Antica Sicilia

3300 South 2020 East, Millcreek
(385) 202-7236

Recent Reviews

The food was incredible. Absolutely on point with flavor for the appetizer, salad, carbonara, and cocktails. Couldn't have asked for better. The only thing that dampened the experience (which is nothing the restaurant can control) was the table of adults (large group) behind us. We were out for our anniversary and naturally just wanted relaxed and chill vibe. The adults w the large group proceeded to get heavily intoxicated and there was a lady cackling the whole time. Now I'm first to say, have your fun. But not so obnoxiously that it disturbs others in a small space. Maybe the restaurant could switch the seating some to house larger parties a little bit away from couples. Just glad the food and service was on point. It made up for the annoyance.

JaredS

First time trying Antica Sicilia, we went based on all the positive reviews. The ambiance was great, the service from Claudio made the dining experience significantly better! We ordered two appetizers, the octopus and the calamari - both were incredible...highly recommend. For primi dish, we got the signature carbonara and the butter and sage ravioli with shaved black truffle...also incredible. We decided to splurge and got some secondi dishes, the Cioppino and the nightly special (salmon baked in a flaky crust with a lemon and caper glaze). The food was more than we expected!! We will definitely be back!

Janely Guzman

Such a beautiful classy restaurant they had live music, they had a dark romantic atmosphere and the server Liz felt warm and attentive to my every need. Even the owner came and greeted us to make sure we were enjoying our meal. We went because of the Carbonara Special but I can see myself going for a special occasion. This is a very fantastic place and I highly recommend it to satisfy the Italian foodie.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stephen Ishihara

Amazing food and

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

London Evertsen

wow just melts in your mouth and great service, i wish there were more Italians working here but it was so nice.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jake S

Always a great experience dining here. Service is fast and attentive - Claudio has great energy and recommendations. The entire staff is extremely accommodating. The carbonara is consistently incredible - come hungry!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bruschetta Sicilia Mia, Our Signature Carbonara

Alex LaValle

We had the BEST experience at Antica. Claudio was a fabulous waiter who very clearly cares about the food, wine, and experience. Everything we recommended was fantastic and it's our new favorite restaurant. Can't wait to go back

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

CoriG

Our server was Claudio and he was amazing! He made our experience so wonderful. They also had live music that was outstanding and really created a beautiful ambience. We will definitely be back.

AndyT

It was our first time at Antics Sicilia and it was wonderful. Great service by Lauren and the rest of the staff. We started with Bruschetta. So fresh. The Carbonara was delicious, as was the wine from Sicily. We finished with the amazing olive oil cake. I highly recommend this gem of a restaurant.

winerdiner

We arrived five minutes early for our reservation and were not seated until 30 minutes later! Difficult way to start. They gave us an appetizer and apologized. Server was efficient and food was good.

Dina Freedman

Claudio is the Ceasar salad master! Seriously the best and most entertaining waiter we have had in years anywhere! He was very friendly and knowledgeable and hilarious. We had no idea this place had table side food prep and went on a whim. He prepared an excellent salad and the carbonara. Our meal was incredible and the desert was delicious too. We will be back! Thanks for making it a fun evening!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tannon Pedersen

Best lasagna I’ve ever had, not even close. The carbonara was fantastic! The Arancini was insane as well, and a table size Caesar salad was super authentic, and probably the best I ever had as well. Best part of the night was we sent back one our in Cheney ball and some leftover meatballs for them to put in a box for us to take home, and the waiter accidentally threw them away and so they gave us new ones, and they gave us a full order of them. Extremely nice and great service. We were not expecting that.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Lasagna

Fernanda De sousa

Today my boyfriend and I decided to have a night out to enjoy our evening off. First time ever and we will definitely come back. Lauren was an incredible waitress and the manager who also showed up and make some recommendations knew what he was talking about. The atmosphere is beautiful, perfect place to have a romantic evening .

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Tiramisu, Octopus, Spaghetti Alla Carbonara Sicilian, Gnocchi Quattro Formaggi Pasta

WA S

We had a fabulous waitress. The Bruschetta E Prosciutto so good. The Bucatini Alla Siciliana and Tagiolini Sicilian Mia which were delicious. We will go back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bruschetta Sicilia Mia

Irene C.

Very eclectic rustic atmosphere! Great drinks, bruschetta was delicious and pasta was amazing. I splurged and got the truffle pasta and it was andante and just perfect. Not too heavy. My husband and several guests with us got the carbonara pasta, their signature dish, which was delicious but on the heavier creamy side. They all loved it! Our waiter was excellent! Very attentive and even played the Italian accent wonderfully! He explained everything so well.

Load More