Classic cupcake bakery. Interesting flavors that will make you explore outside your comfort zone. Great gifts!
J P.
First visit. Little gem locally. Great dessert selection. Yummy cupcakes. Everyone enjoyed.
Hayley M.
This review is for the establishment as a bakery, not an employer of 15 year olds. I've basically given up hope on anyone being competent at their job in this city.. that being said... Wow, are these cupcakes delicious. They are incredibly moist and delicious. This is a preference when eating cupcakes, if you're expecting a dry Costco cupcake, keep looking. I have tasted gourmet cupcakes and crap cupcakes and these are not the best I've ever had but they're definitely up there. Their flavor selection is so, so. Way too many chocolate options. I would like to see some more exciting options like pink lemonade and lemon.. i also think the cupcakes alone are so delicious, they could easily have some unfrosted options. Their frosting is ALMOST too sweet but their balance of flavors is highly impressive. Example, their vanilla squared is almost too sweet but the addition of maraschino is so brilliantly delicious. I will MOST definitely be a returning customer and am truly glad i turned into this parking lot just so my kids could watch the rain...
Scott S.
We've always enjoyed our stops at TSTF! There's not a single flavor of cupcake you can go wrong with! I'm glad they continue to make some of the more popular ones year over year rather than discontinue. I do wish the drink selection inside was a bit more extensive.
Lindsay Liddle
I got 4 jumbo cookies all different flavors: salted Carmel, peanut butter, confetti, and chocolate chip. They were all amazing! My absolute favorite was salted carmel.
L S.
This is an amazing dessert spot. If you are craving dessert the Sweet Tooth Fairy has the best cupcake shake. Period, jump in your car and get one now. You pick out your favorite cupcake and they blend it up in thick ice cream. A perfect combination. If you want something different try their cake bites, cookies or brownies. You will not regret it!
Stephen Smith
This is an amazing dessert spot. The Sweet Tooth Fairy has the best cupcake shake. You pick out your favorite cupcake and they blend it up in thick ice cream. A perfect combination. If you want something different try their cake bites, cookies or brownies. You will not regret it!
TL Black
Sweet Tooth Fairy never disappoints! My boys get the biggest grin every single time I surprise them!If you have not had their sugar cookies, they are amazing! We also really love their salted caramel cookie. My boys were super happy when I picked him up from school and got them a special treat!We went to Sweet Tooth Fairy and had the best time! Their treats are always delicious and Jodie was the best to get a fresh brownie out of the back because of allergies! The Samoa was DELICIOUS! My boys also loved the Kit Kat cookie!The raspberry lemon cookie is DELICIOUS!Tonight for family night we also came here for their delicious cookies! It has the best atmosphere! My kids love me to spoil them by taking them to Sweet Tooth Fairy! This place is the cutest! We loved the cupcakes and ice cream! It is the best treat place in town! There are so many amazing cupcakes to choose from! The staff is amazing!!!The cookies are amazing! My personal favorite is the salted Caramel cookie or the cupcake sugar cookie.Today I tried the raspberry lemonade cookie and it was quite tasty but the Fairyfunfetti is my sons favorite. You can’t go wrong with their yummy treats!We went here again today. You can’t go wrong. Everything in this place is delicious! My kids are growing up right.The cookies were delicious today! What a delicious treat!
Shannon C.
Needed a special cupcake order with only a couple days notice. Sweet tooth fairy delivered and the cupcakes were delicious.
Lularoe Nicole Neff
Stop by for their new BIG COOKIES! ???? we loved the peanut butter and fairy getting ones the best!!!! Lots of yummy chunks and a great BIG cookie recipe!
Sent a message over Instagram and they were very responsive and able to fulfill a gender reveal order the same day. Very kind people operating this store. Thanks so much for being a part of our special announcement!
Miranda Matger
This bakery was amazing from start to finish! I’m in Texas , my kiddo is in Utah. The ordering process was easy & friendly ! They even delivered the cake & sent me these pictures. I couldn’t be more pleased with the design & entire process.
Rebekah Ort
The cookies look delicious and tasted good. The Samoa cookie was very disappointing. It had hardly any flavor. The rest of them were great. We really liked the coconut chocolate chip one, and my girls flipped over the beautiful rainbow cookie.
Breezy
Tried a variety of cookies. They were a little on the dry end. The peanut butter cookie was amazing though!
Bradley Iverson
Ordered 6 German Chocolate Cupcakes for my Dads 80th birthday. They were so dense and dry no one eat more than one bite. Expected a whole like better cake part of the cupcake for a specialty shop. Waste of money too much hype for this small shop.
