hour for a “5 course meal” because the waitress was rushing us through the dinner.. not how I wanted my Valentine’s Day dinner to go at all.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

The Stan Team

We have had great experiences in the past. Tonight we had the valentines experience-a 5 course set menu for $65 each. Portions were tiny and the value just was not there. Some of the options available were misses. Course 1: bruschetta was a single slice. Course 2: our group tried the tuna tartare, baked oysters and watermelon salad. All were ok, but nothing amazing (and again, very small portions). Course 3: a small drink to cleanse the palate. It was nice. Course 4: Salmon portion was small and had little flavor. Filet mignon was tiny (maybe 3 oz) and pre-sliced so unsure if it was even filet. Course 5: Crème brûlée was tasty.We enjoy the restaurant and will be back, but not for a set menu (overpriced for what we got)

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

chilly162

Disappointed that we were not told in advance that it would be a pre set menu. Portions were insultingly small and our waitress was acting she wanted us to be in and out as fast as possible. We were there for 1 hour for a “5 course meal”. Didn't come close to the value that we paid for.

Disappointed

We went for Valentine's Day. They offered a special menu. We were disappointed that we couldn't order from the regular menu but it was ok. The food on the Valentines menu was just ok. Portion sizes were ridiculously small. I got the ravioli and there were only 3 on the plate. The bruschetta was a very tiny one, although tasty. For the price charged, we should have gotten more than 3 ravioli. Price to product ratio was outrageous.

Load More