Mr Gatti's Pizza

4526 S Broadway Ave, Tyler
(903) 944-7777

Recent Reviews

KoopaSlayer

Went to try this place out for the first time on a Monday just to find their doors locked and closed. Won't be giving it a second chance no reason to be closed on Mondays. Try Marcos pizza instead

Alicia Delgado

First time coming here and will definitely come back again. Probably for my son's 10th ?.

Nicole Brittany

I was dreading to come in here because we are from Amarillo and the Gattis there is beyond horrendous! We walked into this location, greeted promptly with friendly and happy employees. The store is very clean, great food, and very impressive!! I can’t wait to come back!!!

Cynthea Nichol Crowder

other than like 4 or 5 games being out of order it was good. food wasn't great, but we had a great time overall! prolly should always have prizes in stock. the shelves looked quite low.

Rebecca Mowery

The pizza was fresh but didnt taste very good. The ranch was very watered down, the cheese tasted funny. They didnt have many prizes to choose from for the kids but candy.

Ashlee Price

A lot of the games were down. Pizza was.. Different. The taste is unique. Im not sure what it is but we weren't big fans. Mac and cheese and salad was all we wound up eating. Then I got sick about an hour later. Not sure if the two are connected but it seems to be a food poison type sickness..

Ana Nymous

It was fun I really loved the arcade and we loved the buffet it was just a great place to go and hangout at

Anquishae Oliver

This location is the absolute worst buffet is horrible you have to ask for fresh pizza salad looks bad… the game room is small and not even half of the games work! It’s not even worth the money I seriously wouldn’t waste my money here ever again!

Jonathan Ortiz

Has to be the worst pizza I’ve had. Not trying to be rude but it’s just my honest opinion. Stale, cold, too much sauce, falling apart. Buffet was hardly stocked, it tasted like school pizza. I would recommend going to Ken’s over Gatti’s.

Phillip Alt

Cost me 38.02 for old pizza,desert cinnimon pull apart was so hard I couldnt eat it. Salad bar was a mess and poorly stocked. I will not be back. Hardly any pizza on Buffet. Very disappointing. July 17th 4:45 pm. Wont be back.

Steven C. Fountain

They aight! Dallas was cool. #Skating

Gerald Andries

Staff was friendly ,the salad bar is nice, and custom order pizzas for buffet , had a great lunch

Wendy Erskine Silvey

Pleasant, hardworking and friendly employees! Thanks for hosting our Paint Party! Great buffet and salad bar too.

Diana Alamos

We went today it had been 2 years since we last ate at Gatti’s .. and we were very disappointed the Sauces they had for the pasta we’re almost empty and dry.. they only had about 12 costumers there and about 6 or more employees working lots of dirty tables restroom were very dirty . 2 years ago we had celebrated my daughters birthday there and we liked it.. but after today we will never go back or even celebrate a birthday there ! Lol

Amy Elizabeth Baldwin

We have been to Mr. Gatti's Pizza several times and it is great! The food is great and the service has always been helpful. For someone who is in a wheelchair, it is a huge advantage. Trust me, I speak with a lot of experience!The tables are spaced out just right. So that makes it easier to get a chance to sit down and talk or to eat a meal! ...After the pandemic hit, most people would avoid going out to eat. But it is ok, I am excited to have the opportunity to get out and enjoy the town. ...

Load More