Classic cupcake bakery. Interesting flavors that will make you explore outside your comfort zone. Great gifts!
First visit. Little gem locally. Great dessert selection. Yummy cupcakes. Everyone enjoyed.
This review is for the establishment as a bakery, not an employer of 15 year olds. I've basically given up hope on anyone being competent at their job in this city.. that being said... Wow, are these cupcakes delicious. They are incredibly moist and delicious. This is a preference when eating cupcakes, if you're expecting a dry Costco cupcake, keep looking. I have tasted gourmet cupcakes and crap cupcakes and these are not the best I've ever had but they're definitely up there. Their flavor selection is so, so. Way too many chocolate options. I would like to see some more exciting options like pink lemonade and lemon.. i also think the cupcakes alone are so delicious, they could easily have some unfrosted options. Their frosting is ALMOST too sweet but their balance of flavors is highly impressive. Example, their vanilla squared is almost too sweet but the addition of maraschino is so brilliantly delicious. I will MOST definitely be a returning customer and am truly glad i turned into this parking lot just so my kids could watch the rain...
We've always enjoyed our stops at TSTF! There's not a single flavor of cupcake you can go wrong with! I'm glad they continue to make some of the more popular ones year over year rather than discontinue. I do wish the drink selection inside was a bit more extensive.
I got 4 jumbo cookies all different flavors: salted Carmel, peanut butter, confetti, and chocolate chip. They were all amazing! My absolute favorite was salted carmel.
This is an amazing dessert spot. If you are craving dessert the Sweet Tooth Fairy has the best cupcake shake. Period, jump in your car and get one now. You pick out your favorite cupcake and they blend it up in thick ice cream. A perfect combination. If you want something different try their cake bites, cookies or brownies. You will not regret it!
This is an amazing dessert spot. The Sweet Tooth Fairy has the best cupcake shake. You pick out your favorite cupcake and they blend it up in thick ice cream. A perfect combination. If you want something different try their cake bites, cookies or brownies. You will not regret it!
Sweet Tooth Fairy never disappoints! My boys get the biggest grin every single time I surprise them!If you have not had their sugar cookies, they are amazing! We also really love their salted caramel cookie. My boys were super happy when I picked him up from school and got them a special treat!We went to Sweet Tooth Fairy and had the best time! Their treats are always delicious and Jodie was the best to get a fresh brownie out of the back because of allergies! The Samoa was DELICIOUS! My boys also loved the Kit Kat cookie!The raspberry lemon cookie is DELICIOUS!Tonight for family night we also came here for their delicious cookies! It has the best atmosphere! My kids love me to spoil them by taking them to Sweet Tooth Fairy! This place is the cutest! We loved the cupcakes and ice cream! It is the best treat place in town! There are so many amazing cupcakes to choose from! The staff is amazing!!!The cookies are amazing! My personal favorite is the salted Caramel cookie or the cupcake sugar cookie.Today I tried the raspberry lemonade cookie and it was quite tasty but the Fairyfunfetti is my sons favorite. You can’t go wrong with their yummy treats!We went here again today. You can’t go wrong. Everything in this place is delicious! My kids are growing up right.The cookies were delicious today! What a delicious treat!
Needed a special cupcake order with only a couple days notice. Sweet tooth fairy delivered and the cupcakes were delicious.
Stop by for their new BIG COOKIES! ???? we loved the peanut butter and fairy getting ones the best!!!! Lots of yummy chunks and a great BIG cookie recipe!
Restaurantji Recommends
Sent a message over Instagram and they were very responsive and able to fulfill a gender reveal order the same day. Very kind people operating this store. Thanks so much for being a part of our special announcement!
This bakery was amazing from start to finish! I’m in Texas , my kiddo is in Utah. The ordering process was easy & friendly ! They even delivered the cake & sent me these pictures. I couldn’t be more pleased with the design & entire process.
The cookies look delicious and tasted good. The Samoa cookie was very disappointing. It had hardly any flavor. The rest of them were great. We really liked the coconut chocolate chip one, and my girls flipped over the beautiful rainbow cookie.
Tried a variety of cookies. They were a little on the dry end. The peanut butter cookie was amazing though!
Ordered 6 German Chocolate Cupcakes for my Dads 80th birthday. They were so dense and dry no one eat more than one bite. Expected a whole like better cake part of the cupcake for a specialty shop. Waste of money too much hype for this small shop.