Pizza is really good there and recommended, service in the restaurant with a particular employee is not welcoming and very rude. However if order the pizza's and no longer go in there. I will never order food in my name because I do believe they might do something to my pizza.
Patrick B.
Really really ridiculously good pizza. Super friendly staff. I'd go there is you're in the area.
Brandon B.
My recent experience at Extreme Pizza left much to be desired. From the moment I placed my order, it was clear that something was off. The person who took my order seemed preoccupied, as getting my name, address, and payment information took much longer than it should have. What really struck me as odd was being asked how much of a tip I wanted to give the driver before the pizza was even made. It felt rushed and unprofessional. As for the pizza itself, I was extremely underwhelmed. The default crust was thin and lacked flavor, the cheese was burned in several places, and the overall taste was mediocre at best. While I can say that I've tried Extreme Pizza, I can also say that I probably won't be trying it again anytime soon. Overall, it was a disappointing experience.
Maggie Flynn
I’m a pizza snob, I’m owning it! A native from Chicago and I like to try pizza whenever I go. New York pizza is good, but this Extreme Pizza was amazing!!! Of course it’s not comparable to Chicago deep dish, so adjust your expectations but keep them high because Extreme’s pizza was delicious, fresh, hot, chewy crush and went all the way to the edge. Yes, I ate the entire individual pizza. Owning that too! It would be a shame if you were in Crystal City and didn’t stop here for a quick bite. Staff were great and price was good considering this is DC-area, so nothing else could beat great food, service and affordable!!! What else could you ask for! Oh, did you notice they have a 4-page beer menu, hello - amazing!!! Who else does that??? Bon appetite!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza with Mushrooms
Jenny H.
If you are dairy free or vegan, Extreme Pizza would be an excellent choice for you! I called in an order and spoke with a very friendly employee and was told my order would be ready in just 10 minutes. We are currently dairy free so appreciate that their crust is vegan and that they offer vegan cheese. It's an up charge of 2 toppings, price depends on the size of your pizza. For the large 14" inch pizza I got, the cheese was an extra $4. It's well worth it because it actually tastes like cheese and is nice and gooey and stringy! They are very generous with the portions as well. We got a custom Hawaiian pizza and added pineapple (canned) and Canadian ham (nice big slices!) for about $25. The pizza was ready, hot and fresh, and was boxed when we arrived. Easy to pay and they take Apple Pay! It was empty when we arrived, probably because it was a really rainy day, but they have plenty of seating. The dining area looked very clean and it looks like a great place for your family to hang out and enjoy a pizza or to meet with your friends. Casual but comfortable.
Sumeyra Tuzuner
Amazing pizza and so easy to order and customers online for take
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Signature Pizza
panicbox34
Delicious and great attentive service, truly, but I recently found out they will not make alterations to the pizza slices even though the pizzas are built and baked in house - they would not remove onions for a friend of mine, nor would they do light cheese. Huge obstacle for a huge amount of people with dietary restrictions. While I am not one of them, I cannot give this restaurant more than two stars with them in mind.
Christopher B
The cozy ambiance, friendly staff, and delicious pizza is a winning combination. The photo of the slice was mouthwatering – definitely a must-visit spot when you're in town. And yes that was considered 1 slice although it looks like 2.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Scott Cowgill
Great service. Good vibe old school pizza n beer. Good pizza Good cheese.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dalal H.
Certain pizzas here are exceptional, others can be a bit average, wings are meh. But the poltergeist (sp?) pizza with alfredo sauce is addictive and is the main thing we keep ordering. The inside of this spot is small and simple, we always just do carryout. I would definitely recommend trying their different pizzas as the flavors and quality are certainly there.
Very satisfying pizza. We choose it over and over again versus many other options. Efficient delivery service. Rarely makes mistakes. Salad sometimes is hit-or-miss. We prefer delivery or takeout, but they do have a little bar area and a small section of tables if you want to eat right there.
Joe C.
Meh. Its ok. Not much more than that. Chewy, i like mine with a slight crisp. Service was a little less than meh. Staff seemed annoyed if you asked for a refill of beer much less water.
Sancho Hater
The pizza is actually better than average, I enjoy the Kickin' Chicken specialty pizza on occasion. Extreme also boasts an impressive beer selection; both on-tap and bottle/can. The bone-in wings are good but take way too long to make. My only real complaint is that one of the employees may engage in illicit sexual activities with your significant other. The employee seems to be a nice person but is really a lying, backstabbing, homewrecker. They are capable of staring you straight in the eye like they are your friend, but will continue to cheat on their partner with your partner.Oh, and they sometimes close early.
Pizza is really good there and recommended, service in the restaurant with a particular employee is not welcoming and very rude. However if order the pizza's and no longer go in there. I will never order food in my name because I do believe they might do something to my pizza.
Really really ridiculously good pizza. Super friendly staff. I'd go there is you're in the area.
My recent experience at Extreme Pizza left much to be desired. From the moment I placed my order, it was clear that something was off. The person who took my order seemed preoccupied, as getting my name, address, and payment information took much longer than it should have. What really struck me as odd was being asked how much of a tip I wanted to give the driver before the pizza was even made. It felt rushed and unprofessional. As for the pizza itself, I was extremely underwhelmed. The default crust was thin and lacked flavor, the cheese was burned in several places, and the overall taste was mediocre at best. While I can say that I've tried Extreme Pizza, I can also say that I probably won't be trying it again anytime soon. Overall, it was a disappointing experience.
I’m a pizza snob, I’m owning it! A native from Chicago and I like to try pizza whenever I go. New York pizza is good, but this Extreme Pizza was amazing!!! Of course it’s not comparable to Chicago deep dish, so adjust your expectations but keep them high because Extreme’s pizza was delicious, fresh, hot, chewy crush and went all the way to the edge. Yes, I ate the entire individual pizza. Owning that too! It would be a shame if you were in Crystal City and didn’t stop here for a quick bite. Staff were great and price was good considering this is DC-area, so nothing else could beat great food, service and affordable!!! What else could you ask for! Oh, did you notice they have a 4-page beer menu, hello - amazing!!! Who else does that??? Bon appetite!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza with Mushrooms
If you are dairy free or vegan, Extreme Pizza would be an excellent choice for you! I called in an order and spoke with a very friendly employee and was told my order would be ready in just 10 minutes. We are currently dairy free so appreciate that their crust is vegan and that they offer vegan cheese. It's an up charge of 2 toppings, price depends on the size of your pizza. For the large 14" inch pizza I got, the cheese was an extra $4. It's well worth it because it actually tastes like cheese and is nice and gooey and stringy! They are very generous with the portions as well. We got a custom Hawaiian pizza and added pineapple (canned) and Canadian ham (nice big slices!) for about $25. The pizza was ready, hot and fresh, and was boxed when we arrived. Easy to pay and they take Apple Pay! It was empty when we arrived, probably because it was a really rainy day, but they have plenty of seating. The dining area looked very clean and it looks like a great place for your family to hang out and enjoy a pizza or to meet with your friends. Casual but comfortable.
Amazing pizza and so easy to order and customers online for take
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Signature Pizza
Delicious and great attentive service, truly, but I recently found out they will not make alterations to the pizza slices even though the pizzas are built and baked in house - they would not remove onions for a friend of mine, nor would they do light cheese. Huge obstacle for a huge amount of people with dietary restrictions. While I am not one of them, I cannot give this restaurant more than two stars with them in mind.
The cozy ambiance, friendly staff, and delicious pizza is a winning combination. The photo of the slice was mouthwatering – definitely a must-visit spot when you're in town. And yes that was considered 1 slice although it looks like 2.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great service. Good vibe old school pizza n beer. Good pizza Good cheese.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Certain pizzas here are exceptional, others can be a bit average, wings are meh. But the poltergeist (sp?) pizza with alfredo sauce is addictive and is the main thing we keep ordering. The inside of this spot is small and simple, we always just do carryout. I would definitely recommend trying their different pizzas as the flavors and quality are certainly there.
Restaurantji Recommends
Food was extremely mediocre.
Food: 3
Good beer selection and pizza
Very satisfying pizza. We choose it over and over again versus many other options. Efficient delivery service. Rarely makes mistakes. Salad sometimes is hit-or-miss. We prefer delivery or takeout, but they do have a little bar area and a small section of tables if you want to eat right there.
Meh. Its ok. Not much more than that. Chewy, i like mine with a slight crisp. Service was a little less than meh. Staff seemed annoyed if you asked for a refill of beer much less water.
The pizza is actually better than average, I enjoy the Kickin' Chicken specialty pizza on occasion. Extreme also boasts an impressive beer selection; both on-tap and bottle/can. The bone-in wings are good but take way too long to make. My only real complaint is that one of the employees may engage in illicit sexual activities with your significant other. The employee seems to be a nice person but is really a lying, backstabbing, homewrecker. They are capable of staring you straight in the eye like they are your friend, but will continue to cheat on their partner with your partner.Oh, and they sometimes close early.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3